4 ms·
University exams, this probably makes a lot of sense. After all, the exam is the exam and whether a student is well-spoken and actively participates in class sh
by ghaff 3y ago
University exams, this probably makes a lot of sense. After all, the exam is the exam and whether a student is well-spoken and actively participates in class shouldn't matter for an exam grade. I'm less convinced that blinded conference proposals are a good idea--an argument I've had with various people. If you know based on past experience that someone will almost certainly hit a home run, I'm less inclined to pick a random person without obvious qualifications for the same topic--although just picking friends of the committee can obviously go too far.
- wongarsu 3y agoYou could try to work around that by first grading all anonymized proposals, then grading all potential speakers without knowing their proposal. In the third round you deanonymize and look at the weighted average of the two grades. You probably still need some judgment calls because the combination of speaker and topic can be important. But the score would give you a good base to work of. Maybe you could make it even more impartial by allowing conditional scores in the first two rounds. Like "Jim is a 6, but a 8 if his talk is about molecular biology" or "this Lessons Learnt talk is a 5, but if it's by X, Y or Z it's a 9"
- ghaff 3y agoYeah, but I'm not sure conference proposals by themselves actually have a lot of value given that, in many cases (ask me how I know), the presentations won't actually exist until week or two before the the event. Certainly a talk by X that's totally unconnected from anything they're directly involved with has less value.