3 ms·
I agree with this and generally I am not against GM crops in theory. I think that: 1. Monocultures are bad. GM crops don't have to be monocultures but they gen
by EthanHeilman 14y ago
I agree with this and generally I am not against GM crops in theory. I think that:
1. Monocultures are bad. GM crops don't have to be monocultures but they generally are for a number of business reasons that have nothing to do with food production.
2. GM crops cross-pollenate thereby spreading patented genes to non-GM fields. The owners of these non-GM fields are then sued and forced to switch to GM crops.
3. GM crops business models are often built around vendor lock-in. Historically vendor lock-in has been bad for software development and I think we can extrapolate these results to farming.
4. Cross pollination to wild-type is generally disruptive to the environment short term (for example consider what happens when wild plants produce pesticides from a GM gene). The effects are probably no different than introducing an invasive species. Generally people see this as a bad thing (snakes in Hawaii for example) and create laws to prevent it from happening. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Invasive_species http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Invasive_species
5. There is a big difference between point mutations and transgenic plants. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Transgene http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Transgene
I think GM crops can be developed, used in a safe manner and provide a great benefit to humanity, but that is not the current state-of-affairs. There are good reasons the EU regulates GM crops as much as they do.
- vlasta2 14y agoWell, I agree that there may be dangers. Eco-activist groups should focus on forcing and helping the scientists and corporations to do more thorough testing. They should not destroy crops or attempt to stop the research. Thinking that they can stop it is naive. If it does not happen in US or EU, it will happen elsewhere (and possibly with less effective safety precautions). The patent thing is a separate problem. Patent law in many areas is pretty bad.