3 ms·
You of course run into pretty big problems with both Gabor Mate, an admirer of Hamas, and Noam Chomsky, who among other things is infamous for denying the genoc
by tptacek 3y ago
You of course run into pretty big problems with both Gabor Mate, an admirer of Hamas, and Noam Chomsky, who among other things is infamous for denying the genocide in Cambodia on campist grounds. About the whole cursed situation you can distill out a through-line, of people starting their analyses with the axiom that an alliance of western capitalist world powers is responsible on a daily basis for all the ills of the world, and extrapolating from there.
I don't know what I think about JVP other than that they're not a mainstream organization. I went down a grim rabbit hole of reading about their advocacy to evangelical churches and the whole "Zionism Unsettled" thing. Look, there's nothing wrong with being resolutely leftist. It's just that it's not reasonable to argue that a resolutely leftist organization is representative of American Jewish people, or that it can insulate other activists from charges of antisemitism when it itself is continuously subjected to those same charges.
About ADL, I probably mostly agree with you, that they haven't navigated the distinctions between anti-Zionism and antisemitism well, and, like other antiracist activist organizations, diluted their credibility with mission creep and capture. Like Rationalwiki, I read ADL things for the receipts they bring and disregard the analysis.
This thread, too, is deeply cursed, and I don't mean to try to "win" any arguments here; there's no such thing, especially on this topic. I'm just clarifying what I dropped in here to say.
- tptacek 3y ago(after rereading what I just wrote) Actually Gabor Mate and Noam Chomsky are just really good examples of what I'm talking about, right? Like: if an activist said something, and a normie person objected to it, and you came back with "Noam Chomsky says this is just fine to say", you wouldn't expect that to persuade the normie. That doesn't make Chomsky wrong! It just makes him not all that rhetorically useful. Same deal with JVP.