3 ms·
You can see the same principle in a lot of places. This makes me think of a passage I recently read about the legal system in Germany: …Unlike many developing
by Symmetry 14y ago
You can see the same principle in a lot of places. This makes me think of a passage I recently read about the legal system in Germany:
…Unlike many developing countries, German legal doctrine and practice avoid this
result. German regulatory violations seldom void contracts, and German
prosecutors seldom act on regulatory violations revealed in a civil trial. Thus a
gardener in the German gray market who does not pay taxes can sue an
employer for unpaid wages without fear of triggering regulatory prosecution.
And a customer who buys a restaurant meal at an hour when law requires the
closing of restaurants still has to pay his credit card bill. The same applies for a
construction contract that violates zoning regulations, or a credit contract that
violates banking regulations. Although seldom discussed in constitutional law,
separating the civil courts from the regulators and police is an important part of
the separation of powers, especially in countries with a large gray market.
http://marginalrevolution.com/marginalrevolution/2012/05/solomons-knot-and-gray-markets.html http://marginalrevolution.com/marginalrevolution/2012/05/sol...
- rprasad 14y agoThat's generally true of most first world countries, including the US and the UK. Contracts can be broken if they would require an illegal act (i.e., a "crime"), but regulatory infractions generally are not sufficient.