> Some of the music I listened to growing up, that I still listen to, was made by people who were complete neophytes with their instruments. I think it depends

> Some of the music I listened to growing up, that I still listen to, was made by people who were complete neophytes with their instruments. I think it depends on the instrument, the type of music, and the ensemble. Punk band? Sure. Symphony orchestra? Probably not. Which isn't to say that one is objectively better or worse than the other. Lots of people enjoy both.