4 ms·
Why a $100k income no longer buys the American Dream in most places
- mikece 3y ago"Unfortunately, what has happened is that wages haven’t kept up with the cost of living, by and large, for the last 50 years or so" That's putting it mildly. I lived better 15 years ago making $40k less than I do now. Price increases for consumer goods, energy, food, and property taxes in the last four years have been especially brutal!
- pleasantpeasant 3y agoUntil we reverse Reagan's disastrous Trickle-Down Theory(Voodoo Economics), we won't see this changing. Even in the '80s they knew this current world would be the outcome. This isn't a surprise to the Fed or the Reaganites.
- no_wizard 3y agoThis is the trouble with 'infinite inflation' which is the economic model in which we exist (most central banks target 2% inflation), you combine this modeling with what that doesn't cover - things like housing, that up many multiples higher than the official inflation rate. Now many argue "well raises should be higher than inflation" but data continues to show that this isn't the case, as mentioned in the top of the article, for the last 50 years or so, raises have not kept pace with real cost of living increases. I have seen an argument that raises have evened out somewhat to beat the official inflation rate, but this is dubious, because the reported government inflation rate has exclusions to its calculation and doesn't capture the real cost of living increases faced across the US, due to inflation rate calculation exclusions and approaches. I've long argued we need some kind of deflation in real costs, what that would look like is hard for me to say. I know its complicated, however I think a good place to start is perhaps returning to pre Reagan era economic 'reforms' is a good first step, as I've seen mentioned elsewhere (on HN or otherwise), as so called 'Reaganomics' hasn't really panned out for the average American over the long term.
- slowmovintarget 3y agoWe haven't had "Reaganomics" at play since Bush senior. Repeal of Glass-Steagall under Clinton, ACA, and Dodd-Frank puts us in a completely different economic regime than 'Reaganomics.' Include alternative definitions for both CPI and unemployment which paint rosier but untrue pictures of the system. These have been in place starting with the Obama administration and continue today. The admonition from the Reagan administration on economics was fairly simple: Lower the rates, broaden the base. We've not been doing that for a long time.
- verteu 3y agoBut the median wage is up 40% in the last 15 years... If your pay has been constant, you're getting salary decreases in real terms.
- _mlbt 3y agoThat's great, but how much has the price of housing, food, cars, energy, and a college education increased during that time frame?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- verteu 3y agoMy other comment in this thread compares the growth of CPI and wages (wages grew faster).
- _mlbt 3y agoCPI doesn’t properly account for these factors that I mentioned.
- verteu 3y agoCPI includes housing, food, cars, & energy. You're welcome to check an alternate metric (eg Truflation), but they're all quite similar to CPI.
- yftsui 3y agoA simple Google search will give you an obvious result: “Spending to purchase and improve houses and other housing units is treated as investment and not consumption in the CPI.” You are welcome.
- verteu 3y agoRight, that's covered by "owner's equivalent rent." This is LOWER than what homeowners actually pay. (Think about it -- Do landlords make negative `profit = home_payment_expenses - rent`?) Any why would GGP mention food, cars, and energy? They are directly included in the CPI. I think it's more likely that GGP is under the false impression that these items are excluded from the CPI -- It's a conspiracy theory originating from economists' practice of using "CPI Excluding Food, Shelter, Energy, and Used Cars and Trucks" as a lower-variance estimate of the future inflation rate. > You are welcome. Skip the snark, it's against HN guidelines.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- richwater 3y agoGovernment expenditure in 1960 was $77 Billion/year. Adjusted for inflation that would be $820 Billion/year today. Actual spending today is $6,180 Billion/year, a ~7.5x multiplier above inflation. Your income is being stolen through taxes and spent at an alarming rate.
- pleasantpeasant 3y agoReaganomics. We should try to slowly go back to a pre-Reagan economic world.
- drewcoo 3y agoThe shift to neoliberalism happened under Carter. https://www.salon.com/2011/02/08/lind_reaganism_carter/ https://www.salon.com/2011/02/08/lind_reaganism_carter/ Nixon was our last New Deal President. https://isi.org/modern-age/richard-nixon-new-deal-nationalist/ https://isi.org/modern-age/richard-nixon-new-deal-nationalis... Silly as it may seem, you probably want a more Nixonian world.
- fxd123 3y agoYou are mistaken. Reagan's tax cuts, which included cuts for the lower class, decreased tax revenue and put more money in the average person's pockets. Presidents after Reagan started to pillage the lower and middle class for more tax revenue. Notably George H.W. [1] [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Omnibus_Budget_Reconciliation_Act_of_1990 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Omnibus_Budget_Reconciliation_...
- JohnFen 3y agoTaking what you say as accurate and complete just for the sake of argument, those tax cuts also meant that people had a greater non-tax financial burden. They also had adverse social consequences that increased costs for everybody. The wealthy certainly did get great gains out of it, but it was at the expense of the non-wealthy because the tax cut they received was tiny and didn't offset the increased expenses.
- freitzkriesler2 3y agoWe have too many asset owners who are trading amongst themselves, leaving real workers in the dust. It's time to cut down real estate investors by restricting ownership to real people and heavily taxing multiple property ownership. Yes, building more helps but until the landed gentry is removed as a demand pressure then affordability will not get better.
- MichaelMug 3y agoWhich real estate investors? Because it’s a spectrum. From the mom and pop trying to supplement their income to the investment firms that bought tens of thousands of properties. The latter being a bigger problem here. What I’ve seen lately is mega apartment complexes being built and funded by private equity. That’s not good either. Things will end up like Europe where no one owns their flat they just rent in perpetuity.
- bryanlarsen 3y agoAlmost all low income earners rent from an investment firm. Any tax on investment firms will be passed down to the renters. Taxing those investment firms is a tax on the poor. Taxing short term rentals, OTOH...
- freitzkriesler2 3y agoAll of them from Mom and Pop to black rock. A small leach is the same as a big leach.
- fxd123 3y ago> heavily taxing multiple property ownership Which would harm the development of multi-family housing and increase the cost of living. Remember that "real workers" do not build and own 100+-unit dwellings
- freitzkriesler2 3y agoThis is utterly false. Unless those developers are selling their units they are part of the problem. Ban renting and force the sale of units in those multi new builds and it eliminates the problem . Doubly so once you've forced the sale of multi unit owners, now you have a gkut of available properties on the market and reduced demand which lowers the price. The fact that this farce keeps getting perpetuated is why the problem will never go away.
- nine_zeros 3y agoThis is what happens when the fiat economic system is based on constant inflation without any moderation. The next recession - without adequate drop in prices - is literally going to create third-world-esque homelessness in vast majority of the country.
- TrackerFF 3y agoI think it's crazy how $100k seriously can't cut it in the US? Here where I live, in Norway, $100k is more than enough to live very comfortably almost anywhere in the country. Only exceptions would be certain expensive parts of Oslo, and some other high-income areas/towns around Oslo. And if you're two people earning that kind of money? Early retirement would be a viable option in as little as 10-15 years, if you have a sober lifestyle. But, then again, I have friends and ex-colleagues that live in the US - and I'm not talking about expensive places like NYC, SF, etc. - bur rather medium sized cities in flyover country, and even there people are paying rents (or purchasing homes) that feel pretty stiff to me.
- fxd123 3y ago$100k absolutely can cut it in most of the US- even in expensive cities. The median income in New York City is $76k [1]. The article uses a wild definition of "American Dream" where 50% of income has to be able to be spent on non-essential things. I really don't think most people will actually spend like that. [1] https://www.census.gov/quickfacts/fact/table/newyorkcitynewyork/HSG010222 https://www.census.gov/quickfacts/fact/table/newyorkcitynewy...
- anotherhue 3y agoRents are still $3.5k though. I guess everyone has roommates and that doesn't show up in the data. https://www.renthop.com/average-rent-in/new-york-ny https://www.renthop.com/average-rent-in/new-york-ny
- fxd123 3y ago> I guess everyone has roommates Yes, apparently 40% of single people have roommates in NYC Keep in mind that having a "roommate" is common everywhere in the US- 50% of households are romantic partners, with most of those households having 2 incomes. You have to keep that in mind when looking at living expenses everywhere.
- _akhe 3y ago
- verteu 3y ago> "Unfortunately, what has happened is that wages haven’t kept up with the cost of living, by and large, for the last 50 years or so" Not sure about 50 years, but from 2001-2020 (period where data is most easily available for me) things seem fine? CPI: 175.1->257.971 (2.1%/yr) Median wage: $27060 -> $46310 (2.9%/yr) Mean wage: $34020 -> $61900 (3.2%/yr) Bottom 10% wage: $18140 -> $27340 (2.2%/yr) Rent burden (median_wage / median_rent): 25% -> 28% (and it's now back down to 27%) [1] https://data.bls.gov/cgi-bin/surveymost?bls https://data.bls.gov/cgi-bin/surveymost?bls [2] eg https://www.wolframalpha.com/input?i=median+US+wage+2022 https://www.wolframalpha.com/input?i=median+US+wage+2022