3 ms·
One of the challenges Redis labs here have is that there's very little reason for their userbase to stay loyal to them. antirez retired from Redis development
by simonw 3y ago
One of the challenges Redis labs here have is that there's very little reason for their userbase to stay loyal to them.
antirez retired from Redis development a few years ago.
From https://github.com/redis/redis/graphs/contributors https://github.com/redis/redis/graphs/contributors it looks like activity since he left has been mostly from people who didn't overlap with him much.
Redis Labs have not shown themselves to be outstanding stewards of the project as far as I can tell. Why shouldn't people support the fork?
- sdesol 3y agoHere's some additional insights regarding Redis and Valkey https://devboard.gitsense.com/redis?id=f66d8a46ef https://devboard.gitsense.com/redis?id=f66d8a46ef If you ignore comments and just look at people raising issues and pull requests, Valkey has more contributors https://devboard.gitsense.com/redis?id=f66d8a46ef&comments=ignore&nb=all https://devboard.gitsense.com/redis?id=f66d8a46ef&comments=i... Full disclosure: This is my tool
- nijave 3y agoI'm wondering how much of this is related to initial setup and rebranding. Iirc OpenTofu had a 2-4 week surge in PRs just getting builds, infrastructure, and rebranding cleaned up so they could build Terraform on new CI under a new name.
- sdesol 3y agoI would say a lot right now. If you look at contributors with open or merged pull requests https://devboard.gitsense.com/redis?id=f66d8a46ef&comments=ignore&issues=ignore&nb=all&prs=merged%2Copen&files=merged%2Copen&board=gitsense.insights https://devboard.gitsense.com/redis?id=f66d8a46ef&comments=i... Redis has 14 contributors vs 48 for Valkey. I think it is very unlikely that Valkey is adding a lot of new code right now, so the activity is probably related to the rebranding to Valkey.
- nijave 3y agoChangelog line items is probably a better measure (assuming the line items are aligned to features and bugfixes and not just a list of PRs) https://github.com/valkey-io/valkey/releases https://github.com/valkey-io/valkey/releases Maybe version number/release cadence is also helpful.
- sdesol 3y agoI have a metrics called LCMFC (last contribution minus first contribution) which can give you insights into how long people have been contributing for. In a few months, I'll be able to better segment things. I had (and will reintroduce in the future) a contributions insights tab that focused on labels, which I think can also help you understand how things are changing without actually digging into the code.
- devsda 3y ago> Why shouldn't people support the fork? That's a valid question and to be fair to Redis, we should also ask ourselves what are the incentives for Redis (or any other commercial oss) to continue development of truly free and open-source Redis? If the answer is opensource ideals, it is not an honest or realistic answer. If the answer is they can always get paid through hosted offerings and product support, Redis folks are saying that's not a sustainable option because of cloud providers. Redis users fall into broad categories of individual developers, startups, medium level companies and enterprise scale companies. Individual users are unlikely to pay. Enterprise customers are big enough to have dedicated resources for support. It leaves startups and medium level companies. These users are leaving on-premise and moving to cloud providers and if there's a frictionless hosted solution by the provider itself they are likely to prefer that over paying Redis. There are always exceptions but I don't think this is far from reality. If the quip is, Redis should offer a better product, they cannot! Not when competing with cloud provider's own offerings. They will be always be at a disadvantage in terms of total cost(for marketplace products) and resources spent for development of the core product itself. I believe their license changes is about them trying to reduce the impact of cloud offerings. I don't know if there is a better approach for Redis and the community but as users of their product we are also responsible to provide a sustainable path for development and come up with a solution for this common problem. Otherwise, Redis will not be the only product to take this direction. PS: There are exceptions like postgres but there aren't enough of them at that scale.
- _msw_ 3y ago> PS: There are exceptions like postgres but there aren't enough of them at that scale. We need more communities and projects like PostgreSQL. Why can’t Valkey be another one?