3 ms·
Does it matter if they are the same? If they have an inventory of engines that get rebuilt after launches but enough that they do not need to delay launches, it
by dylan604 3y ago
Does it matter if they are the same? If they have an inventory of engines that get rebuilt after launches but enough that they do not need to delay launches, it's good enough for my use.
It's similar to a NASCAR race. They pretty much tear those down and rebuild after each race as well, but it's the "same" car.
- jauntywundrkind 3y agoIt matters and it doesn't. It doesn't affect turn around because you can have a ready to go inventory. But it matters how much an engine can be reused because it's a significant material and labor effort to produce them. Are the 9 engines from each flight reusable, and to what extent? Does half the motor get replaced each time or is it generally ok? The Ship of Theseus debate doesn't have a hard answer to it. We can -like the Persian Immortal - respect the continuity of the thing. But so too we should track and follow the churn of the pieces, acknowledge the parts decayed. I for one am very curious how much of the ship and how much of the motor needs replacement, and how often.
- Isamu 3y agoIn the context of rockets, what is important and salient here is reuse, and even if some motors are swapped out, they are still available for refurbishment, rather than destroyed on reentry.
- jauntywundrkind 3y agoUnless they have to be written off cause they are wrecked? Tesla's kept this one close to the chest. We really don't seem to have much data at all on how the rocket engines are doing after re-entry. The rocket engine itself might well be it's own Ship of Theseus, requiring considerable replacement. We just don't know, it's just not clear.
- dylan604 3y agoWould launches be as cheap if they had to keep replacing the most complicated part of the ship? Could they hide the expense of replacing the engines with subsidized pricing like Uber?
- fdfdfdfdfdddf 3y agoShip of Theseus The engines are the most expensive part of any rocket by far. Clearly SpaceX has produced some incredible economies from reuse, but it's definitely not as clear cut as simply "reusing a single rocket twenty times".