3 ms·
> The conclusion is that for the Intel Macs it does not make much of a difference, but for the M series there is a benefit from going USB4. It's worse than tha
by rsynnott 3y ago
> The conclusion is that for the Intel Macs it does not make much of a difference, but for the M series there is a benefit from going USB4.
It's worse than that; if you use a USB4 enclosure with an Intel Mac (or, really, just about any computer that's more than a few years old), it'll run at 10Gbit/sec (because USB3 is the fallback point, not Thunderbolt 3), but if you use it it with ARM Mac it'll run at 40Gbit/sec. If you use a Thunderbolt 3 enclosure instead it'll run at 32Gbit/sec in both cases. All bets are off if Thunderbolt 4.
As always, USB, and associated standards like Thunderbolt, continue to be absolutely baffling. I think there had been the perception that USB4 would make all this a bit less confusing, but it very much hasn't.
- samatman 3y agoA lot of growing pains for sure. We've gone from "you have to find the cable which fits the port, and if you don't, you're out of luck" to "grab one of the 'universal cables' and see what happens when you plug it in". Although in practice I find it pretty easy to pick out power-only UBC-C, USB-only USB-C, and Thunderbolt USB-C, by the build quality/thickness of the cable. What's aggravating is devices (cheap ones) which use the USB-C port but will only charge from an OG 500mA charger. I keep those chargers in rotation as a result, but they're useless for any other purpose.
- moondev 3y agoI just ran a disk speed test on my 2018 Mac mini, connected to a USB4 NVME adaptor. NVME inside is a Samsung 970 pro (PCIE 3) Read 2692 MB/s Write 1774 MB/s System information claims the device as "USB4 NVME SSD Pro Enclosure" on the Thunderbolt 3 bus and not the USB bus