4 ms·
Yes, it's illegal to distribute copyrighted material against the copyright owner's wishes. It doesn't matter if it's a peer-to-peer network. From both a legal
by dpark 14y ago
Yes, it's illegal to distribute copyrighted material against the copyright owner's wishes. It doesn't matter if it's a peer-to-peer network. From both a legal and technical standpoint, there's basically no difference between placing a song on a webserver for people to download and hosting it on a peer-to-peer network.
Also, if your peer to peer network has you downloading the same thing over and over again, then your peer-to-peer network is broken.
- grhino 14y agoIn a peer-to-peer network, it may be the case that 10 peers each share 1/10 of a file to 10 other peers. Would each of the sharing peers hold full responsibility for sharing the file even though technically they only delivered 1/10th of it. I would expect awarding damages to hinge on this kind of hair splitting.
- nknight 14y agoIn areas of tort liability, it's routine for there to be a determination that party A is liable for X%, B is liable for Y%, etc.. Historically, I don't think this would come up as much in copyright law. General torts often involve a confluence of events triggered by multiple actors, whereas copyright violations have usually been clearly the act of a single person or entity, so I'm not sure there's much case law around this.
- wmf 14y agoThis case was based on the "making available" theory, not actual sharing, right? Under that theory, if each peer was offering the whole file they could be fully liable for infringement.
- Karunamon 14y ago>Yes, it's illegal to distribute copyrighted material against the copyright owner's wishes. Mostly true, but I feel like I must point out that fair use (what narrow legally defined version of it we have, anyways) overrides the copyright owner's wishes. Not that this applied here, but it's an important point anyways.