3 ms·
How certain are you that projects are actively seeking to attract potential contributors? Managing open source contributors is non-trivial work. It's actually
by simonw 3y ago
How certain are you that projects are actively seeking to attract potential contributors?
Managing open source contributors is non-trivial work. It's actually one of the harder forms of engineering management, because you're dealing with volunteers - you can't even really directly tell contributors what to do, you have to deploy a whole bunch of (difficult) soft skills and influence and leadership to point people in the right direction.
How confident are you that there's sufficient demand from projects to attract more contributors in this way?
- aendruk 3y agoYeah I have zero interest in actively soliciting attention to my projects. I shared them in case that helps anyone. We have web search.
- joewadcan 3y agoThis. Just because something should exist, doesn't mean it can be created today. The effort to build and attract open source projects is a monumental task. Unless you're offering something BIG - there's alot of inertia to overcome. I'd focus on building on top of the GitHub API to create those features you want. Not only will you focus your time on the unique stuff, GitHub can help with distribution and discovery.
- kristopolous 3y agoI'd imagine there's almost always a door open for talented and competent people looking to make meaningful contributions and have substantive impact.
- simonw 3y agoI love it when people contribute to my projects by opening an issue, discussing their idea, then contributing a clean PR with bundled documentation and tests. Actively soliciting contributions isn't necessarily the way to get that. Look at what happens with Hacktoberfest: there are hundreds of thousands of newer developers out there who want to earn their stripes by contributing to an open source project. The amount of work this creates for the projects themselves is enormous.
- kristopolous 3y agoSure but the pipeline of increasing responsibility needs to be open to new recruits for the long-term viability of a project. We all used to be dumb teenagers as well.
- nox101 3y ago> then contributing a clean PR with bundled documentation and tests. I've never seen this. No tests, un-clean PR. Describing them how to fix it would take more time than re-doing the PR myself. Of course maybe if I thought they were going to contribute a bunch more PRs it would be worth spending time training them but I've never had that kind of contributor.
- simonw 3y agoI had one of these recently! https://github.com/simonw/shot-scraper/pull/133/files https://github.com/simonw/shot-scraper/pull/133/files They're /incredibly/ rare though.
- dolmen 3y agoThis is a wrong assumption. Opening the code doesn't necessarily mean that external contributions are expected. Reports of issues might be welcome, code contributions less. I've seen too many popular projects polluted by low quality contributions. When they get merged without care, the project's quality degrades. When they accumulate, the load on the maintainers shoulders becomes heavy.
- aendruk 3y agoWhile you’re not wrong this is a confusing interpretation of the parent. almost always → necessarily talented, competent, meaningful → low quality
- haswell 3y ago> The primary goal of this application will be to serve as a directory for discovering open-source projects Maybe an increase in potential contributors is a natural outcome of increased discoverability, but I’m not convinced that a new site that is primarily facilitating project discovery will drastically change contributions. If you’re the type of person to submit code to a project, you’re probably already scouring the web to find the projects that are most relevant to you, and a site like this just makes that process more efficient. Most users of OSS are not contributors, and this project seems to be aimed at one of the barriers to adopting OSS: knowing where to look for options when you realize you need Tool X for Project Y.
- simonw 3y agoThat makes sense. As an open source maintainer a directory that helps people discover my projects in order to use them is a whole lot more interesting than one that helps me find contributors.