It's not possible to blind the experiment's test subjects. Again, all I'm asking for is the level of critique to be comparable to the strength of the claims. We

It's not possible to blind the experiment's test subjects. Again, all I'm asking for is the level of critique to be comparable to the strength of the claims. We are eager to critique lower stakes claims, but for some reason Haidt typically gets a pass here. All I'm asking for is consistency. I'm not sure how to put this, but effect size and causation are different things. It's a category mistake to compare.