2 ms·
"It could be read to say that computers should be presumed to be executing the instructions they're given reliably, unless evidence shows otherwise. It's about
by graemep 3y ago
"It could be read to say that computers should be presumed to be executing the instructions they're given reliably, unless evidence shows otherwise. It's about malfunction, not misapplication."
You are making a technical distinction the law does not make. The law relates to the output - to the evidence generated from the system as a whole. The presumption is that the logic is correct too - which is why it is such a terrible assumption.
- kemitchell 3y agoWhere do statutes or court decisions say that? To my eye, none of the authorities quoted in the article do. It's merely implied.
- fanf2 3y agoRight. In the specific case of the Post Office miscarriages of justice, the system as a whole included Horizon central office staff who made manual and sometimes incorrect adjustments to the individual Post Office ledgers, and the discrepancies were later blamed on the postmasters.