3 ms·
The BMI (Body Mass Index), while far from perfect - mainly because it can't tell the difference between relatively heavy muscle and relatively light (density wi
by swores 3y ago
The BMI (Body Mass Index), while far from perfect - mainly because it can't tell the difference between relatively heavy muscle and relatively light (density wise) fat, so a very fit and very strong person can wrongly be classified (and in the opposite direction too) - is still the standard recognised by the WHO, by the NHS in the UK, etc. It's just calculated by body mass divided by the square of the body height, using kg and m.
And then there are specific names for ranges of BMI, which include "Normal range" for 18.5 to 24.9, "Overweight (Pre-obese)" for 25-29.9, and then three classes of "Obese" above 30 as well as three "Underweight" types below 18.5.
Generally this is simplified down to "Underweight", "Normal", "Overweight", and "Obese", with the following words after "Normal" and "Overweight" being implied, and with the multiple levels of underweight and obesity ignored unless discussing someone light or heavy enough that it's worth considering the differences between "Obese (Class I)" and "Obese (Class III)", or between "Underweight (Mild thinness)" and "Underweight (Severe thinness)" - all still based purely on the BMI number.
Sorry for the long winded answer, but even more here: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Body_mass_index https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Body_mass_index
Weirdly it seems like this study used the same logic but set non-standard boundaries (27.5 rather than 30 as the point between Overweight and Obese).
- renewiltord 3y agoThe boundaries are different for South Asian and East Asians. NUS's participation probably influenced using the Asian cutoff rather than the Caucasian cutoff.
- anitil 3y agoInterestingly that horseshoe effect of people with large muscle mass having a high bmi might be appropriate for sleep apnea. Strong-men who move in to very high weights (120kg+) will almost always need CPAP due to muscle mass around their necks
- zten 3y ago> a very fit and very strong person can wrongly be classified (and in the opposite direction too) Unfortunately, it usually goes in the bad direction, by quite a bit. BMI under-predicts obesity. You only have to hit 25% body fat as a male to be obese, or 32% as a female. https://academic.oup.com/jes/article/7/Supplement_1/bvad114.007/7290234 https://academic.oup.com/jes/article/7/Supplement_1/bvad114....
- lm28469 3y ago> The BMI (Body Mass Index), while far from perfect - mainly because it can't tell the difference between relatively heavy muscle and relatively light (density wise) fat, so a very fit and very strong person can wrongly be classified Let's be honest a second here, for every "too muscular bmi obese" there are a thousand "good ol obese"