2 ms·
Assuming I'm reading it right, this is an absolutely classic vulnerability, something people who study cryptographic vulnerability research would instinctually
by tptacek 3y ago
Assuming I'm reading it right, this is an absolutely classic vulnerability, something people who study cryptographic vulnerability research would instinctually check for, so what's taken so long is probably for anyone to bother evaluating the P-521 implementation in PuTTY.
- some_furry 3y agoCorrect. Every time I've seen P-521 in a professional setting, it is the very first thing I check for.
- astrange 3y agoHow often do people get it wrong? It doesn't seem particularly difficult to generate 521 random bits.
- some_furry 3y agoThis is the first time it's ever actually happened. I'm just painfully aware of missing developer ergonomics and ways to shoot oneself in the foot.
- tptacek 3y agoIt was found a bunch a decade or so ago. PuTTY is just a more obscure codebase.
- some_furry 3y agoSorry, I should've been clearer: all the times I've checked for this specific bug, I did not find it in the code I was looking at. All the times I looked for it was the series of events I was reflecting on. That's what I meant by "the first time it's happened". I shouldn't write comments before my first cup of coffee.
- MaxBarraclough 3y agoThe classic FOSS tragedy of the commons: we'd all benefit from an in-depth security review of the PuTTY codebase, but no one will fund it.