3 ms·
What does it mean to "keep" the software? You can return the installation media, and say you erased the program, without having erased it. I would say that if
by kazinator 3y ago
What does it mean to "keep" the software? You can return the installation media, and say you erased the program, without having erased it.
I would say that if you work for Microsoft and they give you a program free in order to test, then it's not a form of income. The program doesn't represent monetary value in that situation. Microsoft, the copyright holder, is licensing you to have a copy of that program under terms which do not involve exchange of money.
This interpretation could be strengthened if the medium were marked as not for sale or resale.
Something given to you cannot count as income if you cannot resell it, or not legally.
The interpretation could be further strengthened if the gifted software is not entitled to any support.
Now let's think about dual licensing. Suppose you can obtain a proprietary version of a program for $100, or you can get it free under a copyleft license. It's exactly the same program, just packaged with different licenses. Have you received $100 worth of income? Or is it nothing, because the free one comes with no support?
- tedunangst 3y agoEh, well, in this scenario they did keep the installation media, and Microsoft isn't in a position to add resale terms to other parties software, etc., etc. They are not the copyright holder.
- wodenokoto 3y ago> Something given to you cannot count as income if you cannot resell it, or not legally. That definition definitely doesn’t pass muster. You can gift employees Spotify accounts, in their name. Not resellable, definitely a gift.
- Kwpolska 3y ago> Microsoft, the copyright holder Nope. The entire point of this was testing third-party off-the-shelf software.
- bjornsing 3y agoThis sounds surprisingly logical to me as a Swede. Here you can be taxed for income even if you didn’t receive anything at all. Take for instance a company office with a canteen exclusively for employees. Let’s say the canteen charges 20% under market price for a meal. In that case the employees can be taxed for having access to that canteen, even if they don’t eat there. This access is considered a taxable income.
- mdekkers 3y ago> This access is considered a taxable income. Sounds like this meets the definition of racketeering
- tux3 3y agoThere is no coercion or deception in this situation, so it can't be racketeering. Unless you want to classify all taxation as an extortion racket. It's just a bad tax policy that creates weird incentives ("use the canteen even if you don't need it"). Let's keep the word racket for criminal enterprises and antivirus companies.
- mdekkers 3y agoNo coercion? Try not paying it.
- tux3 3y agoRight. But this position applies equally to all taxes. So that's a general "taxation is theft" type position. Which is fine in general, just not specific to this particular tax.
- mdekkers 3y agoI don’t believe all taxes are equal, or bad. But some are terrible, such as this one.
- tux3 3y agoI agree this one is terrible, but I don't think it's because this one is racketeering. If we think this tax is a racket, we should equally think that all taxes are a racket. That's because your "Try not paying it" argument applies to all taxes. If we think this tax is uniquely bad, there should be another reason that it's bad. Which is my point.
- michaelt 3y ago> Microsoft, the copyright holder, is licensing you to have a copy of that program under terms which do not involve exchange of money. As I recall, this anecdote is part of a larger story: * This was at a time where it was common to buy software in retail stores, it would come in a fancy cardboard box with a stack of floppy disks (or a CD-ROM), a printed manual, a warranty card you could mail in, and so on. * Microsoft wanted Windows 95 to have good compatibility so someone went to a software store and brought one copy of everything the store sold. * Then Microsoft handed these out to Windows 95 testers and told them "You can have this for free if you report any bugs you encounter" * The employees received (and got to keep) the physical box, installation media, manual etc. > I would say that if you work for Microsoft and they give you a program free in order to test, then it's not a form of income. Tax authorities have fairly strict (and complicated) rules about this sort of thing, to stop companies/employees dodging income tax using 'free' gifts. If I could give my employees a $50k cash bonus and it got taxed at 24% or I could gift them a $50k car "for testing" and it was tax free, everyone would be getting paid in cars.
- bombcar 3y agoIt’s exactly that - the IRS doesn’t want people bypassing taxes via weird gift freebie methods. So if it’s not much and it’s not regular, they don’t really care.
- kazinator 3y agoBecause the state wants people's wealth to be like a bar of soap; every time it changes hands, a little comes off. During one year, the same dollar might circulate, becoming part of twelve people's income. The state gets a slice from each one, even though it's the same dollar.
- ProblemFactory 3y ago> If I could give my employees a $50k cash bonus and it got taxed at 24% or I could gift them a $50k car "for testing" and it was tax free, everyone would be getting paid in cars. Belgium has exactly that (use of a car is tax-free) and as a result company cars are wildly popular. Getting rid of this tax loophole has been unpopular, but as a compromise they will only apply it to electric cars in the future.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]