3 ms·
Here's [1] a very relevant article from 2018 explaining what was probably going on in more detail. --- When [Japan's consumption tax] was last increased in 20
by somenameforme 3y ago
Here's [1] a very relevant article from 2018 explaining what was probably going on in more detail.
---
When [Japan's consumption tax] was last increased in 2014, to 8% from 5%, smuggling of [gold] jumped as criminal organizations quickly realized how to game the system for their own enrichment.
The scheme works like this: Procure gold in places like Hong Kong, which does not tax it. Have mules hide it in their luggage and blend in with tourists, traveling to Japan to sell to stores that buy gold from the public. The stores pay for both the gold itself and the consumption tax. The tax component becomes pure profit.
And with the consumption tax set to rise to 10% in October 2019, margins will grow even fatter. Japan has an unflattering reputation as a "go-to place" for gold smugglers.
---
[1] - https://asia.nikkei.com/Economy/Japan-braces-for-gold-smuggling-rush-in-shadows-of-tax-hike https://asia.nikkei.com/Economy/Japan-braces-for-gold-smuggl...
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- jsnell 3y agoThis explanation doesn't make any sense to me. The business model of stores buying gold is to pay below the market price. If their nominal price+taxes paid to the seller ends up higher than the above the market price, the business isn't profitable, and they'd stop buying.
- ace32229 3y agoThey can claim the tax back from the government when they sell it.
- arshbot 3y agoCould the gov tell there’s a discrepancy in taxes paid and taxes reimbursed?
- bennyhill 3y agoRight, the stores would actually pay a little less than market value+tax on any "presumed used" gold. Charging taxes on a consumer resale is hard and unpopular as it is double taxation, the only example I can think of is weird places with house sale stamp taxes and such.