3 ms·
As someone who's met the clinical criteria for MDD at various points but later discovered the cause lied in a severely traumatic upbringing, I'm not sure about
by taurath 3y ago
As someone who's met the clinical criteria for MDD at various points but later discovered the cause lied in a severely traumatic upbringing, I'm not sure about pushing TMS on folks when the state of psychiatric care is so poor. Were I the client going thru this treatment, I might have a psychiatrist say I'm a great candidate for effectiveness, but it wouldn't treat the actual underlying causes and may expose me to harm potentially. I am very glad I decided against taking that route.
TMS has a lot of side effects (Seizures, cognitive effects, permanent increases in auditory threshold, tinnitus, headaches) and the overall neurological mechanisms are not, to my knowledge, well known - my interpretation is that its a bit like degaussing a brain. If you have secret sauce, its in studies that aren't public. Assuming its based around studies like this: https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0165178123005589?via%3Dihub https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S01651...
Is it a viable GTM strategy? Maybe - but you may find yourself having every incentive to hype up a procedure that may cause harm, even if legal, which seems like an ethical minefield if not a significant source of liability. If the effects of TMS across the whole nervous system were more well known and side effects could be more easily predicted, perhaps that would be another story.
- giantg2 3y ago"but it wouldn't treat the actual underlying causes and may expose me to harm potentially." There are so mamy people that think depression is just a chemical imbalance that can be solved by treatments and ignore the fact that many times there is a legitimate cause for their valid feelings.
- aidan_tsai 3y agoThank you for your opinion and sorry for the delayed reply. We recognize that the path to mental wellness must be comprehensive and deeply personalized.
- aidan_tsai 3y agoThank you for your candid feedback on TMS and its implications in psychiatric treatment. You've rightly pointed out the complexities and potential risks associated with such therapies. And I agree with you that addresses the root causes of mental health issues, not just the symptoms. While acknowledging the side effects of TMS, including those you've mentioned like cognitive effects and headaches, our research focuses on mitigating these through targeted treatment approaches. Severe side effects are relatively rare, and our goal is to further reduce their likelihood through improved predictive accuracy.