3 ms·
I was more or less with you until > Doesn't the observation come first, and the math just explains what was observed? and feel the need to point out that math
by defrost 3y ago
I was more or less with you until
> Doesn't the observation come first, and the math just explains what was observed?
and feel the need to point out that math for Pluto's rough position came first and directed observers (roughly) where to look; that math for symmetry groups and permutations came first and then real world applications in crypto came later; that math for non Euclidean geometry was worked upon before physical observations suggested Newton wasn't exactly correct in his mechanics and Einstein got hyperbolic about lightspeed.
Math can come along before any observations are made that might suggest the math has application .. there was at least one mathematician in history that expressed a dread that their work might find an application (eg: in war, etc).
- _akhe 3y ago> "math for Pluto's rough position came first and directed observers (roughly) where to look" But the math wasn't proof that Pluto existed, it wasn't proven until it was discovered.
- defrost 3y agoThe "proof" part wasn't addressed there, just the question "Doesn't the observation come first, ..." Clearly this isn't always true, nor straightforward as the two can be intertwined in an iterative feedback. In other cases math theory domains can exist for decades prior to any observations that call upon those domains to expand or produce an applicable description for physicists or others.
- _akhe 3y agoI was referring to the observational proof when I said that - the entire Higgs craze was about the proof - not about math as both of you guys are saying. The math part was thought of in the 60s, 2012 was about the actual discovery - did you think LHC was a math lab? The point was they said they could observe it in 2012. What that guy above said about E=mc^2 was random nonsense that has nothing to do with this story, like a lot of people on this site he's in Jordan Peterson fashion just randomly asserting like a know-it-all with no thought behind the statements or proof to back them up. Despite his high score here you can safely ignore what he said about completing the Standard Model (billiard ball hypothesis) it doesn't, Standard Model is still incomplete, and there's no proof that subatomic structures even exist as particles - let alone all the subsequent theories predicated on that. > Clearly this isn't always true In what case can you say there is proof something exists without having any observable evidence for it - even if the math "checks out"? What - dark matter? Ghosts?