4 ms·
Bostrom's Deep Utopia
- karma_pharmer 3y agoBoston writes engagingly, though not concisely. Understatement of the year.
- dotsam 3y agoI recently read Deep Utopia and I found it frustratingly disjointed and inelegant. I kept expecting a big reveal, or a drawing together of the various threads into an unexpected insight, which never came. I agree with the review by Steve Jurvetson, linked at the start of Hanson's review. > My biggest frustration with the book is that he takes over 500 pages to convey what could be more clearly said in well under 50... > there is no high-level organization to the book... > more of a survey of all possible answers versus the much more difficult task of making specific predictions....
- boomskats 3y agoIt's been interesting trying to revisit Bostrom over the last few months. I'm really not a fan of cancel culture, but it does feel much more difficult to consider anything he's ever said without the context of that 'racist provocation' email that recently resurfaced, and the pre-emptive tonedeaf non-apology apology he wrote in response [0]. I know Oxford let him off the hook (it doesn't surprise me as he's a huge asset to them), but his ideas feel that much more like provocative sensationalism now, it's like they're tainted in my head. Kinda puts him in the same category as Jordan Peterson. Also, relevant discussion from a couple of days ago: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40065862 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40065862 [0]: https://nickbostrom.com/oldemail.pdf https://nickbostrom.com/oldemail.pdf
- K0balt 3y agoIdk if you read the actual letter, there doesn’t seem to be any racism in his intention, but rather a caricature of cancel culture that when taken completely out of context reads like a racist rant. It’s unfortunate that we have become so superficial that we cannot see beyond sentence fragments to see meaning. Still, it was an example of thumbing of the nose to the cancel culturista, an act of defiance that apparently wasn’t taken in stride. With the censors, It’s not so much what you say, but rather not speaking in the way that “they” want you to that brings out their ire - you can (and cacelistas often do) say the most racist drivel, but as long as it’s said using the right language, it’s acceptable, even laudable. I have come to think of this faux-left movement as being an effort more to reshape culture by pruning meaning and prohibiting discussion, a mentally lazy revolution that pretends to solve problems by hiding from them.
- boomskats 3y agoI did read the actual letter. Idk if you read my actual comment. Him stating "Blacks are more stupid than whites", and following it up with "I like that sentence and I think it is true", feels unnecessarily offensive, and he doesn't really address that in his apology at all. Saying hurtful things and then trying to intellectualise why they were hurtful, with an apology letter clearly aimed at your academic peers rather than those who your words would have hurt, is not about censorship. It's about not being a dick.
- K0balt 3y agoHmm, I wonder if we read the same letter, since you are leaving the salient parts out. He said some stupid things, as an example of saying stupid things. It was reprehensible, IMO, and exhibited very poor judgment, but his full statement makes it clear his intention was not to imply that one race is genetically superior to another, but rather to say that poor nutrition and socioeconomic conditions lead to suboptimal outcomes and measurable differences in cognitive health. I think that’s a plausible hypothesis, and I think that poor nutrition and socioeconomic conditions are something that a wealthy society should probably be trying to address. I also think that he used some very portly chosen words to make an unimportant, belligerent point… and then that point was roundly made for him by everyone deciding that he must be a racist. And maybe he is, I don’t know, but the contents of that particular letter don’t say that to me, even as objectionable as the parts that you brought out of the full context certainly are. As for not being a dick, he absolutely should be called out for saying dickish, petulant things. But that’s not what happened.
- skulk 3y ago"I think you, K0balt, are a very poor quality person." I like that sentence. I think it's true. But come on, I would never leave a comment starting like that on HN, it would go against the guidelines and be plain rude.
- K0balt 3y agolol. I’m not really sure that’s apples to apples, but if it is close then I would propose that the right thing to follow that up with would be a proper apology for your offensive language. Obviously mr bozo didn’t do that, which makes him either clueless or kind of a dick, and he absolutely should be called out for that. But that’s not what happened.
- ImHereToVote 3y agoI think we should be more critical of intellectuals that spout off things that are obviously and offensively mal-informative.
- aebtebeten 3y ago> Apparently folks in the USSR once wanted to find aliens because they assumed that, as aliens must be very smart, they’d be communists. On the other hand, the conceit of Pandora's Planet (1973) was that the aliens were technologically advanced, but somewhat earnest and honest and dim*, so they encounter earth and get steamrollered by our advertising, conmen, and fads. Fast forwarding half a century, I wonder if a Federation of Planets counterpart would have the memetic antibodies to resist assimilation via gamification dark patterns? * this now seems less plausible to me than it did at the time; I'm guessing a large driver for developing (energy-intensive!) intelligence is spending much of your time around species that indicate one action but intend a different one.
- somenameforme 3y agoIt's all about fertility, reproduction. When intelligence offers a greater chance of fertility, that species will trend towards becoming more intelligent. In the scenario where intelligence starts to become an impediment to reproduction, like exactly what is happening right now with humans, then a species will start to become less intelligent. So for an alien species to succeed, they're likely to need to adopt some sort of ideology that: - Keeps fertility high - Keeps outward motivation up - Protects from pleasure traps Explaining parts 2&3 - imagine we create some sort of virtual device that one plugs in and it just basically gives you endless pleasure. If enough people would be interested in such a device, it could easily destroy a species. A rather odd 'great filter' of the Fermi Paradox. It's a species not going out with a bang or a whimper, but something more like a moan. Similarly, if people are just comfortable enough with what and where they are, then they may not have the motivation to carry out the massive work required to actually explore the stars. Putting these altogether, I wouldn't be entirely surprised if the first intelligent alien species we meet immediately begins trying to convert us to their God(s). Convert all the infidels of the universe seems like one sure fire solution for all the above. It also sets the stage for dystopia for those who choose not to acknowledge the grace of Qzar'dn the Almighty.
- 082349872349872 3y agoThe species with the greatest fertility (prokaryotes) are the least intelligent. (and looking at r-selected vs K-selected species in general the inverse relationship seems to hold: greater intelligence correlates with lower litter size; compare frogs and rats)
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- alt0_ 3y ago> Nick Bostrom’s new tome … has a great cover True, but I wish they went with the Sisyphus one. For context, they did a survey on the cover of the book, and one of them features Sisyphus, on top of the hill, with his boulder. I found it captures the topic of the book quite well.