4 ms·
'Eat the future, pay with your face': my dystopian trip to an AI burger joint
- camillomiller 3y agoTo file under “oh wait that actually wasn’t AI”, as the journalist herself subtly points out.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- lgeorget 3y agoThe bit about computer vision and being able to adapt to a new kitchen without reprogramming or to a human employee moving things around is interesting.
- mtsolitary 3y agoWouldn't you want your robot precisely designed to the spec of your kitchen as it throws hot oil around, rather than figuring it out on the fly with computer vision? As another commenter pointed out, robots have been frying potatoes at immense scale for decades, without a single LLM or AI in sight. Just "normal" computer programs can do it.
- bko 3y ago> After I left CaliExpress, I found myself driving to the closest McDonald’s, where I ordered another cheeseburger prepared by other humans. It was smaller, and the ingredients were clearly cheaper, but I found myself savoring the well-honed flavors of this drive-through classic. I wonder if the author eats at McDonald's regularly or just reserves her visits after eating at automated fast food vendors she's reviewing. In all seriousness, these kinds of articles fetishize human workers and read more like activist pieces arguing against tech. The tech journalist that hates tech is a phenomenon I noticed a while ago. I wrote about this before but here are 5 of the latest articles from a nyt tech journalist There’s Nothing to Like in Facebook’s Plans to Hook Our Kids The Maps That Steer Us Wrong Apple’s Illusion of Privacy Is Getting Harder to Sell Why Tesla’s ‘Beta Testing’ Puts the Public at Risk The Assault on Our Privacy Is Being Conducted in Private The articles can be summarized as Facebook bad, digital maps bad, Apple bad, Tesla bad and big-tech bad What other field has journalists covering it that absolutely hate everything about it? Why bother at this point? That's why YouTube personalities like mkbhd and Doug demuro are so popular because they honestly love the things they're reporting on. Who wants to read the umpteenth article about how meta is selling our data? https://mleverything.substack.com/p/journalism-shouldnt-be-so-professionalized https://mleverything.substack.com/p/journalism-shouldnt-be-s...
- throaway893 3y ago>What other field has journalists covering it that absolutely hate everything about it? Politics
- bko 3y agoAren't most journalists carrying water for certain politicians? Just look at the article Uri Berliner wrote on how politics affected their reporting. The journalists felt a need to cover up a story because it would negatively impact a favored politician of nearly everyone there https://www.thefp.com/p/npr-editor-how-npr-lost-americas-trust https://www.thefp.com/p/npr-editor-how-npr-lost-americas-tru...
- truculent 3y ago> The articles can be summarized as Facebook bad, digital maps bad, Apple bad, Tesla bad and big-tech bad Even from the headlines, it’s clear the criticism is more targeted than that. To generalise so aggressively is either bad faith (ironic, no?) or poor reading comprehension. Are youtube personalities journalists? Is it the job of journalists to be popular? Should it be?
- bko 3y agoSure but where's the article about how uber reduced drunk driving, made cabs stop ripping people off and profiling. Or how google maps liberated so many people to feel comfortable exploring new places? Or the million other benefits that these new technologies have. Why is everything negative? Imagine if science reporting didn't report on drug discoveries and just how new drugs are leading the inequity in healthcare outcomes between those that can afford them and those that cant
- luminen 3y agoIt's a lot easier to criticize than it is to create.
- matthewmacleod 3y ago
- alnwlsn 3y agoWhat's old[1] is new again. I guess with an AI to take your order, the last piece has been solved. Only took 60 years. [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FmXLqImT1wE https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FmXLqImT1wE
- 7373737373 3y agoI once witnessed a noodle making bot absolutely YEET a plate of spaghetti with sauce at the wall of its box. It went everywhere. Quite an amazing sight to behold. Also watching the humans having to clean up afterwards.
- heckelson 3y agoSo what you're saying is: Develop a noodle cleaning bot before you work on your noodle cooking bot? ;)
- badcppdev 3y agoI really like the word "yeet". 10 years old this month I think [0]. I really need to look up the origin sometime 0 - https://trends.google.com/trends/explore?date=all&q=yeet&hl=en https://trends.google.com/trends/explore?date=all&q=yeet&hl=...
- silverquiet 3y ago> But manning a grill – keeping track of burgers and cheese and buns and onions, and being able to flip the different objects at the proper time – turned out to be a tremendously sophisticated robotics problem, one too tricky for the startup to tackle I suppose if my software job gets automated out of existence, I can go to work flipping burgers.
- giraffe_lady 3y ago10+ years ago when I worked in fancy kitchens we would every once in a while get a white collar guy (always a guy) interested in changing careers to something they could be "passionate" about. I saw it work a couple times but never with tech people. We stopped even letting them try lol. They'd come in expecting to be in a position of authority, expecting us to be grateful for all the changes they'd immediately want to make to how we did things. To some extent this was also true of the other professionals. But they'd usually shake it once they got humbled by seeing up close how fast a good cook can actually shuck perfect oysters or just calmly handle the intensity of the line during dinner. Never saw a programmer adapt to it.
- akskakskaksk 3y agoOne of my former coworkers is now a high-end chef after he abruptly quit the company I was working at. He's married now and he seems happy.
- giraffe_lady 3y agoIt's cause he made all his money in tech first. It's a hard life otherwise.
- silverquiet 3y agoI never worked in a kitchen I'd remotely describe as fancy, but I've certainly worked a fast food kitchen or two. I know way better than to go to one looking for meaning; it'd strictly be more of a last-ditch paycheck thing for me at this point, and not an option I'd like to be forced into; that's for sure. Mostly I'm just disappointed that apparently we're determined to make humans toil in order to free up the robots to create art; I rather preferred the opposite vision.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- rhplus 3y agoThe absurdity of the fry robot is that they’re automating around cooking stations designed for humans, rather than modifying the cooking stations for automation. These are consistent processes that can be automated with repetition - conveyors and timers and such. We manage to fry millions of KGs of chips (crisps) around the world, and none use robotic arms to gently shuffle a fry basket in a small vat of oil.
- gordian_NOT 3y agoSeems like a “performance” is baked into the price. You’re right, surely there are better machine optimized methods of making fries.
- nubinetwork 3y agoAutomate the process, then scale up... doing both at the same time would probably cost more.
- noobermin 3y agoThen why don't you eat a tv dinner instead of getting McDonald's? That's what you're talking about.
- rhplus 3y agoParts of fast casual food really isn’t that different to a TV dinner already. Starbucks will literally just warm your breakfast sandwich in front of you using a combo-microwave. McDonald’s uses microwaves and warming ovens for certain items, that are literally just single prepackaged portions straight from the freezer. Even sit down chain restaurants like Applebees and Olive Garden will use microwaves and poaching to bring preprepared items to serving temperature. Not exactly TV dinners, but closer to that than from-scratch cooking.
- llm_trw 3y agoBecause you don't have to clean up after yourself.
- VyseofArcadia 3y ago
- DoreenMichele 3y ago[flagged]
- dogleash 3y agoWhy do jounos treat mundane incremental automation progress as dystopian, while casting the dystopian tech paradigm shifts as mundane?
- iamleppert 3y agoI worked for years at a KFC, all the way up to assistant manager. It was actually quite a challenging job, far harder than my senior software engineering role I have now. You have to manage at least 10 different products, and about 10 other variables such as labor and food cost and speed of service in real time, all while typically running a position yourself, and doing inventory in your down time. That said, the actual physical making of the food is a small and trivial part of any operation of a fast food restaurant and this robotic help would be laughed out of any kitchen I was in. Until the robots can do all of the tasks above and quickly switch from one to another and be highly adaptable in real time based on the needs of the restaurant, I think we’re okay. This tells me more the founders of this startup should have gone to work in a fast food restaurant before thinking they are smart enough to innovate it. This feels like ivory tower innovation at best.
- noobermin 3y agoPer the article, their original goal was to man a grill station but they realised it was far too difficult. Still, manning a deep fryer is possible apparently.
- iamleppert 3y agoDropping a fry bag is such a tiny part of what you do in a restaurant it’s almost a joke.
- throwaway35777 3y ago> Until the robots can do all of the tasks above and quickly switch from one to another and be highly adaptable in real time based on the needs of the restaurant Ideally if your robots cost less than $20/hour you can buy enough of them to do one job each.
- nine_k 3y agoPhysical space limitations may prevent you from cramming too many machines inside the restaurant.
- 3y ago
- analognoise 3y agoI'm not seeing anything here that would actually require anything like AI, this looks like old school industrial robotics, a little machine vision, and some basic scheduling - can anybody tell me what I'm missing here, or is it really all things that could been done 30+ years ago without issue?
- topher515 3y agoWhat is most interesting to me about automation in the restaurant industry, is its almost complete absence in the United States. If—as I understand it—labor costs dominate the cost structure of all restaurants, then why isn’t the average restaurant already mostly robots? Is it really a technology issue? We haven’t been able to build a burger making robot until today? Seems unlikely. Is it financial? The capital deployable to build a single restaurant can’t cover the initial costs of the robot? Seems like a McDonalds could spread the costs over thousands of restaurants. So what gives?
- llm_trw 3y agoWages for fast food workers compared to those of the people ordering the food. In most countries the wage spread between minimum wage and average wage is a lot lower than the one in the US. It makes no sense to automate something that your customers are happy to pay for.
- trelane 3y ago"Pay for it with your face?" At a burger joint?! As an occasional connoisseur of Nickelodeon's You Can't Do That on Television back in the day, I can only state that I hear the obvious punchline / catchphrase resounding loudly in my head: https://youtu.be/cATh91BYjjA?si=D6X97xDwZwff3izz https://youtu.be/cATh91BYjjA?si=D6X97xDwZwff3izz
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]