3 ms·
I've never understood these vague hand-wavey claims about it being more important to know when and how to use X or a modified version of X than to be able to im
by dpark 14y ago
I've never understood these vague hand-wavey claims about it being more important to know when and how to use X or a modified version of X than to be able to implement X (here X is mergesort, but could just as easily be some bit twiddling or a TCP connection or just about anything). How can someone simultaneously claim that they understand an algorithm well enough to know when best to apply it (and when to modify it!) and also admit that they can't actually implement it.
If you can't muddle through a basic implementation of mergesort 45 minutes, I can't believe that you are actually in a position to know when mergesort is a good or bad option, and certainly not that you are capable of writing a custom version for some domain-specific needs.
If someone wants to claim that it's simply not necessary to know mergesort, that's a reasonable stance (though I disagree). But to claim to truly understand it without being able to implement it seems like a bit of a fib.