3 ms·
I'm as glad as anyone else to see an abusive company get some scrutiny, B U T . . . Everyone is complaining about Ticketmaster but they're still giving them th
by ryandrake 3y ago
I'm as glad as anyone else to see an abusive company get some scrutiny, B U T . . .
Everyone is complaining about Ticketmaster but they're still giving them their money, so how are they supposed to respond? They are not being financially incentivized to change their ways. This feels a lot like the video gamer who hates Video Game Company XYZ with the passion of a thousand suns, yet like clockwork buys their video games again and again.
Show tickets aren't even a necessity. They're not like food and water--nobody has to buy them. Each and every dollar Ticketmaster collects is from a fan making a voluntary purchase of a luxury. Purchasing from a company that abuses them.
- JumpCrisscross 3y ago> Everyone is complaining about Ticketmaster but they're still giving them their money, so how are they supposed to respond? This is why monopoly is a market failure. There isn't a market mechanism that can correct this.
- failuser 3y agoPotentially, a big player with money to burn can undercut them, but it does not look like that’s going to happen.
- JumpCrisscross 3y ago> a big player with money to burn can undercut them Unclear. There are limited cities that can support a 30,000+-seat stadium. Most of them have some already. Unless there is way more demand for these venues than I realise, I'd also guess they're close to saturation, i.e. adding another venue would result in lower utilisation. This natural monopoly in large concert venues creates a condition where winning is Pyrrhic, since it results in no profits for everyone playing.
- failuser 3y agoTake losses, unseat the current monopolist, take their place.
- dugite-code 3y agoI believe a big problem is many venues have either lock in contracts, or are outright owned by live nation directly or indirectly.
- kxrm 3y ago> Potentially, a big player with money to burn can undercut them I guarantee you that Ticketmaster's pockets are much deeper. They have entrenched themselves. This romantic notion that consumers should strike against situations like this or that smaller players should find edges in are just not realistic to me because of the entrenchment, coercion and scarcity at play here. A very popular band in the 90s tried to fight Ticketmaster. They failed. So I just don't understand this narrative in the face of all the evidence that these tactics just don't or won't work. https://news.yahoo.com/1994-pearl-jam-took-ticketmaster-230031845.html https://news.yahoo.com/1994-pearl-jam-took-ticketmaster-2300...
- failuser 3y agoI’m talking about someone like a big venture capital fund or a big bank. Or someone like Saudis. That’s a lucrative field. Ironically, any company doing this will want to take the place of monopoly, not increase competition in the long run.
- kxrm 3y agoI don't see it. There are far better investments than going after Ticketmaster. As soon as you enter this market you are fighting a giant that has a $1 Billion war chest not to mention very favorable venue holdings that they can immediately use as leverage to destroy you.
- nektro 3y agototally agree. I think one other angle to potentially consider is that, like many other things in the industry, this has an outsized impact on smaller artists. singers make most of their money through touring so fans might be more inclined to wade through live nation's scheming in order to support artists with a smaller base.
- doctorpangloss 3y agoSmaller artists don't make any money. There is no long tail. There's no working artist. For every 1 person you are thinking of, in the 10k to 300k monthly listeners range, there are 19 who are taking money they inherited or earned somewhere else, and transferring it to "music," and sometimes that transfer winds up as surplus to their fans, and sometimes that transfer goes to Spotify and LiveNation/Ticketmaster. You could abruptly stop going to shows of smaller artists, and nothing would economically change. It's a complete fantasy. I mean, it's an attractive narrative, it has some arithmetic to it, but c'mon, this is the status quo for all non-guilded creatives: the money that they earn is so little, it doesn't really matter. It matters from the point of view of the aesthetics of being A Consumer Who Supports Small Artists, but it doesn't matter economically in any sense. Breaking up LiveNation/Ticketmaster would wreck the biggest artists, not little ones. Really we should be asking: What has Taylor Swift done for small artists? Whom has she featured on her tracks? Ed Sheeran, Bon Iver, Brendon Urie, Haim, Maren Morris... You might not have heard of Maren Morris, but she has millions of monthly listeners on Spotify. The problem with what the Justice Department is proposing has similar energy to many of their efforts in the creative industries: they don't know what their fucking side is. They think it's "consumers." Man, if only it were so simple.
- throw87468592 3y ago[flagged]
- Clent 3y agoWhen did seeing a live event become a luxury? Live events have been the norm throughout history. The fact that it can now be classified as a luxury speaks to the need for drastic change.
- JumpCrisscross 3y ago> When did seeing a live event become a luxury? Live events have been the norm throughout history As a luxury. Put on by a Roman politician running for office, or as a rare treat travelling through town. Also, caveat: TicketMaster has a monopoly on ultra-large venues. You can see small bands and plays without ever touching TM.
- anthonypasq 3y agopeople somehow feel like the they have right to see a Taylor Swift concert for $40 but if you suggested that SuperBowl tickets should be $40 everyone would look at you like youre crazy. Seeing a live event is not a luxury. Seeing the most popular entertainer in the world in a giant stadium is a luxury.
- selectodude 3y agoSure, but the economist would say that Taylor Swift should have made every penny of the $300 ticket cost. Live Nation getting even a penny is the market failure, not the cost of the ticket itself.
- lotsofpulp 3y agoWhy would the economist say that? If Taylor swift made every penny, then what reason would the business that operates the venue have to operate?
- bombcar 3y agoSome people would like to see all the ticket money go to Taylor, and then she pays for the venue, credit card fees, and such herself. As it is, those get funneled off earlier in the process, and people get annoyed.
- kxrm 3y ago> Everyone is complaining about Ticketmaster but they're still giving them their money, so how are they supposed to respond? They are not being financially incentivized to change their ways. That's a monopoly. The actual product being a luxury item has no bearing on whether a business practice is damaging to consumers. If I have no other choice but to buy tickets for a show through TM, I can't easily avoid them to choose a better service. Frankly breaking up Ticket Master is something that should have been looked into decades ago.
- ryandrake 3y agoYou have a choice to not buy the ticket. This is like hating De Beers yet buying diamonds from them. Monopoly on a non-necessity: anyone can opt out. If they are breaking the law, the government should throw the book at them and yea they should have done it long ago, but also people should stop giving money to a company they hate, regardless of whether they are a monopoly.
- kxrm 3y ago> You have a choice to not buy the ticket. This is like hating De Beers yet buying diamonds from them. Monopoly on a non-necessity: anyone can opt out. I fundamentally disagree with your characterization of a consumer's options. Is your argument that I should have the fortitude and knowledge to opt out of coercive economic relationships? Why should I, as the consumer, bare the brunt of the responsibility for holding a corporation responsible for their misdeeds when they utilize their scale and volume to nullified my actions? Do I, as an individual, have any sway over corporate decision making when my fellow consumers do not have that fortitude or knowledge? I do not agree that every scenario of corporate abuse should fall on the consumer to hold the corporation accountable because we are on unequal footing. This is regardless of the product being offered. These particular companies are taking advantage of shell games to keep customers in the dark on how they are being abused. I, as a simple consumer, withdrawing my dollars have no weight on the scale. You really should read up on how Pearl Jam tried to fight Ticket Master in the 90s and lost popularity because they were effectively unable to host a show for years. If Pearl Jam wasn't able to defeat Ticket Master, I find it laughable that you think individual consumers have any more weight in this matter.
- newsclues 3y agoThe luxury of happiness.
- pixl97 3y agoI mean no... There is no reason to behave like we exist in a low trust economy for any non-essential service when these 'non-essential' services are a massive portion of our total GDP. Really, to follow your over libertarian line of thought it would be ok to say "Oreo's don't need to follow food safety laws because Oreo's aren't a necessity, you can buy bread and water". Instead we apply food safety laws to all food products so you don't play cancer russian roulette. And the same should go for service transactions. I shouldn't have to find out that the one company that seems to own all venues is a monopolistic bastard that will fuck you over. Instead I should elect a representative government that punishes the living fuck out of companies that try to behave like that so the general consumer saves massive amounts of time and money thereby benefiting society.
- qwertygnu 3y agoApologizing on behalf of exploitation is unbelievably weak. What do you like to do? Bike? What if one company controlled all bike sales and bike lanes, bikes costed $20,000 and you needed to pay every time you go on a ride? Programming? What if one company controlled all computer sales and internet access, they costed $50/hour to use and each program is another $10/hour and it costed another $200/month to host anything publicly?
- doctorpangloss 3y agoThere are people in the comments here giving you a hard time. I agree with you. People are talking about Oreos and biking and shit. You know, Oreos have calories, bikes move you around the world. Just don't buy the fucking tickets anymore. It's that simple. There are a million ways to monetize. If you stop going to live shows music won't die. Maybe huge pop acts will.
- crabmusket 3y agoSo I should... punish the artists I like as a protest against a monopoly they are not responsible for?
- blahedo 3y agoI don't buy tickets from them. I'd like to go to shows, and I do go to some smaller shows where I can buy tickets directly from the venue. But I don't support Ticketmaster. So I go to less shows than I like. ...does that make me more morally qualified to complain than other people? Why?