4 ms·
Moore's law has been redefined several times already. At the beginning it was every 12 months, then 18, and now it's 24. What's being measured has also chan
by bryanlarsen 15y ago
Moore's law has been redefined several times already. At the beginning it was every 12 months, then 18, and now it's 24. What's being measured has also changed. It used to be frequency scaling that we measured, but that changed after the debacle of the Pentium 4.
But the essence of Moore's law has always remained: the exponential growth in the capability of ICs. The other relatively constant aspect of Moore's law is that people have always predicted it to last another 10 years. When Moore first formulated the law, that's approximately what he believed. So when somebody says that they expect Moore's law to end within 5-10 years, I take that with a big grain of salt.
What will kill Moore's law will be an unwillingness to continue to spend more money to build semiconductor plants. It used to cost only a few hundred thousand dollars to build an IC plant. This cost has increased exponentially to the point where a plant today costs $10 billion dollars. It's reasonable to suppose that a consortium of semiconductor manufacturers could invest $100 billion in a plant, but on current trajectories, a $1 trillion plant may be necessary to continue Moore's law in 10 years. Do you think that will happen?
- carsongross 15y agoYes. The cost of the exotic silicon and post silicon alternatives are dramatically higher than todays costs, which are dramatically higher than yesterdays. Couple that with the fact that the majority of people have far more computing power than is necessary for their day-to-day existence (e.g. emailing, posting on FB and looking at cat pictures and/or pornography.) So costs continue to increase by some super-linear function but benefits follow a sigmoid curve. The disconnect between marginal cost and marginal demand for computational power is what's going to knock Moore's Law off it's curve IMO, not some hard technical barrier. The futurists are always spending someone else's imaginary money, so they don't have to worry about stuff like that.
- ericb 15y ago> The futurists are always spending someone else's imaginary money. A $35 raspberry pi can outrun what used to be multi-million dollar mainframes. Are you sure that cost factors are relevant when the trend is so strongely toward lower costs? If prices drop, then lower utility uses become feasible.
- carsongross 15y agoPast returns do not indicate future performance. Technical innovation is slowing down, not speeding up. Raw, usable linear CPU performance at the fingertips of normal humans using personal computers has been essentially flat for half a decade, with the majority of material perf changes coming in the I/O subsystem, and yet still the CPU sits idle for the vast majority of its life. I'm probably wrong, but it's still a reasonable position: we've seen technical stagnations before. I'm simply (and probably incorrectly) projecting the current trend I see, as an end user of technology: raw straigh-ahead cpu perf is stagnating and, unless I see real progress on AI (which I don't) I'm skeptical that a lot more of it will help most people doing most things, unless we are talking a lot lot more. If some of the more exotic technologies get practical and cheap, I'm happy to be wrong, but I think it's important to note that Moore's Law was observational: he was describing what he saw happening rather than envisioning it. We no longer are seeing what he saw. A phase change may fix that, but that's very different than what we've been mining for the last half century, and much harder to project out.
- mistercow 15y ago> It used to be frequency scaling that we measured From the very beginning, it has been economically feasible component density, and as far as I know, that has not changed. Look at this graph for example: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Transistor_Count_and_Moore%27s_Law_-_2011.svg http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Transistor_Count_and_Moore...