6 ms·
> I think ideally there would be some kind of verification that the customer was indeed present and that their ID had been verified, but I don’t see how you can
by dragonwriter 3y ago
> I think ideally there would be some kind of verification that the customer was indeed present and that their ID had been verified, but I don’t see how you can do that in the US as there aren’t ID cards or similar forms of universally available ID.
Requiring government issued photo ID for identity verification is not at all an uncommon policy for various purposes in the US, and AFAIK all states have universally available ID cards (they are generally not free of charge, but they are universally available.)
- mjevans 3y agoID REALLY should be paid for by taxes and 'free' for everyone obtaining their proof of identity. Now, a 'drivers' license might have an extra fee on top of that. Maybe the free IDs could be issued by police departments? Either way this is a good time for someone to register as a voter too, WA state has a simple checkbox for that and other states can too.
- gosub100 3y agoEspecially since the recent push for "Real ID" required to fly. Ok if it's so "Real" it should be easily scanned and verified. When you get your phone they should hand you a pamphlet saying that when you lose your phone this is the process, these are the risks, and offer you the option to upgrade the security to require, say, a passport to restore your account.
- datavirtue 3y agoYes, and the police could drive them to the voting booth as well.
- nicbou 3y agoI help people move to Germany. Requirements like this make it really hard for people to settle in a new place. On the other hand you can’t expect a teenager working minimum wage to identify a Thai passport. There exist services for ID verification, usually by video call. They exhibit the same limitations though.
- citrin_ru 3y agoIf a passports are accepted it should not create a problem for most foreigners/immigrants. And Thai passport doesn't look too different from others: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thai_passport https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thai_passport guess an untrained worker will not spot a forgery but that's true for no matter which country's passport do you use and something like an US driving license looks easier to forge than Thai biometric passport.
- vinay427 3y ago> something like an US driving license looks easier to forge than Thai biometric passport I'm not sure this is the right comparison, in general, although I agree with your point (below). I suspect that one benefit of accepting domestic driving licences as ID, but not most foreign non-passport documents, is due to familiarity. That's probably as important a factor in spotting forgeries as the security features embedded in the document, which aren't very useful if the person checking isn't familiar with an authentic version of the document. In practice, I tend to agree that someone is likely to not be familiar with many driving licences, such as (in the US/Canada) those from distant or low-population US/Canadian states, provinces, or territories, or (in much of Europe) a smaller European country's driving licence or national ID card, so a foreign passport is far from the main concern.
- TheNewsIsHere 3y agoAgreed. And even within a jurisdiction not everyone may be very familiar with domestic IDs. FinCEN just yesterday released a notice to financial institutions regarding the use of forged and legitimate US Passport Cards in connection with fraudulent or suspicious activity. The notice includes a litany of validity tests given that people just don't see these very often. I have a US Passport Card that I present as my photo ID when asked, because I don't want my address presented to just anyone who might have a valid need to ask for ID. Federal employees look at it and waive me on, but outside that I get a mix of "I've never seen this" (and every time it's still been accepted) and a lot of careful scanning of the card.