4 ms·
I have a lot of time for the concept behind Metro- that we should move beyond trying to represent real-world concepts in the digital space, and instead should m
by untog 15y ago
I have a lot of time for the concept behind Metro- that we should move beyond trying to represent real-world concepts in the digital space, and instead should make a "digital native" experience. It remains to be seen how it works out, but just playing with the Win8 preview, the UI is considerably better than Apple's "leather-bound" address book.
- gurkendoktor 15y agoI understand what you say, even if I don't agree, but does this apply to the Windows 8 desktop? (Optional) transparency and gradients are not more or less digital than solid colors, so far this looks like a skin of Windows 7 to me.
- zokier 15y agoOf course the changes are going to be evolutionary, incremental. MS probably has the Longhorn fiasco in fresh memory. Bringing revolutionary changes is extremely prone to failure.
- TazeTSchnitzel 15y agoWindows 8 is a huge, revolutionary change though. They completely scrapped the start menu, start button, traditional software delivery, etc.
- untog 15y agoIt was more that the transparency and gradients were attempting to replicate 'glass'. Why? What purpose does that serve? For a long time people cited user familiarity (I'm sure why Apple has made the skins they have) but I think it's time to move beyond that.
- CountSessine 15y agoIt was more that the transparency and gradients were attempting to replicate 'glass'. Why? What purpose does that serve? In the case of Vista, it was to show off the snazzy new GPU window compositing. In Window 7 it was inertia. Ah, no, but no practical purpose from the user's point of view. In fact, it actually looks pretty gaudy. I'm glad someone at Microsoft agrees.
- gurkendoktor 15y agoBut does anyone really think of glass? How would glass help with familiarity? Lots of hardcore digital people always had their terminals set to transparent. Microsoft (following Apple^) did the same and add a blur for usability reasons. If MS suddenly declared that the solid blue shapes in Windows 8 are solid-colored origami paper, would the same interface suddenly be worse because it was skeuomorphic? (^ I'm not talking about the mirror Dock in 10.5, but about the transparent modal dialogs with a blur in 10.5+(?), and the old 10.4 Dock.)
- jcromartie 15y agoYeah, it's interesting to see Microsoft actually moving the UI forward in a real way. The whole "authentically digital" thing might be too high-brow for consumers though. While Apple has consolidated on what works well for them and their users recenty, Microsoft actually seems to be looking to the future. I have to respect that, even if I still like the Apple stuff better than the Metro UI so far.