9 ms·
Psychiatric risks for worsened mental health after psychedelic use
- yieldcrv 3y ago> We find that 16% of the cohort falls into the “negative responder” subset. “they should have known they had a family history of schizophrenia before using it!” every dismissive psychedelic user that brags about increased empathy in the next breath but in all seriousness, yes I would like to see more studies so we can at least have side effects printed on the side of the package, so the right people can take informed risks
- moneycantbuy 3y agoso 84% had a positive response?
- jjallen 3y ago84% positive and 16% worsened mental health is not the same thing as 84% and the rest neutral or mild side effects.
- mikeyouse 3y agoNo.. 16% had a negative response, 28% had ~no response, and 55% had a positive response. I think people would be much more hesitant to try psychedelics for their mental issues if you told them it was a coin toss whether it would help or not -- and was an unlucky game of Russian Roulette from making their mental problems worse.
- bennyhill 3y agoPeople take prescribed drugs for less than a 25% chance that it helps and a Russian roulette of side effects. Does sexual dysfunction improve depression?
- yieldcrv 3y agoI, for one, would like the same standard applied to psychedelics, instead of worrying about whether bad results lead to its continued prohibition It seems that right now people are too worried about a bad result messing up their ability to talk casually about their trips I just want side effects to be based on less conjecture science lets its beliefs die, faithful die with their beliefs right now, psychonauts seem to be in the latter group and its not helping the science form at all
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- jrflowers 3y agoThis makes sense because people that have used psychedelics sharing their positive experiences are the bad guys and people that have used psychedelics sharing their negative experiences are the good guys
- yieldcrv 3y agousing anyone as a source for side effects is a dumb standard and we should reach parity with how other drugs are studied just like this study is trying to chisel at while psychedelic communities are uniquely dismissive
- jrflowers 3y agoExactly! People that say that they’ve benefited from psychedelics are uniquely dismissive and people that say that those people form a uniquely dismissive community that should be distrusted are not uniquely dismissive
- yieldcrv 3y agointeresting commenting strategy, its as if its supposed to spark introspection by strawmanning absolutes that nobody said to discredit their position, while feigning agreement with them oddly consistent in your other recent posts dang, is this substantive to you?
- mistermann 3y agoAt least there's one thing everyone can agree on: what seems to be true is true.
- fleshmonad 3y agoUnironirally this. Whenever taking drugs of any kind, but especially with one's that meddle with your reality. There is no excuse for not doing your research. Your consciousness is all you have
- otherme123 3y agoThing is research has been extremely hindered in the last ~100 years. At least they are trying to do their research instead of going blindly "psychedelics bad, make you jump from roofs and stare at the sun. Take this thingy-zepam for years instead, known to turn you into a zombie, increase the risk of suicide, create dependency and tolerance, and have withdrawal".
- uniqueuid 3y agoI find the design and results somewhat underwhelming (weak significance in a N=800 sample with >50% dropout). The authors also mention that they lack power, but the only correct answer then is not to do the study, include more people, more data points, or reduce measurement variance. That said, I think it's a refreshing perspective, and it seems like a good idea to look at effect heterogeneity in psychedelics use. Thinks like bayesian trees (BART) can help identify subgroups that react differently to stimuli along specific characteristics.
- WesternWind 3y agoA lower power study can still lend weight to a good meta analysis.
- uniqueuid 3y agoThat is true, but there are also conditions where low-powered studies degrade meta-analyses. For example, if the panel attrition is caused by self-selection on unobserved variables, then the study contains bias that is not (and cannot be) accounted for, which skews the meta analysis. But yeah, those concerns are mostly about measurement not sample size.
- coldtea 3y agoMeta-analyses are even less rigorous than a low power study
- exodust 3y agoInteresting that OCD is the winning disorder, with zero negative responders. Recalling my mushroom days.... Okay, I think I get it. Psychedelic experience is, in part, about embracing the beautiful chaos of the universe. Surrendering to the charms of free-flowing wild information at scale so huge there's no chance of imposing your own orderly corrections - as you might in normal every day life via OCD. That's my armchair take anyway. Psychiatric history | Negative responders (%) | Non-responders (%) | Positive responders (%) OCD | 0.0 | 25.0 | 75.0
- otherme123 3y agoThe n=16 is ridiculously low, though. Psychotic disorder, with 25%/25%/50%... n=4. The only number from Table 2 that makes sense is the aggregate. Even "history" vs "no-history" the differences are not that big, and slightly suggest that having a history of psychiatric illness has better outcome.
- exodust 3y agoYes true, I left out n=16 for my casual observation. It's a murky subject due to the traditional way being far removed from clinical environments. Anything artificial like therapy props would stand out under the influence of psychedelics, but I guess they've thought of that. Good luck to them.
- int_19h 3y agoMy subjective take is the opposite - psychedelics make you see order (patterns) emerge out of seeming chaos pretty much everywhere you look.
- exodust 3y agoYeh the infinite latticework does reveal a kind of order, I know what you mean. Perhaps it calms the OCD person seeing all those patterns. Although while under the influence of psychedelics you're unlikely to arrange your sock drawer with compulsive order. You're more likely to free the socks from captivity.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- AnarchismIsCool 3y agoYou know when you see HN discussion on some subjects where you have significant background and it's hyper cringe? Psychology/neurology is one of those areas where the community's commentary is almost always extremely...factually challenged. Be very careful making health decisions based off of HN comments. Lots of people with strong agendas and weak subject matter knowledge. Also, be careful not to over-estimate your ability to interpret random study results. It's kinda like trying to get a project to build you downloaded from sourceforge.
- 2four2 3y agoI've found this to be generally true. Engineers are passionate and intelligent people, but frequently make the mistake of thinking this means they are experts in everything.
- rokkitmensch 3y agoDentist's curse.
- tivert 3y ago> but frequently make the mistake of thinking this means they are experts in everything. That condition has a name, and it is "Engineer's Disease" or "Engineer's Syndrome."
- fragmede 3y agowhich tbh isn't fair to the doctors and lawyer who also suffer from the disease
- tivert 3y ago> which tbh isn't fair to the doctors and lawyer who also suffer from the disease Even if that's the case, I think framing it as "Engineer's Disease" is pretty critical for HN, which at times can become a literal orgy of it. Also, SV culture amplifies Engineer's Disease into a destructive force only rivaled by its counterpart in finance. Doctors and lawyers who suffer from something similar are far more limited in their effects.
- cupcake-unicorn 3y agoThis really just feels like fearmongering because this is a threat to big pharma. I mean, several commonly prescribed antidepressants have black box warnings about increased risk of suicide. When they trialed Prozac on people with no history of mental illness, someone committed suicide out of the blue. Fairly certain someone could cobble together a much more compelling meta analysis about even worse adverse effects of psych meds on similar populations, but due to NAMI and big pharma I think there's pressure not to draw those lines too clearly. I think there's a clear bias in cases of big pharma approved meds to jump to "Oh, it wasn't the medication, the condition just worsened" and with psychedelics/weed to jump to "The substance use is causing this". Even when there is proof of RX medication worsening mental health conditions, it's common to have these relationships straight up denied by the prescribing doctor. This isn't to say that there isn't a similar relationship in psychedelics, but it feels really disingenuous to me to be mentioning this outside of the wider context of psychiatric meds which somehow get a free pass for causing a much wider and dangerous range of side effects. If psychedelics cause less harm than commonly prescribed drugs in the same population, isn't that a good thing? We should understand these harms, but the bias of Big Pharma needs to be taken out of the picture.
- swores 3y ago> When they trialed Prozac on people with no history of mental illness, someone committed suicide out of the blue. I hadn't heard about this before, and while I'm sure it is possible for any drug that messes with brain chemicals to cause someone to decide to kill themselves, I've always been told & read a different explanation for the suicide warning that comes with most (or all?) antidepressants: Which is that a depressed person while at their lowest might think about suicide but not have the energy or willpower to do anything, but if they start taking a drug that partially fixes it, so they start having energy again, but doesn't fix their root problems so they still think that suicide would be preferable to life, and suddenly have energy to make that happen. Which is also the reason that modern guidance is for antidepressants to be co-prescribed with talk therapy, to try to use drugs to let the person be able to work on their issues, rather than just hoping the drug can fix all issues.
- 3y ago
- andy_ppp 3y agoN of one but my friend (who always saw the world as very black and white) killed herself not long after doing Ayahuasca. I’m pretty sure it contributed to her death, she became an extreme fantasist about judgement and god, not a formalised religion but a personified fantasy with crazed rules and vengeances. It was not good.
- epilys 3y agoI'm sorry for your loss. I'm not a medical practitioner but it sounds like the experience triggered a psychotic "break" in your friend? It's a sad but real possibility with psychedelics that more people should be aware of.
- orbit7 3y agoDevasting when such events occur. This can also occur from doing meditation for some, I'm not sure if anyone has measured whether there is any set means to determine individual level of risk and whether any particular mental conditioning/ study would mitigate that risk. Certainly awareness is important.
- looneytoon 3y agoAlso not medical but I experienced similar and it sounds like psychosis to me. Personally I had manic episode triggered by taking several doses of acid spread over a week or so preceded by shroom doses spread over prior weeks. This culminated in several nights of insomnia, paranoia and then psychosis - the religious stuff is relatable. I had intense apocalyptic beliefs and “visions” - sort of closed eye waking dream more so then an open eye hallucination. The black and white thing also highly relatable and I think it is splitting (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Splitting_(psychology) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Splitting_(psychology)) - again not an expert. Her suicide is very sad but I can relate. Rest in peace. Personally it took me at least a month to feel functional again and then probably a year to start feeling better. Prior to that I struggled immensely with depression most of my life and abusing substances was my attempt to pull out of it, so to bottom out intensely like that feels extremely hopeless. Once again giant disclaimer that I’m not authority, but I learned more about how psychedelics work from neuroscientists who research them and it was very illuminating. They are extremely potent in regards to neuroplasticity which seems like why they can be heaven or hell (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Psychoplastogen https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Psychoplastogen). My best take away from the scientists was to space trips out by several months similar to what you should do for MDMA. Frequently redosing keeps your brain activity from stabilizing. That’s not their advice or strong statements (they were avoiding advice-giving entirely), of course, just what I took away. Years later and I have done a lot introspection and learning and I have taken psychedelics again. I can identify my own anxiety, paranoia, or bad patterned thoughts creeping up and talk myself back. I don’t attribute that traumatic experience or drug use in general to improving my circumstance and I sure as hell don’t recommend it but it does seem like my life going to total shit was a step I needed to take to get it back together. Therapy would’ve been easier.
- optimalsolver 3y agoReminder. Psychedelics can also lead to extremely traumatic experiences: https://www.reddit.com/r/DMT/comments/gb9ar0/dark_dmt_trip_report https://www.reddit.com/r/DMT/comments/gb9ar0/dark_dmt_trip_r... This doesn’t get mentioned in the current “psychedelics as a cure-all” hype wave.
- ssijak 3y agoit gets mentioned
- namero999 3y agoMaybe not the best example as the report ends with "I’m doing great now! I think the experience despite being f* terrify was super useful", but I get what you mean. However, serious narrators or researchers usually don't fail to mention that we are not dealing with a panacea.
- jajko 3y agoIt gets mentioned all the time, everywhere I ever saw anything. If you really see info only in such way, stay away from those sources
- ahiknsr 3y agofrom the post > and out of pure immaturity and desire to breakthrough I packed 100mg into the bowl. https://psychonautwiki.org/wiki/DMT https://psychonautwiki.org/wiki/DMT says heavy dosage is 60mg+. > This doesn’t get mentioned in the current “psychedelics as a cure-all” hype wave. No. You forgot to mention 100mg is way above heavy dosage.
- Jerrrry 3y agoThats not how DMT works.
- n4kana 3y agoThat’s a trauma cum redemption story. Sometimes it’s just trauma. RIP Richard Skibinski (July 17, 2022) https://www.reddit.com/r/Psychedelics_Society/comments/uzed20/high_dose_mushroom_trip_destroyed_my_life_a_year/ https://www.reddit.com/r/Psychedelics_Society/comments/uzed2... https://www.legacy.com/us/obituaries/legacyremembers/richard-c-skibinsky-obituary?pid=202434402 https://www.legacy.com/us/obituaries/legacyremembers/richard...
- rdtsc 3y agoIt’s pretty scary to me that so many people seemingly on whim are willing to upgrade their brain firmware. I often hear stuff like “and then my whole view on reality changed”. Unless there’s an easy way to upload the previous “factory image” so to speak, it feels pretty risky to experiment with that.
- holoduke 3y agoAn illusive broken firmware it is. Better stay sober. Also when learning new things being sober is better. You wont get your phd using drugs. You wont get your brains to a new state using drugs. You maybe think you do, but thats a illusional defect of your brains when using drugs. Stay sober.
- mistermann 3y agoIs the omniscience pure rationalists experience on vanilla consciousness genuine?
- morbicer 3y agoDouglas Engelbart - inspired by LSD to invent computer mouse Steve Jobs stated LSD was “one of the two or three most important things I ever did in my life” Francis Crick saw the double helix of DNA on LSD Kary Banks Mullis, the biochemist who won the 1993 Nobel Prize in Chemistry for his improvements to the polymerase chain reaction technique: “It [LSD] was certainly much more important than any courses I ever took.” Ralph Abraham claimed the insights he had while on psychedelics such as LSD profoundly influenced the development of his mathematical theories. And there's more and I am not even mentioning that most artists are using something. So yeah, if you can get Nobel prize you can definitely get PhD. You do you, I don't know what you have achieved but don't claim you posses some universal truth.
- holoduke 3y agoYour examples are exceptions and are certainly not a justification. Drugs are destroying lives of a lot of people who otherwise could have good lifes.
- reify 3y agoI am nearly 70 years old. I have been taking psychedelics for 50 over years. I am retired psychotherapist and I do not have a predisposition to mental ill health. I was also a substance misuse worker and methadone dispenser for over 10 years. I gave up smoking hash when I was 40 years old. I did notice that with the introduction of skunk and the increase of up to 20% more Tetrahydrocannabinol (THC), there were more and more people being sectioned under the mental health act with psychosis. Whereas prior to skunk when people generally smoked good old fashioned, Moroccan, Lebanese and Afghani hashish it was a rarity. I know a range of people of different ages who partake in psychedelic use and have no trouble, like me, in holding down a professional job role and engaging fully in life. As with all drugs there is a risk, however, the risks with Psyceedelics are very low in comparison with other drugs. We must not use individual cases to determine the safety of any drug. Here in the UK the media went wild over reports that a 18 year old girl (Leah Betts) had died from taking MDMA. Very rarely are the true facts given; The coroner said that "water intoxication", and not an allergic reaction to the drug, was the cause of death. I have a great deal of respect for Professor David Nutt who is an English neuropsychopharmacologist specialising in the research of drugs that affect the brain and conditions such as addiction. His recommendations to the government to reclassify drugs were rejected and he was sacked. heroin is top of the list - alcohol is 5th on the list - LSD is 14th on the list - Ecstacy is 18th on the list
- eimrine 3y ago[flagged]
- iammjm 3y agoPsychedelics are a force to be reckoned with. Plus people are conflating clinical trials with taking unknown substances, in unknown amounts without considering the proper set and setting. Controlling for the substance and amount as well as having a professional, caring guide to help the patient through the experience will be a FAR different experience than eating a fist-full of shrooms at a party some stranger gave you while under the influence of other things...
- quchen 3y agoI’m also worried about all the self-medication, where people treat serious issues without supervision. But I also want to highlight that there is a place for recreational, responsible, and safe drug use; there is a _lot_ between between clinical/therapeutic settings and random recklessness.
- underseacables 3y agoWe infer that the presence of a personality disorder may represent an elevated risk for psychedelic use and hypothesize that the importance of psychological support and good therapeutic alliance may be increased in this population. Feels like another publish or perish paper.
- probably_jesus 3y ago[dead]
- nukeyoular 3y ago[dead]