4 ms·
The Space Shuttle wasn't a boondoggle because it was a truck; it was a boondoggle because it was an incredibly expensive truck. It failed utterly at the ostens
by pfdietz 3y ago
The Space Shuttle wasn't a boondoggle because it was a truck; it was a boondoggle because it was an incredibly expensive truck. It failed utterly at the ostensible and valid reasons it was constructed, to make access to space cheap and routine.
- dylan604 3y agoWhere the shuttle led, cyber truck has followed.
- justinclift 3y agoThe cyber truck is just a follower. The Roadster got there first: https://where-is-tesla-roadster.space/live https://where-is-tesla-roadster.space/live
- namaria 3y agoThe reason it was expensive was the military specs (be able to land back home after one orbit etc). The goal of the space shuttle was also to help drive USSR to bankruptcy and it delivered. The soviet counterpart was a huge resource drain and did exactly nothing.
- pfdietz 3y agoThe reason for military specs was the case for the Shuttle was so marginal it required fantastical projections of launch rates and launch market to make the numbers work (and all that was far too optimistic, as subsequence experience showed). This required all government launch customers to use it. NASA desperately needed the military on board; the military didn't want it and had to be strong armed into supporting it. That military requirements were then added has to be the responsibility of NASA (or of NASA's political masters) for forcing the military to be a customer.
- akira2501 3y agoIt was designed to put classified satellites in orbit and possibly go recover them. In the long run it somewhat paid off for the repair Hubble missions. It was also a pretty cool truck. It generated 21kW of power, using Hydrogen/Oxygen fuel cells, and captured the output water for use on missions. During most of it's life it had to send the excess water overboard, but when it came to ISS, they started bagging it up and transferring it to the station. The power itself, the payload bay, the payload manipulation arm made this a pretty nice platform to build ISS with. Which was a natural consequence of the shuttle not being good for much else than building space stations and recovering spy satellites before the Russians did. In terms of a natural step in our evolution towards a space faring society it was an incredible vehicle and it inspired the imagination of everyone who watched it fly.
- pfdietz 3y ago> It was designed to put classified satellites in orbit and possibly go recover them. It ended up useless for both roles. The military quickly moved back to expendables. Satellite recovery never made any sense as a mission for the Shuttle; satellites are generally not worth recovering at those launch costs. > In the long run it somewhat paid off for the repair Hubble missions. Clearly not. For the cost of the shuttle program, a large number of copies of HST could have been built and launched on expendable boosters. This is especially the case when one amortizes engineering cost of the program over multiple instances of the physical hardware. All the other things you mention there are examples of drawing a bullseye around where the arrow landed, post hoc rationalizations. A launch vehicle that is actually cheap, like Falcon 9 or even more so (if it works) Starship would be far more inspiring; look at the palpable excitement from SpaceX's achievements. The shuttle was a Potemkin Village in its inspiration: it superficially looked cool, but objectively it was a hollow shell, leading nowhere. The truly sad thing about the shuttle was that the US could have had cost optimized expendable launchers many decades ago, even launchers that could have evolved into something like Falcon 9 with a recoverable first stage (the Saturn 1B might have been a good jumping off point; the H-1 engine is in the same thrust class as the Merlin, it just weighs twice as much). Bastiat's "What is Seen and What is Not Seen" should be kept in mind when thinking about the program: compare it to what the alternative could have been, not to nothing at all.