3 ms·
Because it shows no remorse. The reason for reduced sentences for juvenile offenders is the idea that they ‘didn’t know any better’. That they can learn and gro
by lazide 3y ago
Because it shows no remorse. The reason for reduced sentences for juvenile offenders is the idea that they ‘didn’t know any better’. That they can learn and grow and NOT be a menace to society soon.
If they still refuse to take any ownership or show any contrition even after being clearly shown something was a major problem (hence the court case), then why reduce the penalty? Who would it be helping, exactly?
- arp242 3y agoRemorse for what? Something he didn't do? There is nothing to be remorseful about. This is the sort of non-logic where you're presumed guilty and/or punished for asserting your innocence. Aside from the obvious absurdness of it, it's also literally unconstitutional as it violates your 5th amendment rights, which is why another judge reversed the decision later on. And considering all of this is about an 11-year old makes it that much worse.
- lazide 3y agoIf the court finds you guilty, then by definition within the system you did it. It doesn't mean you actually did, but it does mean the system says you did. Which is the point of my comment. It doesn't mean it actually makes sense in real life, but it's why the system does what it does. And the reason why the system will prosecute kids like adults sometimes - the nominal reason is because they don't think it's worth giving them a pass either due to the severe nature of the crime, or because of the lack of contrition of the accused. If they're actually innocent, then per the system they should get zero penalty eventually regardless of how they are prosecuted. We know that being held in an adult jail while awaiting trial is a pretty severe penalty in fact of course, which is why it eventually got thrown out that he got treated that way. Plenty of adults get stuck in jail for years while awaiting trial, then get released and theoretically suffered no penalty either. But we also know that is bullshit. No clear better alternatives (except bail) have shown themselves however. If the kid had been caught on tape murdering a bunch of other kids and still claimed he was innocent, then no one would be objecting that he be put in an adult jail while awaiting trial though. Since putting someone that violent in a juvenile facility is making it as dangerous as an adult one. Judges have wide discretion to make these calls, and this judge clearly screwed up. But that's the how and the why.
- arp242 3y agoNo one found him guilty of anything at this point. How can they when deciding in which court he should be judged? That happens before the trail. You're talking complete bollocks utterly disconnected from anything to do with this case.
- lazide 3y agoYou might want to actually read my comment. He was arrested pending trial. They have to decide where to put him, pending trial. If the judge expects to try him as an adult for the reasons I listed, then they're going to put him in an adult jail. If the judge expects to try him as a juvenile for the reasons I listed, then they're going to put him in a juvenile jail. Either way, someone does have to make the call. And there are circumstances where the call that was made is appropriate. Since it's 'detention pending trial', if he gets acquitted or charges dropped then per the system he 'suffered no penalty'. Same as anyone else arrested and put on trial. We know that isn't true though, since anyone in jail is still in jail and jail sucks. If he is found guilty, then he gets transferred. Clearly it was a bad call on the Judge's part doing what they did, which is why it got reversed - eventually. But as anyone who has dealt with the courts is well aware, everything is glacial - unless it's going to make your life a pain in the ass. That usually happens quickly. But like everyone else, one you're in the system, you're going to have a bad time regardless. What else do you propose is going to happen though?
- noodlesUK 3y ago> What else do you propose is going to happen though? Not parent but I don’t think that we should be holding anyone pending trial when what they’re accused of is so minor, child or otherwise. Furthermore any decisions about pre-trial detention shouldn’t hinge on remorse or contrition, they should hinge on the alleged offenders risk of flight and their potential risk to the community.
- lazide 3y agoThe judge is supposed to consider severity. Obviously it went too far in this case. Regarding remorse/contrition though - that is absolutely a factor of in potential risk to the community. Example - Someone gets arrested for DUI. Who is higher risk? Someone who insists they didn’t do it and fuck anyone who thinks they did and they’ll do what they want, or someone who says ‘that was terrible, and I didn’t do exactly what the prosecution says, but I’m not going to be driving anytime soon until this all gets worked out’? Because plenty of people in the first category end up driving drunk while pending trial and kill more people.
- exe34 3y agoSo you want them to lie? My dad was like that. I admitted to several things I didn't do in order to reduce the amount of caning. This led to a funny incident at school. Somebody did something, and another grassed. The bully came to question me - I had no memory of telling on him, but the way he described the comments, I though oh that does sound like something I'd say. I took the beating. Then the actual grass came up and asked me why did I admit something I hadn't done?
- b112 3y agoUnclear what a 'grass' is. Are you referring to falling down?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- boomboomsubban 3y ago"Grass" means "report to the authorities." Seems to originate in Britain as rhyming slang between copper and grasshopper, though I looked up the etymology for this post.
- ajb 3y agoGrass is British slang for informing on someone
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- lazide 3y agoFair or not, this is the idea behind 'no contest' pleas in court. No admittance of fault, but not going to fight the prosecution either because it isn't worth it. It isn't necessarily fair or sane - it's predictable though. Which is something.
- maxbond 3y agoThis line of thinking is entirely incompatible with the presumption of innocence and the right to protection from self incrimination.
- lazide 3y agoWelcome to bail/pretrial detention hearings. Practically, what are the alternatives? Every arrest is cite and release pending conviction? Society would be even more out of control.
- maxbond 3y agoThe alternative is to charge them as a juvenile, and to refrain from inferring a guilty conscious from their lack of "contrition" (which is a patently ridiculous thing to expect from an 11 year old - which is the real issue with charging children as adults, not that they supposedly are more reformable, but that they cannot be held to the same standards as adults). You're engaging in a slippery slope fallacy. This was a miscarriage of justice. Civilization would not have crumbled if this child wasn't put through the wringer.
- lazide 3y agoNo, I’m not arguing if it is right or wrong. I’ve been explaining why the levers exist as that was what was being asked. And to be clear, the case I’m referring to the kid was tried and convicted (originally) of 1st degree murder with a shotgun. In juvenile court. And if it turned out the kid did murder them, then people would be up in arms that he got released early - especially if he committed another murder before he got locked up again. Which could happen. Cases like this too [https://www.klfy.com/local/iberia-parish/trial-for-11-year-old-charged-in-iberia-parish-homicide-pushed-back-another-week/amp/ https://www.klfy.com/local/iberia-parish/trial-for-11-year-o...]. Was it a miscarriage of justice? Perhaps, I haven’t seen the evidence. The courts eventually came to the conclusion it was! Until they did, according to the courts it wasn’t. it was also legal while it was happening. And 11yr olds are plenty capable of being defiant, malicious, contrite, etc. too. And active dangers to those around them. I wasn’t there in court when this was going on, so I have no idea if the kid was being out of control, or the judge was being out of control. I’ve seen both play out. The appeals court felt it was the judge. The whole situation is quite terrible regardless. But that’s what the criminal justice system is for - to resolve terrible situations in some eventually sensible way. Woe to whoever gets caught in its gears though.
- morsch 3y agoChildren might be incapable of determining certain actions are wrong or illegal. They might be able to do that, but unable to apply this knowledge to their own behavior. A trial won't fix immediately this, just like charging an 11 year old like an adult won't make him grow a beard.