3 ms·
The analysis of the DMCA Safe Harbor status in this article is incorrect. Subsection (a) -- "Transitory Digital Network Communications" -- is just one of four d
by duskwuff 15y ago
The analysis of the DMCA Safe Harbor status in this article is incorrect. Subsection (a) -- "Transitory Digital Network Communications" -- is just one of four distinct ways in which a service provider can qualify for Safe Harbor status. (The author is correct only in that it doesn't apply to Pinterest.) Of the three others, the most relevant for Pinterest is subsection (c), "Information Residing on Systems or Networks At Direction of Users".
In any case, links are not copyrightable works, so the fact that Pinterest is modifying them to alter or remove affiliate tags is most likely irrelevant.
Read the whole thing for details: https://images.chillingeffects.org/512.html https://images.chillingeffects.org/512.html
- jakeludington 15y agoA link doesn't need to be a copyrightable work for the "material" posted by a user to be considered altered. What matters is how a court defines "material" and whether or not the court would define that "material" as modified by the service provider or not.