9 ms·
Kleiner Perkins Partner Ellen Pao Sues Firm for Gender Discrimination
- huhtenberg 15y agoTrue Hacker News!
- mwexler 15y agoI suspect it's here because it ties into a) gender issues being a hot topic among developers over the last few weeks here at HN, as well as b) the fact that KP is a power player Silicon Valley and impacts the lives of many startups. Perhaps not developer-oriented, but certainly in line with recent posts here on HN.
- maybird 15y agoIndeed. I hope "brogrammers" take note.
- jdminhbg 15y agoEven if brogrammers existed, they wouldn't be reading legal briefs about sexual harassment cases in VC firms.
- gaius 15y agoSure they do. They just call themselves "Rubyists" or "rockstar ninjas" instead.
- chestercheetaz 15y agoI hope "brogrammers" exist.
- natrius 15y agoI would pay cash money to get people to stop using that term unironically.
- SeoxyS 15y agoYou can be a "brogrammer" and be outraged at this all the same, you know… Your association of brogrammer == sexist is just as offensive and discriminatory as the attitude you accuse all brogrammers to have towards women.
- tomjen3 15y agoI am outraged at this. No company should have to suffer employees doing stupid things like this. If she wants to sue over his behavior, why not sue him? Oh right, who has the most money?
- ebf 15y agoIf the company allowed the discrimination and harassment to occur even after several complaints, why shouldn't they be held liable?
- MartinCron 15y agoI thought that sexist was part of the definition of the "brogrammer" term. It's at least exclusionary.
- sp332 15y agoLearning from others' mistakes is very hackerly.
- drostie 15y agoMaybe. But I upvoted it instead because it reminds us that this happens to people. More precisely: it happens to people who are rich, and people who are poor. It happens to big people as well as small people. Being harassed, and giving in briefly to the harassment in the hope that it will stop, does not necessarily make you weak, and does not stop you from seeking justice afterwards. I don't presume to say whether it's true, just that the story has resonance for those reasons. I hope it reminds someone else in a bad situation to, y'know, break out, blow the whistle. I hope it reminds men who see it happening and who hear these complaints to act on them, to try to speak up against people making openly sexist comments.
- protomyth 15y agoThose were the main reasons I submitted it, with the other being about risks. Office romances have serious risks. No matter who was right or wrong, the initial coverage is going to be painful. The narrative is cookie cutter at this point, and let's face it, with just a filing and the need to push a story out, you really cannot expect anything else. If your business name generates page views then expect a couple of updates as journalists actually read the the full filing. Sadly, you probably just shouldn't do it.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- candre717 15y agoI respect and admire her courage and bravery to do what's right, in light of her career.
- oh_sigh 15y agoYou're jumping to conclusions that she is doing what is right, and isn't either trying to get a pay out, or views her companies actions through a lens of default sexism.
- gaius 15y agoShe's a partner in the firm - the highest rank there is in VC. It's unlikely she would have been promoted to that level if they were all sexists.
- sp332 15y agoDeciding not to promote people is not the only form or expression of sexism.
- MartinCron 15y agoRubbish. Next you're going to insist that racism still exists even though we have a black president.
- sp332 15y agoOr that ageism still exists just because every US president has been over 40.
- natrius 15y agoIsn't that a bit premature? It may be a civil case, but presuming innocence until proven otherwise is still a pretty good policy.
- 15y ago
- staunch 15y agoIt sounds like the senior guys didn't take her complaints very seriously because she had been in a relationship with the guy. It was only when another woman complained about the same guy that they got rid of him. It also sounds like the firm is controlled by men who tend to favor men for promotions and compensation. Ultimately I think lawsuits like this are what will move the industry forward. It forces complacent old powerful men to take young women seriously. Hopefully she gets paid for her trouble and KPCB significantly improves their environment for women.
- oh_sigh 15y agoHow you can determine this based entirely on the complaint? The firm has not had a chance to defend themselves. How do you know they favor men? Maybe there is a bigger pool of talented men than women in this field?
- temphn 15y agoIn the suit, Pao alleges that she was sexually harrassed for years by Ajit Nazre, a former partner with the firm who left last year. The two took a business trip together in February 2006, the suit says, during which Nazre made sexual advances toward Pao and she rebuffed them, causing him to become “brusque and distant.” Nazre continued to pursue Pao and the two had a brief relationship, which she broke off soon after, according to the suit. "And the two had a brief relationship". Wait, so then it wasn't harassment? During that time I'm sure she thought his persistence had paid off. It is all too reminiscent of this satire: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gBVuAGFcGKY http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gBVuAGFcGKY
- brown9-2 15y agoYou seem to have missed this part of the article: but after breaking things off with him, multiple Kleiner Perkins partners and an outside human resources consultant allegedly ignored Pao’s complaints about repeated harassment and retaliation, and rejected her requests to transfer away from Nazre. Having once been in a relationship with a person does not open the door to continued harassment after the relationship is over.
- larrys 15y agoInteresting discrimination lawsuit by her husband last year: http://dealbook.nytimes.com/2011/02/02/the-money-manager-who-is-suing-the-dakota/ http://dealbook.nytimes.com/2011/02/02/the-money-manager-who...
- sriramk 15y agoAlso irrelevant to whether this case has merit or not. Not saying you're implying it does, but I see a lot of commenters on Techcrunch and other places making that jump.
- unreal37 15y agoThe apartment building wouldn't let him buy a second unit, even though he's worth $10's of millions. Something fishy for sure.
- loverobots 15y agohttp://dealbook.nytimes.com/2011/07/12/s-e-c-and-pension-systems-to-examine-fletcher-fund/ http://dealbook.nytimes.com/2011/07/12/s-e-c-and-pension-sys... A few searches reveal that the apt complex may have been right. Something fishy, but in his hedge fund: "The public pension systems were allowed to earn a return in the range of 12 percent to 18 percent, they said in a statement. If the fund earned less than 12 percent, other investors, not the three pension systems, would absorb the losses. As a tradeoff, the pension systems’ agreed to forgo any return above 18 percent." Then there was the case of having pledged $50 million to charity but not actually given them or something.
- larrys 15y agoDakota is a coop. In NYC coops have an absolute right to reject anyone for any reason and often do. Even celebrities and people with tons of money. http://cooperator.com/articles/1450/1/Top-Dozen-Reasons-for-Co-op-Board-Rejections/Page1.html http://cooperator.com/articles/1450/1/Top-Dozen-Reasons-for-... Edit: (Comment below). Where I said "have an absolute right to reject anyone" I meant as long as it doesn't violate a law. This is similar to how a company can refuse to hire anyone for any reason as long as they don't state a reason which is prohibited by law and as long as no evidence to that surfaces.
- lukejduncan 15y agoNever have relationships with people at work. Avoid the ambiguity. You're colleagues. Period.
- xbryanx 15y agoSure, that might be good advice, but such absolutism isn't viable as a workplace system. Research into propinquity (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Propinquity http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Propinquity) tells us that romantic relationships are actually quite likely in the workplace. We should develop systems that handle this less-than-ideal(sometimes) behaviors. One of those systems is anti-discrimination law.
- iy56 15y agoThere was even another recent HN submission in the same spirit: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4005906 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4005906 Smoking is forbidden on airplanes. But if someone does smoke, it's better that they have an ashtray available rather than starting a fire by trying to dispose of the ashes improperly.
- rokhayakebe 15y agoI work in a place, a small one as a matter of fact, where 3 pair of people met and each went on to either get married, or be engaged to each other.
- jarek 15y agoNever sexually harass people at work. Avoid the ambiguity. You're colleagues. Period.
- Symmetry 15y agoOr at the very least with people who you report to or who report to you.
- JabavuAdams 15y agoIt's strange -- people don't seem to harass up the chain of command. I wonder why that is? People who engage in sexual harassment may not understand office norms, but like everyone else, they have an instinctive understanding of power relationships.
- Oscarus 15y agoFrom Business Insider: "In addition, Pao alleges that females in the firms were often left out of dinner meetings held by male counterparts. She says women weren't invited because they would "kill the buzz."" I imagine the men want to hang out with one another and exclude women so that they can talk freely, without having to worry about 'creating a hostile work environment,' eg, by talking about sex, their marriages, etc. So their options are: a) invite the women out with them and behave the same, and risk getting sued for a "hostile work environment." b) exclude the women from these dinners. c) include them, but refrain from speaking freely, thereby 'killing the buzz.' d) eliminate the dinners altogether, which may lead to reduced morale, engagement, commitment, etc. I'm not stating a position here, but identifying that, even if this specific allegation is true, it's not necessarily spiteful, and that each course of action has pros and cons. The same thing happens with say, recovering alcoholics – they’re constantly invited to functions where alcohol is served when they’ve sworn off the stuff, but they can’t sue over their discomfort; nor do they get upset when others enjoy alcohol. On the other hand, excluding anyone on any basis from associating with higher-ups is bound to hurt their chances of being promoted up the ladder. The other allegations are more problematic, if true.
- chernevik 15y agoMaybe it's just how such briefs are written but this thing doesn't seem to lay out evidence or argument that she should have been promoted and bonused. Nor does it trouble itself anticipating obvious benign explanations -- she wasn't good at her job, didn't work hard, etc. Doesn't she have to make some showing that her performance merited the compensation denied her?
- wizzard 15y agoIt's going to be more difficult to prove performance when her performance reviews for the past few years are being challenged. At any rate, I'm sure merit will be discussed during the trial. IANAL but the brief is supposed to be a list of complaints, not a hagiography of the plaintiff.
- kogir 15y agoHer side of the story sounds awful, and to the extent it's true KP's inaction and behavior is despicable. I'm curious why she stayed though. VCs move between firms in the valley not irregularly, leaving previous firms on both positive and negative notes. My top two guesses are that either she wasn't able to find anything else, or she wanted to stick it to them by collecting enough evidence to win this case. Both make me sad - the former because it means everyone else was blind to her apparent talent, and the latter because even if she wins this she'll never get that time she was miserable back. I hope that the truth comes out and justice is served, but can't help wondering if success elsewhere might have been the best revenge.
- melindajb 15y agoActually most VCs do not switch firms. This was made clear by Ann Winblad in her epic TED talk located here: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HybHcXGvrGM http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HybHcXGvrGM If you spent your whole life to reach the top of your profession, you wouldn't want to walk away just because some douchebag was harassing you. Many women do just what you suggest, which is right on an individual level but doesn't help the cause of the gender. Ms. Pao, as a wealthy and successful woman has the opportunity to change the game. And the resources to fight a firm with very deep pockets. If people who make it don't fight to change the system, who will?
- jordo37 15y agoIt seems to me that the significant allegation in this case is the fact that she asked to be moved and KP said no. I believe some of the other details are incriminating as well and in the end it doesn't matter that she had a relationship Nazre, but as soon as something like this is muddied many people will say its complicated and therefore not worth the time to look at it. But, no matter these other details, she felt uncomfortable and asked not for retribution, but to sacrifice her current role in order to escape an uncomfortable situation and KP said NO. That seems unacceptable to me.
- wizzard 15y agoThe part where he boss tells her she should just give up and marry her harasser (Fact 13) is gross. Fact 29 is also pretty damning. If this is true, it's clearly not just a problem with Ms. Pao in particular, but all women. I agree with all the other posters who have said this is why you don't have personal relationships with people at work. Especially not in the same group. I do have trouble understanding the part where Nazre is continually harassing her, so she just gives in and has a relationship with him, despite him apparently being married. This is all kinds of wrong.
- Natsu 15y ago> I do have trouble understanding the part where Nazre is continually harassing her, so she just gives in and has a relationship with him, despite him apparently being married. This is all kinds of wrong. That's from the complaint. The weirdness shows that we haven't been told the whole story yet. Still, this whole thing is disturbing.
- onetime555 15y agoHere's what I know: 1. She's beautiful, smart, terrific, and reasonable 2. Her husband is extremely wealthy, so this isn't about money 3. Her husband sued the Dakota building for discrimination (she lives in SF, he lives there, they commute between) Make of that what you will.
- alain94040 15y agoHow does this relate to John Doerr's quote that "[The world’s greatest entrepreneurs] all seem to be white, male, nerds". I'd love to be running discovery for this case. How likely is it that someone, once, wrote something really stupid in an e-mail between senior partners, regarding Pao's allegations?
- FrankRiedel 15y agoWait a minute. If Ellen is married, why was she having sex with colleagues at her firm?
- silverlake 15y agoIn the complaint, page 10, line 3. Chi-Hua Chien organized a dinner for partners and explicitly excluded women because "they would kill the buzz." Reading the complaint shows that KPCB was following the standard playbook for removing an employee cleanly. A lesson for the kids out there: HR works for the company, not for you. Never reveal anything to HR. http://www.scribd.com/doc/94433811/Kleiner-Perkins-Ellen-Pao http://www.scribd.com/doc/94433811/Kleiner-Perkins-Ellen-Pao