3 ms·
What happened? Not enough people applied? Here's the last batch.[1] Gives a sense of what's being funded. Ideas: - MoneyNow - leverages the new FedNow instan
by Animats 3y ago
What happened? Not enough people applied?
Here's the last batch.[1] Gives a sense of what's being funded.
Ideas:
- MoneyNow - leverages the new FedNow instant payment system. FedNow is run by the Fed and transfers money in seconds with a charge of just US$0.045 per transaction. And they mean seconds. If the money isn't there in 10 seconds, the transaction times out.
Few banks support it yet, but some do. It needs consumer-facing support. The Fed just does the back end. There's a big security problem with consumer side payments - these are irrevocable no-holds transfers, like cash. Figure out how to handle that. Competes with Venmo and PayPal; could make them obsolete. Venmo isn't really instant; try to withdraw the money you just "received".
- Reading Teacher - teach illiterate kids to read with a phone app using AI. Text to speech and speech to text all work now. A true automatic reading teacher should be possible. Gamify it so kids use it. Sell to parents, not schools.
- Rust Game Engine - the Rust language ecosystem has some game engines and libraries that almost work, but the open source maintainers got bored and didn't finish the job. Modest amounts of cash would push that over the top. Monetize by selling back-end services for such games.
[1] https://www.ycombinator.com/companies/?batch=W24 https://www.ycombinator.com/companies/?batch=W24
- dang 3y agoNo idea how many people applied but I'm sure there's no lack - I just felt bad for forgetting to put the usual footer at the bottom a month ago. And I worry about the comments I see on HN interpreting YC as just for credentialed-elite applicants. It's deeply not true and I have a personal feeling about the question - being one of the uncredentialed-unelite-self-doubting types who could have been dissuaded from applying if I had been reading comments like that instead of pg's essays at the time.
- juped 3y agoThis is just an empirical question, right? What are the proportions of credentialed elites among all applicants and successful applicants? If this number is surprising, it would mean a lot more to people than any amount of insistence.
- JohnTHaller 3y agoForgetting something like the footer thing happens. Forgive yourself for it. Maybe set a calendar event now for one month out from the next batch. It's how my ADHD brain remembers things. As for the 'uncredentialed' thing, there are a ton of forces at play and I'm sure there will be more credentialed folks applying due to financial and access reasons. I'm an uncredentialed person (state SUNY school) who got flown out for an interview for YC Winter 2020. I didn't get selected due to my proposal itself and shortcomings within it, not due to a lack of any credentials. I enjoyed the experience and learned a bit about it. I may apply again at some point for another venture I'm working on.
- giantg2 3y ago"And I worry about the comments I see on HN interpreting YC as just for credentialed-elite applicants". Eh, I feel like it's partly true but not by design. The people who are smart enough or connected/rich enough to get into ivy league schools are more likely to be able to dedicate resources to an idea or creating a better sales pitch. I would guess that post-grads and ivy league grads are over-represented compared to the population in general or the population of college grads. Of course a good idea can come from anywhere, but I'd imagine the data supports the idea that the odds are better for some groups vs others.
- nullhole 3y agoFWIW you did make me consider it. As others have said, the mere process of writing out an idea means thinking about the idea in a new way, and can lead to new insights.
- choppaface 3y ago[flagged]
- sokoloff 3y agoPeople invent all kinds of reasons to support the path they choose. People with confidence/optimism select data that reinforces their “go for it” decisions. People who want to find elitism as a reason to not do something will be able to that as well. Elitism surely exists in the world, but letting that stop you seems like cutting off your own nose to spite your face.
- andrewmcwatters 3y agoThat's a whole lot of "AI"...
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- sillysaurusx 3y agoUnfortunately the rust game engine idea (as much as it kills me to say this) is a perfect example of not YC material. Every VC, whether early stage or late stage, must fund companies that have a chance of growing by 5% every week. It’s remarkably hard to start anything that can maintain that growth. https://paulgraham.com/growth.html https://paulgraham.com/growth.html is worth internalizing. But there’s a second caveat here: YC invests in people, not in ideas. From pg himself: https://www.ycombinator.com/blog/the-reddits https://www.ycombinator.com/blog/the-reddits > Their idea was bad though. And since we thought then that we were funding ideas rather than founders, we rejected them. But we felt bad about it. Jessica was sad that we'd rejected the muffins. And it seemed wrong to me to turn down the people we'd been inspired to start YC to fund. So it might be worth applying with a particularly bad idea. Or at least it used to be; I have no idea whether YC ever encourages strong founders with a bad idea to re-apply with a better one, or if you get any feedback from the partners that they almost accepted you but rejected because of the idea. (One of my neat memories as a 19yo is getting a thoughtful email from pg saying we almost made it to the interview with an idea that was essentially “blackboard sucks; make better school software," but the biggest factors against us were my age and the fact that selling to schools was about as hard as selling to governments back in 2008.)
- Animats 3y agoI know that. I just threw that in because I've been doing game work in Rust and the graphics stack suffers from too few devs. Better school software is worth another go-round, now that we have large language models. Somebody already emailed me offering to fund the MoneyNow idea. That's a bad idea for another reason. The big problem with money transfer is fraud. PayPal is mostly a fraud-management service. Money transfer and user interface are the easy part.
- sillysaurusx 3y agoI’d be very curious to see what you’d choose to work on if you were forced to pick something with the highest probability of growing at 5% per week minimum. I suspect you have a few ideas, but it becomes a different sort of question when you imagine yourself committing to one for the next 10 years. Which idea could you see yourself throwing all of your effort into growing each week till you’re today+10 years old?
- eddd-ddde 3y agoUnrelated, but they _charge_ you for transferring money??? Is the US ever gonna have true free instant transfers? Without none of this venmo paypal shenanigans?
- ghiculescu 3y agoMost (all?) countries do this. Consumer banking services will offer free transfers as a loss leader.
- bcye 3y agoI think SEPA Instant in the EU is probably free, seeing as EU will require banks to provide SEPA Instant for free to their users (or at the same cost as normal transfers)
- carstenhag 3y agoRight now you do have to pay for it at many banks. Some include it in the monthly cost if they have one. Some just cover it with their marketing costs...
- dustincoates 3y agoThis isn't true: > Contrary to what many believe, SEPA transfers are not entirely free. Sure, most banks do not charge for SEPA transfers, but some banks still do. When there are charges, you pay the same price for a SEPA transfer as you would for a domestic wire transfer. Regulation 924/2009 mandates banks to apply the same charges to cross-border euro transactions as they do for domestic transfers. Banks are prohibited from levying different charges based on the recipient bank's location. Therefore, if your bank in France charges you nothing for making transactions within France, then you will also pay nothing for euro transfers to Portugal, for example. https://www.quanloop.com/en/investing/are-sepa-payments-really-free https://www.quanloop.com/en/investing/are-sepa-payments-real... I was unable to find out what the cost to banks was, but it's possible there is one and it's covered by the monthly fees that European banks charge, which are relatively rare in the US.
- 3y ago
- h1fra 3y agoLast batch had 27,000 applications [1]. I think it's just a moment where VCs have a lot of money to spend after 1-2years of recession, and a whole new market has open with AI (or to say it better, every markets are now open to AI disruption) [1] https://www.ycombinator.com/blog/meet-the-yc-winter-2024-batch https://www.ycombinator.com/blog/meet-the-yc-winter-2024-bat...