3 ms·
The Netflix one is trash. The Tencent one is fairly close to the book. Downside is there is definetly some "rah-rah" nationalism and the pacing isn't the great
by alephnerd 3y ago
The Netflix one is trash. The Tencent one is fairly close to the book.
Downside is there is definetly some "rah-rah" nationalism and the pacing isn't the greatest, but all in all I'd say the Tencent one is a pretty strong adaption.
If an abridged version of the Tencent adaption was bought by Netflix it would have done very well.
- mplewis 3y agoAs a big fan of the books, I preferred the Netflix adaptation to the Tencent one.
- routerl 3y ago> The Tencent one is fairly close to the book. Not really? It both overexplains simple concepts (e.g. the billiard table scene) and underexplains important concepts. The Netflix show just has awful writing, and only cares about visuals. My favorite example of bad writing is the very last scene, where three characters are having a conversation, then one of them suddenly gets up and says "let me show you something". So they drive for (seemingly) hours, apparently in perfect silence, only to get out of the car, look over a field, and deliver a handful of pithy lines, followed immediately by "okay let's go back". (For book readers: this is the "bugs vs. humans speech"). Anyway, they're both ephemeral garbage. I guess 3BP will be like Dune, where it takes decades for a decent adaptation to show up.