4 ms·
> According to space research and development company Aerospace, the chances of being struck by an object from space are one in a trillion depending on where yo
by rsynnott 3y ago
> According to space research and development company Aerospace, the chances of being struck by an object from space are one in a trillion depending on where you live.
I have doubts about this, given that this _keeps happening_.
- xanderlewis 3y agoWell, what does it mean? Each time a piece of debris falls you have probability p = 10^-12 of it hitting you? Or there’s probability p every day that there will be a piece of falling debris? Or p chance of being hit across a lifetime? Extremely events do indeed happen regularly if you have enough rolls of the die.
- outop 3y agoMaybe it's one in a trillion that a particular piece of space junk, not already known to be falling from the sky, will fall and hit a particular person. This seems quite scary since the product of the number of people and the number of pieces of space junk is much more than a trillion.
- DiggyJohnson 3y agoThe question GP is really getting at though is "1 in a trillion per what?".
- krisoft 3y agoWhat exactly keeps happening? Nobody got struck by the object in this specific case.
- dotnet00 3y agoLiterally a handful of cases of this happening throughout history, barring the space shuttle disasters, which were a somewhat different situation. This incident makes ~15 cases of debris striking people or property since the start of the space age. In most of those the debris was found either washed up on shore or landed in some wide, open area like a farm, with only 4 of those incidents involving actual hits on humans/animals, 7 humans in total (5 sailors injured in one incident, a woman tapped on the shoulder, a boy getting hit in the head and toe, and a sheep being killed).
- lelandfe 3y agoThis was in December https://www.newsweek.com/china-falling-long-march-rocket-debris-explodes-village-1855676 https://www.newsweek.com/china-falling-long-march-rocket-deb...
- Symmetry 3y agoI believe those spent stages never made it to space, certainly they didn't make it to orbit. And because only the people living downrange of that particular launch facility have to worry it's covered by "depending on where you live".
- dotnet00 3y agoI count those as situations similar to the Shuttle accidents, in the Shuttle's case it was an inevitable consequence of the design that the area it had to fly over would be exposed to debris if it broke up in reentry. In the Long March's case, it is by design that the stages fall back down and often land near villages. It isn't an accident when they keep doing it despite obviously knowing that it would happen (thus the rocket debris warnings being issued prior to the launch). I count these separately because of course you're at a higher risk of getting hit when the process by which you would get hit is actively controlled in such a way that would cause the chance to be higher. In comparison, this debris strike was not intended, the battery was expected to fully burn up during reentry. The other incidents I cited were similar, they were all orbital debris that was not expected to make it back intact or hit an inhabited area.
- orbital-decay 3y agoThese are Chinese launches and their decades-old issue with launch site locations. Very constrained trajectory (like with any other launchers), and stage falling areas are over populated areas. That's why you keep hearing about this each year. These areas aren't wide. ISS is in orbit, and the inclination of 51.6° means any debris can reenter at basically any point on the globe up to this latitude.
- lupusreal 3y ago
- lupusreal 3y agoThe odds of winning the lottery are one in a billion, yet many people have won it. Mighty suspicious! (Except not really, when you account for the size of the lottery-playing population.)
- t_mann 3y agotbh, I don't even know what it means. A randomly sampled location (of what area?) has a 1:1tn chance of getting hit within any given hour? Day? Year? Over the course of an average human lifetime? Something else? I feel like the characters in https://xkcd.com/1985/ https://xkcd.com/1985/