2 ms·
You are assuming that they can, in fact, prove that you did it. The RIAA has been sufficiently sloppy that they have pursued these cases in many situations whe
by btilly 15y ago
You are assuming that they can, in fact, prove that you did it.
The RIAA has been sufficiently sloppy that they have pursued these cases in many situations where the facts were against them. In those it does not always make sense to settle.
And, even if the facts are against you, if you can prove that the RIAA screwed up in how they collected that information on you, they might not be allowed to actually present that evidence. The odds of this succeeding are low, but if even one person succeeds in that, the precedent will be good for everyone going forward. (Of course if you fail, you pay full costs.)
Admittedly it takes an unusual kind of person to prefer one of the latter two courses. But if they succeed, it could be very good for everyone else.
Disclaimer, I am not a lawyer, this is not legal advice, and I personally do not care much either way because I have never shared or downloaded copyrighted content in any public forum.