3 ms·

I know that hacker news frequently dislikes Blockchain but this comment is accurate and relevant and there’s no reason to downvote it.

by nailer 3y ago

ceejayoz 3y ago
"This crime would've been way easier to get away with using Bitcoin" isn't the huge positive endorsement the parent poster implies.
- janandonly 3y ago
  Transporting value across borders is what Bitcoin routinely does, and quite well too: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39520886 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39520886 And if you want to force Afghan refugees (for example) to return and pay their taxes to the Taliban, then I don't know how to respond to that. Bitcoin gives people freedom, as you can read more about here: https://hrf.org/hrf-op-ed-why-central-bank-digital-currencies-cant-compete-with-bitcoin/ https://hrf.org/hrf-op-ed-why-central-bank-digital-currencie...
  - CrazyStat 3y ago
    > And if you want to force Afghan refugees (for example) to return and pay their taxes to the Taliban, then I don't know how to respond to that. This is such an absurd straw man.
  - ceejayoz 3y ago
    Cool. When you enter Japan with $10M in gold, their democratically elected government has opted to charge an import tax. That is one of their freedoms as a sovereign nation. edit: Post above originally said "One country's crime is another country's freedom" instead.
    - QuarterReptile 3y ago
      This incident almost certainly revolves around capital controls in China, with the Japanese infraction only being collateral damage justified by the China problem.
      - ceejayoz 3y ago
        Are you of the opinion that, upon arrival in Japan, the smugglers would've disclosed the gold and gone "phew, here's your $1M we owe in tax"?
paxys 3y ago
How is it accurate? If you have $10M worth of gold in country A and want to get it into country B without paying the 10% import tax, how does Bitcoin help?
- Cthulhu_ 3y ago
  - Sell $10M gold for the sum of $10M - Buy $10M worth of Bitcoin - Transfer $10M worth of Bitcoin to country B, or just travel to country B - Convert $10M worth of Bitcoin to local currency That said, you'd have to do all the conversion of BTC to fiat through shady channels, as by now all of the legal / above ground exchanges report every transfer to the local and international tax offices. Second, any conversion will charge a percentage. In theory, BTC travels freely across borders without import taxes. In practice, it's useless if not converted to fiat, and all conversions are logged and taxed.

I know that hacker news frequently dislikes Blockchain but this comment is accurate and relevant and there’s no reason to downvote it.

by nailer 3y ago

I know that hacker news frequently dislikes Blockchain but this comment is accurate and relevant and there’s no reason to downvote it.

ceejayoz 3y ago

"This crime would've been way easier to get away with using Bitcoin" isn't the huge positive endorsement the parent poster implies.

janandonly 3y ago
Transporting value across borders is what Bitcoin routinely does, and quite well too: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39520886 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39520886 And if you want to force Afghan refugees (for example) to return and pay their taxes to the Taliban, then I don't know how to respond to that. Bitcoin gives people freedom, as you can read more about here: https://hrf.org/hrf-op-ed-why-central-bank-digital-currencies-cant-compete-with-bitcoin/ https://hrf.org/hrf-op-ed-why-central-bank-digital-currencie...
- CrazyStat 3y ago
  > And if you want to force Afghan refugees (for example) to return and pay their taxes to the Taliban, then I don't know how to respond to that. This is such an absurd straw man.
- ceejayoz 3y ago
  Cool. When you enter Japan with $10M in gold, their democratically elected government has opted to charge an import tax. That is one of their freedoms as a sovereign nation. edit: Post above originally said "One country's crime is another country's freedom" instead.
  - QuarterReptile 3y ago
    This incident almost certainly revolves around capital controls in China, with the Japanese infraction only being collateral damage justified by the China problem.
    - ceejayoz 3y ago
      Are you of the opinion that, upon arrival in Japan, the smugglers would've disclosed the gold and gone "phew, here's your $1M we owe in tax"?

paxys 3y ago

How is it accurate? If you have $10M worth of gold in country A and want to get it into country B without paying the 10% import tax, how does Bitcoin help?

Cthulhu_ 3y ago
- Sell $10M gold for the sum of $10M - Buy $10M worth of Bitcoin - Transfer $10M worth of Bitcoin to country B, or just travel to country B - Convert $10M worth of Bitcoin to local currency That said, you'd have to do all the conversion of BTC to fiat through shady channels, as by now all of the legal / above ground exchanges report every transfer to the local and international tax offices. Second, any conversion will charge a percentage. In theory, BTC travels freely across borders without import taxes. In practice, it's useless if not converted to fiat, and all conversions are logged and taxed.