3 ms·
Asking BigTech to police AI is like asking oil companies to solve climate change
- smartmic 3y agoTangentially related: "AI safety is not a model property" (https://www.aisnakeoil.com/p/ai-safety-is-not-a-model-property https://www.aisnakeoil.com/p/ai-safety-is-not-a-model-proper...) https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39939997 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39939997
- zb3 3y agoIs this another (possibly sponsored) bullshit article about "AI Safety"?
- tick_tock_tick 3y agoNo it's like asking Madagascar to enforce jwalking laws in the USA. The cats out of the bag you could ban BigTech from using AI tomorrow and we'd still have plenty of AI Taylor Swift porn.
- brailsafe 3y agoThat's because the people always know what's important ;) It's also the reason that any AI product lives and dies (mostly) depending on whether people will pay for it, especially with finite money. AI hype is only not real if it doesn't evidently move some needle for enough people for a long time consistently. In the short term, it can rely alone on people thinking it's important or the future, and it may be, but that sort of has to play out in some meaningful way. Much like every AI wave before it, and things like Web 3, it'll probably change a few things that weren't already completely automated, but beyond that it isn't really inherently a new type of value created, unless it is. If Madagascar created an AI tool to detect jay walkers, it wouldn't make enforcement of jay walking sensible, it wouldn't stop people from doing it, and it wouldn't even be operational unless the long tail of bylaw enforcement was also completely automated and actionable. If it's not, then you're just spreading some other resource thin or creating more financial problems for more people who just want to cross the street. I'm not going to walk half a KM to the next light if I can see it's safe to do otherwise, so to solve that problem you want to make driving much cheaper and efficient, then people will never feel safe to jay walk since there will always be traffic, and why would people not be driving anyway!? AirBnB built tools that made it as easy as possible for people to convert housing into short term rentals, and maximize their return using ML to price them. That's great for them, except the original inspiration was ostensibly to recoup some of the insane rent they were already paying in SF because of existing political nonsense and too many people making too much money. The result ended up being spreading SFs problem to everywhere else instead of solving anything while SF continues being an absolute human catastrophe. Incidentally, now cities are realizing both AirBnB and terrible housing policy just vacuums up their economy, killing their population and productivity along the way until it costs 100% of the average salary to live in a place, and most of that cash ends up sitting idle, being invested elsewhere, or continually intensifying the same problem until living in a tent city seems like a high prospect. You can extract more money more efficiently, but if there isn't money to replace it, people just end up not spending that money on things that are equally important, like raising their kids, food, medication.
- robtest123 3y ago[flagged]
- paxys 3y agoIs there a single case in history where "government should regulate [xyz sector]" hasn't turned into government passing laws that were ghostwritten by the largest players in that sector to benefit themselves?
- itishappy 3y agoThe EPA seems to doing good work with things like leaded gas, CFCs, PFASs, etc. I feel like our atomic energy agencies are pretty above-board too.
- AnthonyMouse 3y agoWhat you're really getting at is that sometimes the regulation of a sector is captured by the largest players in a different sector, e.g. fossil fuel energy companies want regulation of nuclear power to make it cost prohibitive. The EPA is a similar story. It justifies itself by banning leaded gas etc., but then doesn't do only that, and soon certain domestic industries are wiped out by environmental impact studies and other administrative overhead. The companies in those industries don't care because they just move their facilities offshore. The ones who are already foreign companies or were going to do that anyway may even prefer it, because then the rules eliminate competition from domestic operations in the US. And similar to the case of nuclear, environmental rules are often abused by NIMBYs to inhibit construction rather than merely ensure that it isn't harming the environment.
- pjerem 3y agoTobacco ?
- ethbr1 3y agoAntitrust First sale doctrine Telecom Airlines Food safety Transportation safety Environmental safety Fish and wildlife
- janice1999 3y agoOccupational Safety and Health laws
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- throwaway984393 3y ago[dead]
- samyar 3y agofor climate change we should reach out to climate experts to help us should we reach out to Police or Military for safety? technically this is what they are supposed to do.
- t0bia_s 3y agoIn January 26th, 2024, Jan Lipavský (Czech pirate party, Minister of Foreign Affairs) said in World economic forum in Devos during interview: “It needs to be developed such kind of regulation or possession or to control of those technologies (Ai) that the governments will be sure that it is not going against the interest of government.” This rhetoric was used by communist regime 34 years ago in my country. Governments are genuinely scared by those new technologies. I prefer to educate children about AI, how it works and what can do. Of course, education system in Czechia basically ignore new technologies at school and still use frontal teaching as it was hundred years ago.