7 ms·
Influential women's tech network shuts down unexpectedly
- gnabgib 3y agoDiscussion: [0] (130 points, 2 days ago, 207 comments). Not sure why they updated the title (yesterday[1], it included the group) [0]: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40081761 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40081761 [1]: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40090318 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40090318
- ChrisArchitect 3y ago[dead]
- labrador 3y agoI can think of several very wealthy tech industry women off the top of my head or tech adjacent women like Jeff Bezos ex-wife MacKenzie Scott, who is known for giving money away. I'm not going to assume these women are cheapskates so it must be some other reason. Maybe some issue with WWC leadership?
- Dalewyn 3y agoThis comment from Slashdot[1] suggests it might be a case of execs taking more in pay than they should. [1]: https://tech.slashdot.org/comments.pl?sid=23296842&cid=64409612 https://tech.slashdot.org/comments.pl?sid=23296842&cid=64409...
- justinko 3y agoOf course that’s what it is.
- klyrs 3y agoMaybe it's just my tech reality distortion field but the CEO making less than $200k/y sounds, if anything, abnormally low. Edit: Savage-Rabbit over on /. said it best: why do you hate capitalism?
- Dalewyn 3y agoI don't hate capitalism, I like it. However, pay scales in accordance with revenue. If you are running red ink (as was the case here) and you can't increase revenue sufficiently, then costs including payroll should be decreased to get back in the black. Multiple executives each taking somewhere around $150,000.00 in pay when you're in the red is arguably too much compensation.
- klyrs 3y agoYeah, that's how capitalism works. Any compensation is too much compensation if you're in the red. You can't sustain a business if revenues won't sustain hiring at market rates. So they shut it down. Duh, capitalism. This budget is such a non-story it's really weird how much attention it's getting. Like, did you actually write out that extremely rounded salary estimate down to the penny and full punctuation just because you want that junior-dev-level salary to look extra big? Why the gimmick?
- Dalewyn 3y agoAre you interested in having a sincere conversation or not? There is an argument to be made that there is plenty of room for reduction in the compensation the executives received in order to get back in the black, along with any other cost cutting measures. That's why I wrote out the six figure compensation. If they felt inclined to just shut down rather than try to make ends meet, that's their prerogative. It doesn't make their decision to shut down any less perplexing, though.
- klyrs 3y ago> If they felt inclined to just shut down rather than try to make ends meet, that's their prerogative. You do understand that the alternative is asking people to work for below-market rates, right? At a non-profit where there will never be an "exit strategy" by law? So you're the boss now, you've got $75k to offer a new CFO. Where do you find a qualified candidate, and why do they want to work for you and not a comparable organization offering twice as much? Sometimes, shutting down is the smart move.
- interpol_p 3y agoThe pay listed in that comment doesn’t seem particularly outrageous for C-level execs in an organization, even a non-profit
- readthenotes1 3y ago"2022 Revenue $3,985,587 - Expenses $4,176,409 - Net Income -$190,822 - Net Assets $3,430,821 Executive Compensation $821,106 Executive compensation as a percent of total expenses 19.7%" That's a pretty hefty fee for a few people.
- abenga 3y agoHow many is "a few"?
- readthenotes1 3y agoContinuing to read for you: "Alaina P. (CEO) - $193,725 Jo Anne R. (President Product & Communication) - $184,085 Samaria R. (Chief People And Inclusion Of) - $169,913 Shanna G. (Chief Program Officer) - $137,760 Lise R. (CFO) - $135,625"
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- mvelbaum 3y ago[flagged]
- rgbrenner 3y agoThat was an interesting article.. but no American associates the word "struggle" with China or the Cultural Revolution.
- Apocryphon 3y agoYeah even in an America with unceasing culture wars and Netflix adaptations teaching people about the Cultural Revolution, “struggle sessions” just sound like such an archaic reference, like something from a Philip K. Dick novel.
- ygjb 3y ago> How about a promoting vision of tech where people who can actually code well instead of virtue signal are promoted, whether they be male or female, instead of promoting this intersectional garbage? I don't know, it probably has something to do with the fact that, despite a rich history of successful women in the industry, they are notoriously under-represented in leadership roles, continue to be passed over for promotion, and face cultural challenges all over the world. But don't take my word for it, go educate yourself?
- mvelbaum 3y ago[flagged]
- Apocryphon 3y agoHave you ever heard of Jessica Livingston
- mvelbaum 3y ago[flagged]
- ghusto 3y agoStop forcing things. I agree that having a diverse workforce is beneficial for everyone, the company, the workforce, and to some extent society, but this isn't the way to go about it. If there aren't any woman to hire in tech roles, find out why that is and tackle _that_ problem. Assuming of course it's a problem, which is an assumption we're sweeping under the rug. Culturally, we're pushing woman away from tech. On the other hand, it is a given in neural science that — oversimplification warning — men like "things", and woman like "people". It's not surprising then that there are more men in work that involves "things". An initiative like this does nothing but foster resentment and push-back. No amount of downvotes will change facts.
- politelemon 3y agoThe initiative you're being dismissive of is what emerged from "find out why that is and tackle _that_ problem". There are systemic barriers in place, which are being ignored because it makes the discussion uncomfortable. That's the purpose of promotional groups. They exist to point out those things and help us move past it. Forget tech for a moment and consider any other civil rights that we take for granted today that we wouldn't have x years ago. If addressing it causes "resentment and push-back" consider reflecting on your own biases first. It is very likely the issue is there.
- janalsncm 3y ago> men like "things", and woman like "people". It's not surprising then that there are more men in work that involves "things" Whenever we encounter broad, overarching theories like this our brains immediately jump to things which might confirm it. Our brains love creating simple rules which explain complex phenomena. But if we really want to understand what is true, we need to think explicitly about 1) what is the hypothesis which is being offered and 2) what counterexamples might there be to disprove it. A theory becomes stronger after withstanding counterexamples, not weaker. So this hypothesis is that the lack of women in tech in the US is fundamentally biologically driven, rather than culturally driven. Put in this way, we should naturally ask the question, are women in all cultures as averse to computers as in American culture? > No amount of downvotes will change facts. I’m with you there. That begs the question: what are the facts?
- Apocryphon 3y agoSkimming WWC's website: https://womenwhocode.com https://womenwhocode.com It looks like this organization provides technical training (or collates such learning resources), facilitates professional networking, provides information on job openings, and self-perpetuates by calling for volunteer participation. Pretty innocuous stuff as far as nonprofits go. You could find this sort of support network probably for any underrepresented demographic in any profession or context- The American Association for Men in Nursing: https://www.aamn.org https://www.aamn.org MenTeach, to promote male teachers: https://www.menteach.org https://www.menteach.org A call for more male childcare workers: https://www.cdacouncil.org/en/published-article/opinion-male-educators-in-the-child-care-workforce/ https://www.cdacouncil.org/en/published-article/opinion-male... No idea why such an entity receives this sort of tiresome culture war pushback. This is America, there are organizations for any cause and identity. We have scholarships for left-handed people and Syrians for President Nixon pins (https://www.hakes.com/Auction/ItemDetail/82487/NIXON-28-NATIONALITY-BUTTONS-PLUS-2-ODD-BALLS-FROM-1972 https://www.hakes.com/Auction/ItemDetail/82487/NIXON-28-NATI...). I feel like this is just a unique facet of the culture, where because individualism is so emphasized, people have to find solidarity in specific identities.
- anonfordays 3y ago>You could find this sort of support network probably for any underrepresented demographic in any profession or context >This is America, there are organizations for any cause and identity. We have scholarships for left-handed people and Syrians for President Nixon pins Those examples you listed, combined, don't get a tenth of the funding that WWC does. Nor do they have the same scale of industry backing. The last link is an opinion piece, not a nonprofit for "underrepresented" groups. >No idea why such an entity receives this sort of tiresome culture war pushback. Because WWC is ideologically aligned [0]; they picked a side in the culture war. [0] https://womenwhocode.com/blog/category/dei-observances https://womenwhocode.com/blog/category/dei-observances
- Apocryphon 3y agoAnd yet, they exist. That's the point. These sorts of groups all exist in one fashion or another. You quibble about the amount of funding involved, but ultimately they all exist within the same framework of interest groups for those who ascribe to certain identities. That is a phenomenon that precedes any such "culture war" observed by a narrow time perspective. It is something that predates de Tocqueville.
- pheatherlite 3y agoAren't we over the whole, 'let's tech everyone to code' fad yet?