5 ms·
ISPs can charge extra for fast gaming under FCC's Internet rules, critics say
- ado__dev 3y agoRIP Internet of old. The Internet is truly going to shit from all angles. Squeezed by ever rising costs to get on the net. Bombarded by ads on every single page (trying to browse the net on a mobile device and most sites take up 40-50% of screen real estate on ads). Subs on top of subs for every single service. We really are entering a dark era.
- tester756 3y agoConsider using Firefox + some kind of adblock
- spartanatreyu 3y agoFirefox and uBlock Origin on Android are amazing. Sometimes I'll randomly open something with Chrome by mistake and just seeing 70% of the article filled with pop-up ads makes my brain just shuts down thinking about regular people.
- lupire 3y agoExcept that Firefox + uBlock renders many, many websites and apps poorly.
- bsjaux628 3y agoAnd still a better experience than chrome with ads, plus I almost never encounter a website with problems
- hedora 3y agoI haven't hit any real problems with Firefox. Maybe it's the sites I visit. Mostly news, shopping, and tech stuff. The only real exception I can think of is that Google Meet's audio quality has recently been worse under Firefox than under Safari's. My guess is that the issue is on Google's end (since Firefox used to be fine), or that maybe Safari has access to some special microphone APIs.
- gordonfish 3y agoSince you mentioned Safari, I assume that you're on MacOS where Firefox and other alternative browsers are effectively hindered at the framework/API level there, as such browsers have problems there that don't occur Linux or Windows. For example, the audio in FF outside of Apple sounds real clear and overall great in my experience.
- tarxvf 3y agoI can't think of a single one where Firefox and uBO cause issues.
- MathMonkeyMan 3y agoIt renders them correctly, just not always exactly the same as Chrome. It's hard to blame devs for not testing on a browser with so little market share. Some Javascript or maybe Canvas heavy pages run much more slowly on Firefox and are almost unusable on Firefox for Android. I find that this is rare, though. I'll keep using Firefox + uBlock + Personal Blocklist + Dark Reader + Disable Javascript + Disable CSS + Tampermonkey + Old Reddit Redirect + CORS Everywhere + Consent-O-Matic + Hide YouTube Shorts + Load Reddit Images Directly + ...
- asadotzler 3y agoI find that 99%+ of sites render far better in Firefox with uBlock Origin than with Chrome. Pages render prettier, faster, and more readable. The 1% of pages that render worse are still faster and generally more readable if not quite as pretty. That's a trade I'll make any day.
- gordonfish 3y agoI have yet to encounter a site, that wasn't broken server side in some way, that didn't render usefully. Please cite some actual examples.
- spartanatreyu 3y agoHave you got any examples, because this has not been my experience at all. Not even in the slightest.
- xinayder 3y agoUnfortunately, Firefox on Android still has a long way to go. I have to resort to using Chromite (Bromite fork) with NextDNS for adblocking, otherwise the browsing experience on mobile is not really good.
- screamingninja 3y agoTry NextDNS: https://nextdns.io/ https://nextdns.io/
- gamepsys 3y agoWe must be on different internets. The one I'm on is having a golden era. * My current ISP offers greater than 1000/1000 fiber for a smaller monthly payment than my first home broadband connection in 2003. Adjust for inflation it's probably 1/2 the cost while being over 50 times better. It's incomparable to the dial up before then. * I don't see a lot of ads on the internet. If I see an ad on a website I either upgrade my adblock or I stop going to that website. * I don't have a ton of subscription services. If you were to tally my subscription services and weigh them against what I previously used for competing services I am saving a ton of money. Cable TV, DVDs, and CDs were expensive. * It's so casual and fun to jump on a voice call with a group of friends to play a game, or someone shares a screen of an anime and we have a little movie night. It's so easy to see what games my friends are playing. It's so easy to watch any movie I want, or listen to any song that I want, or play any game I want. The tools to have fun online are way better than ever. * It's possible to learn about anything I am curious about. You can do everything, from getting a highschool level lecture to read the latest research from the top researchers. I often find experts willing to answer my questions, even though I am coming in as a complete stranger. * I absolutely love the move towards more independent publishing. The number of interesting people I follow on twitter, or youtube, or watch on twitch is insane. Before the internet media felt like a monoculture with everyone watching the same 40 channels on TV every night. I'm subscribed to indie newsletters instead of magazines. I'm watching Starcraft 2 tournaments instead of the superbowl. Some of this was around before the internet, but it's much more now and the long term trend is looking great. * I can get involved in so many interesting conversations, and I rarely have problems finding interesting conversations to listen in on or join in on. People from all walks of life, with all kinds of perspectives.
- squigz 3y agoWhile I agree with you that the Internet is not in such a dark place as some people think, I will play devil's advocate and make a couple points in regard to what you said: - If the industry gets its way, adblockers will become illegal or practically unusable. - I get the impression you don't shy away from pirating. For those that don't engage in it, for one reason or another, it's a lot harder to e.g., watch any movie they want. What service is it? How much? Is it available in your country? Is something you saw was on there last week still there? Etc. This also generally applies to most other forms of media (games, music, etc) - Screensharing for movie nights and such is slowly becoming more difficult, as more services implement DRM which disables capturing video (or even screenshots?!) from a stream Again, I don't agree that the Internet is dying, or it's become a "monoculture," or anything like that - but we do have to be wary of the direction some groups would love to take it.
- ZoomerCretin 3y agoThis opens the door wide enough for extortion and the end of net neutrality, and for this to happen again: > Second, that the company repeatedly promised reliable, “no buffering,” “no lag” internet, especially to services like Netflix or to online games like League of Legends, but was in fact purposefully letting the interconnections between TWC and outside companies degrade to an alarming degree — unless the companies, like Netflix, were willing to start paying for access to TWC customers. > https://nymag.com/intelligencer/2017/02/time-warner-cable-lawsuit-says-twc-lied-about-internet-speed.html https://nymag.com/intelligencer/2017/02/time-warner-cable-la...
- transpute 3y agoWhich service tier would apply to ssh/vpn traffic?
- ronsor 3y agoPremium Max Business Plus tier only, starting at $399/month for 50GB of uncapped speed data
- dartos 3y agoI remember having a cellphone in 2009 too.
- supertrope 3y agoRight now they segment plans based on video throttling. Once Net Neutrality is gone they could just “deprioritize” all non-sponsored traffic into oblivion. Then treat any encrypted traffic the same way since they wouldn’t be able to confirm sponsorship status via DPI. https://www.att.com/support/article/wireless/KM1169198 https://www.att.com/support/article/wireless/KM1169198 https://www.t-mobile.com/support/plans-features/activate-hd-video-streaming https://www.t-mobile.com/support/plans-features/activate-hd-... https://www.verizon.com/support/important-plan-information/ https://www.verizon.com/support/important-plan-information/
- Jhsto 3y agoThe title seems to not include that this is about 5G. The next question then is how many gamers really use mobile broadband in the US? Ericsson making the claim that people are willing to pay more for low latency might be the case in the Nordics where uncapped mobile broadband starts from 3 euros/m and fiber is not always available.
- hedora 3y agoThe telephone companies in the US have been pretty aggressively lobbying to drop universal service mandates. From what I can tell, they spent the last few decades deferring maintenance and lining executive pockets. Now they don't want to pay for the deferred maintenance. Anyway, one argument they make is that people can use 5G for their home broadband. From what I've seen, that doesn't actually work in practice. Even though there are cell towers, once the telcos pull out, there's nothing to plug the cell tower into, so you end up with lots of 5G bars, but 2G speeds. Either way, it's a good story, and it helps extract more profits.
- xyst 3y agoThere used to (currently?) be a revolving door between bank regulators and banking industry. Bank regulators would “retire” after a deregulation push then banking industry would so happen to hire that same person as some midlevel executive or director. GS was infamous for this [1] Wonder if we see the same between telcos/major ISPs and FCC [1] https://web.archive.org/web/20140220160810/http://www.nytimes.com/2008/10/19/business/19gold.html https://web.archive.org/web/20140220160810/http://www.nytime... [2] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Revolving_door_(politics) https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Revolving_door_(politics)
- wmf 3y agoAjit Pai went from DOJ antitrust to Verizon back to DOJ and then to the FCC.
- supertrope 3y agoAn FCC commissioner voted for the NBC Comcast merger and then took a job at Comcast. https://archive.nytimes.com/mediadecoder.blogs.nytimes.com/2011/05/13/f-c-c-commissioner-defends-taking-comcast-job/ https://archive.nytimes.com/mediadecoder.blogs.nytimes.com/2...
- 0xcde4c3db 3y agoI find NN to be a tricky issue because the devil is very much in the details, and the history of "platforms" and "networks" in the abstract is a rich text (especially viz. some pretty obnoxious examples of brinkmanship where multiple parties were all convinced that they were the pivotal gatekeeper to the audience/customer base, e.g. [1]) . I don't think there's necessarily a problem with having multiple service tiers where low latency/jitter or high throughput is only guaranteed on a higher tier. But if the network is rigged so that low-tier customers get a bad experience even in low-demand conditions, there's almost certainly some unethical fuckery going on. Basically, there's probably some point where "best effort" needs to be imposed as a baseline rather than a premium option. [1] https://www.latimes.com/archives/blogs/company-town-blog/story/2008-12-30/viacom-threatens-to-yank-programming-off-time-warner-cable-systems https://www.latimes.com/archives/blogs/company-town-blog/sto...
- lupire 3y agoThere's nothing fundamentally wrong with charging more for a better product, even if you are capable of delivering that product to more people. McDonald's doesn't owe its fries customers free burgers just because the burgers are going stale soon. The problem is when there is no effective market for price competition. With a competitive market, prices will naturally drop to approximately efficient resource allocation
- alliao 3y agojust like the texas electric grid right? poster child of free market infrastructure
- convolvatron 3y agoassuming there is a fixed-size pipe owned by a third party which doesn't use statistical multiplexinging, with open access rules to logical providers that charge for things like QOS and transit...then sure. otherwise you're talking about a spherical cow
- orbisvicis 3y agoIt's a bit like health insurance. Instead of grouping everyone into a big bucket and charging the average price, you start classifying people in smaller and smaller buckets: sex, age, weight, family history, genetics, parent's genetics, history of illness, occupation, zip code, building age, hobbies, partner's hobbies ... until you are basically subsidizing yourself plus a cut for the middleman. And McDonald's can charge more for people who roll through the drive-thru in expensive cars, then do a soft-pull through the payment processor, then pay a 3rd party for your current income, then get your credit score, then scan your twitter history for controversial posts, then lower prices for customers who spend equally at Burger King, then raise prices for people who are bad for the bottom line such those who vote for more govt regulation... or maybe democrats in general. I mean, the goal is to maximize profits, so there's nothing wrong with that. Everybody needs individualized probing to determine the price they can bear as individuals. That's market competition for you - efficient resource extraction.
- rowanG077 3y agoAnd so the enshittification of your connection to the internet begins.
- Madmallard 3y agoGames require very low bandwidth. They just require stability. So what are the ISPs even going to do? Just worsen the experience intentionally if you don’t pay more? This is late stage capitalism garbage.
- Avamander 3y agoThey'll deprioritise/QoS its traffic to hell by default. I'd suspect many do so for streaming services already. Which is relatively fair (for those gaming for example) but QoS is such a double-edged sword.
- Madmallard 3y agoQoS?
- Avamander 3y agoQuality of Service
- mminer237 3y ago1. That exact behavior is what the criticized draft order does ban. 2. Unless the cell tower is already overloaded, that wouldn't even matter, would it? 3. Even if it is overloaded, if everyone is deprioritized, nobody would be. Even if they prioritized gaming, that's not going to noticeably affect anyone else. The way I see it, even if cellular companies found a way to implement this, it would only affect people to the extent they're not already giving QoS priority to gamers. And gaming is pretty indistinguishable from a voice call anyway, so they would have to break that at the same time.
- mminer237 3y agoThey aren't even allowed to make things worse, only better. This seems like pointless fear-mongering. Even if they don't care what people think, I can't imagine a practical way for this to affect anything.
- 3y ago
- Alupis 3y agoBefore people cry about the falling sky - read the article. This is specifically about 5G Connections, largely impacting mobile phones and those few who have 5G home internet connections (I pity you). With that said - many of you already pay for "enhanced" video over cellular data connections - and few gripe about it. I'm all for open, dumb pipes and all, but the mobile device space is very crowded as it is, and it's really not a lot of fun to have Google Maps fail to load when you're in a crowded area because a ton of people are posting on Instagram or playing Fruit Ninja.
- cellwebb 3y agoimo it doesn’t matter if the article is about 5G. This will come to home internet connections before you know it.
- tavavex 3y ago> This is specifically about 5G Connections, largely impacting mobile phones and those few who have 5G home internet connections (I pity you). What difference does it make? If they're allowed to deprioritize certain connections over 5G, how long until they're allowed to do it over any connection? And I've never heard of "enhanced video over data" - is that a US only thing? > and it's really not a lot of fun to have Google Maps fail to load when you're in a crowded area because a ton of people are posting on Instagram or playing Fruit Ninja. You have very mixed messaging - first you say that it only affects some types of connections (with the implication that it's a bad thing, but at least it won't affect everyone), but now you're turning around to say it's a good thing, actually. The reason why we should advocate for ISPs to be blind to whether someone's using Instagram or Google Maps is because, if they're not, it won't be used for the benefit of the consumer like you imagine. It will be immediately used to segment the internet into pieces and charge customers separately for it, as just another way of squeezing more money.
- Alupis 3y ago> And I've never heard of "enhanced video over data" - is that a US only thing? Most budget carriers in the US, and even some plans on premium carriers only serve 720p video unless you get a higher tier plan. The reasons are data consumption. > You have very mixed messaging - first you say that it only affects some types of connections (with the implication that it's a bad thing, but at least it won't affect everyone), but now you're turning around to say it's a good thing, actually. QoS is a good thing. If you talk on a VOIP phone, you reasonably expect the other person to hear you clearly - not garbled and choppy. On congested networks, sometimes the network has to decide which packets to drop or slow down. They can do it indiscriminately, or they can do it by need, with realtime communications clearly being a higher priority than a large file upload for example. QoS is nothing new, and it's likely already done by your ISP. > It will be immediately used to segment the internet into pieces and charge customers separately for it, as just another way of squeezing more money. Then, I wonder, why it has not already been done? ISP's have been free to do this since day one of the internet. Why just now? The ideas around "net neutrality" are complex, and unfortunately don't mean the same thing to two different people. Fearmongering about some dystopian future internet has got a lot of people's feathers ruffled, mostly over nothing in my opinion. It's not unreasonable for ISP's in general to charge people based on consumption. We already do this with bandwidth, after all. However, until the day where egress traffic is entirely free, there is costs associated with consumption in both terms of bandwidth and data size. Networks have finite bandwidth, and the faster someone's connection is and the more data they consume, the more of these finite resources they prevent other customers from accessing.
- alliao 3y agoThey're just going to keep try and obsolete net neutrality every couple of years aren't they?
- tavavex 3y ago1. Propose outrageous changes 2. Face public backlash 3. Roll back your plans 4. Wait a few years, repeat steps 1-3 and face slightly less backlash every time - eventually it's gonna work out for you and then we're never going back
- tomohawk 3y agoEmergency responders need higher reliability and priority, even when the network is degraded. That is something that costs more to provide. Those who need such things need to fund it, and not just expect they'll get such service with consumer grade plan/equipment. Police don't drive consumer grade vehicles, they pony up for a vehicle meant for the job. Several years ago, emergency personnel in california were dismayed when their consumer grade plan didn't give them good service in an emergency. There was a big stink about it, but requiring the provider to eat the cost when the government doesn't pay for what they need is short sighted. Those emergency personnel were unprepared, and they tried to shift blame for their foolhardiness. It may be possible to give everyone the same emergency grade service for the same price, but that price will be extremely high. It may be possible to give everyone the same low jitter, low latency experience that gamers want, but the cost will be higher for people who don't care about such things.