3 ms·
> You’re forgetting that the people living in those towns don’t want you to suddenly increase the housing stock by 5x and with it the class sizes. It's actuall
by AnthonyMouse 3y ago
> You’re forgetting that the people living in those towns don’t want you to suddenly increase the housing stock by 5x and with it the class sizes.
It's actually easier to have smaller class sizes with higher density because you spend less on transportation and real estate and can use the money hire more teachers, or lower your taxes, or do whatever you like with it.
> Why should a minority of people, especially those that don’t even live in these towns, dictate how the town will be changing?
Because it's every town operating under the same set of incentives. Existing homeowners don't want more housing because they want the value of their existing home to go up through scarcity. It's the same in every town, so if you want to build "cities" anywhere the decision on whether it can be done in a particular place can't be solely in the hands of the people who have the financial incentive to say no.
> If dense housing is the bees knees, make people want to live in cities.
If people didn't want to live in cities then why does the housing there cost more?
- koolba 3y ago> It's actually easier to have smaller class sizes with higher density because you spend less on transportation and real estate and can use the money hire more teachers, or lower your taxes, or do whatever you like with it. In practice, new housing increases the denominator (number of students) more the than numerator (tax dollars). This is because the existing tax base includes non-residential land that only provides tax dollars without increase school costs. So any new housing is always a net loss. > Existing homeowners don't want more housing because they want the value of their existing home to go up through scarcity. The flip side of that is that people who don’t have those houses want to take that away without paying the market price for that land. > If people didn't want to live in cities then why does the housing there cost more? Historicaly, being close to high paying jobs was a major driver. There’s also an annual resupply of starry eyed graduates. Though I’ll be honest to not understand why anyone would pay a premium to live like a sardine. The air quality alone is enough reason to move out of the city.
- AnthonyMouse 3y ago> In practice, new housing increases the denominator (number of students) more the than numerator (tax dollars). This is because the existing tax base includes non-residential land that only provides tax dollars without increase school costs. So any new housing is always a net loss. The assumption here is that you would have only new residential housing. But zoning that allows for higher density construction also allows for new businesses that pay taxes and have no children. And you would also have to be making assumptions about the ratio of taxes paid to number of kids. But the people who move into small cheap apartments and condos are most often college students and retirees, who don't have kids yet (and wouldn't continue to live there if they did) or their kids are already grown. From which you get new tax dollars but no new students. Whereas the people who can afford a 3- or 4-bedroom unit have money and pay an above-average amount of tax, so they might have kids but they're paying their own way. This is also not just a fraction with a numerator and a denominator. Many of a government's expenses are fixed costs, e.g. most single-lane suburban roads are nowhere near capacity and would not need to be expanded or even experience congestion if the amount of traffic on them doubled. Each new resident you get paying taxes increases the tax base over which you can amortize those fixed costs. Moreover, the ratio is irrelevant. If someone is paying $21,000 in taxes and then their presence requires the government to spend $20,000 more in services, you'd have a net gain of $1000 from their presence regardless of what the ratio is for some other people or existing residents. > The flip side of that is that people who don’t have those houses want to take that away without paying the market price for that land. They are paying the market price for that land. In order to build a multi-story building, you first have to buy a piece of land to put it on. What they're doing is making more efficient use of that land, by creating e.g. 10 housing units on a lot currently being used for 1. That reduces the market price of housing units by supply and demand, but the higher price was only ever a result of artificial scarcity. > Historicaly, being close to high paying jobs was a major driver. So a shorter commute makes up for a higher price. But if you prohibit housing construction, this trade off only gets worse. The job is in the city, you could have lived in a 6-unit building 20 minutes away, but if those are prohibited then you need 6 times as much land for the same number of residents and now they either have to pay more even for the 20 minute commute or take the far away housing with a 60+ minute commute. Whereas if you allow the 6-story buildings, anyone who wants the 20-minute commute can live there and anyone who wants to live in a single-family home can live five blocks away with nearly the same commute but for a lower price than they'd have had to pay when those higher density buildings weren't there satisfying housing demand. > Though I’ll be honest to not understand why anyone would pay a premium to live like a sardine. Density and small units are not inherently associated. You can put 4000 sq ft units in a multi-story building and still have ten times the density as a single-family home of the same size as one unit. > The air quality alone is enough reason to move out of the city. Tell that to the suburban ignoramuses who think it's a good idea to burn wood: https://www.familiesforcleanair.org/wp-content/uploads/2013/05/chart_circles.gif https://www.familiesforcleanair.org/wp-content/uploads/2013/... That graphic isn't even to scale. The pellet stove looks like it's only a little over twice as bad as an oil furnace when it's actually more than a hundred times worse, and the wood stoves and fireplaces people have are an order of magnitude worse than that.
- jjav 3y ago> If people didn't want to live in cities then why does the housing there cost more? Density seems to always make an area more expensive. What are the two densest cities in the US? Which are the two most expensive cities in the US? Increasing density does not ever seem to make an area cheaper to live. Maybe that is ok, but it does contradict the idea of building more to make it cheaper.
- AnthonyMouse 3y ago> Density seems to always make an area more expensive. What are the two densest cities in the US? Which are the two most expensive cities in the US? The causation goes the other way. When an area has a lot of housing demand, that's where they put the tall buildings. Nobody is going to build a skyscraper in the middle of a corn field. But in order for the density to keep up with demand, you can't suppress new construction. That's what causes prices to be high: > What are the two densest cities in the US? Which are the two most expensive cities in the US? Which are the two cities in the US with the most restrictive zoning and building codes? Which are the two most expensive cities in the US?
- alistairSH 3y agoBut in practice, we're so far behind on the supply side that we could densify much of our cities and inner suburbs and still see values rise. And I'm not convinced that when done in a playful manner, that densification doesn't add value to existing SFHs, despite now being located in a noisier/denser/whatever area. People largely prefer convenience and not driving all the time. Just walking to school is a huge plus - fewer noisy buses, more healthy kids, etc. Arlington VA added a ton of mid-rise and high-rise development in the 80s/90s (Clarendon, Courthouse, Ballston) with good results. Reston VA is now doing the same and home that were $400k a decade ago are selling for nearly double. In both cases, the scope of in-fill was tightly controlled - the local governments created dense zones around the Metro stations - which makes sense.
- AnthonyMouse 3y ago> But in practice, we're so far behind on the supply side that we could densify much of our cities and inner suburbs and still see values rise. This is a common source of confusion. If you relax zoning, the instantaneous effect is that the value of land is increased in the areas where the zoning is made more permissive (because now you can do more with the land) and reduced where zoning was already permissive (because now land zoned for those uses is less scarce). So the immediate effect is that the value of the land where single-family homes are will go up, and that effect is permanent. Then the value of indoor space goes down as people are allowed to and do build more of it. Which is what we're after, because the important thing is that people can get a couple thousand sq ft of living space for an affordable price, regardless of the number of floors the building they're in has. If the value of the land doubles but the amount of housing per acre quintuples, you've still made the land cost per housing unit decline by 250%. What that does to the long-term value of existing single-family homes depends on how much demand there is. In areas where the zoning had been oppressively restrictive, the gain in land value from relaxing the zoning could exceed the amount that it's even possible to lose from the value of indoor space. For example, you have a $400,000 house and the new zoning makes the land itself worth $500,000, but housing still becomes more affordable because someone can buy that $500,000 piece of land, build a dozen housing units there and sell the property for $2.4M, pricing each of the units at $200,000. The existing single family home still sells for $500,000+ though, not because it's a housing unit but because it's an acre of land where someone could build a dozen. > In both cases, the scope of in-fill was tightly controlled - the local governments created dense zones around the Metro stations - which makes sense. It doesn't. It makes a significant amount of sense to put a 3-5 story building in an area with mostly single-family homes, because that can often be supported with no additional infrastructure. If you want to put them all in the same place then you have to upgrade the utilities and transportation infrastructure there. Which is fine if that's what happens naturally because people choose to develop a particular area, but there is no reason to force it. And trying to concentrate them all in one area also slows down the construction and makes it cost more, because then the land cost there remains high for lack of alternatives, forcing developers to buy out those particular people (and giving them undue gains that should have been evenly distributed to the community at large) instead of buying whatever properties were already on the market.