5 ms·
Turning off electrical grids to prevent wildfire− a complex, technical operation
- electricdreams 3y ago[flagged]
- bagels 3y agoWhy don't you just let us in on the secret instead of cryptically referring to what I assume is some conspiracy channel?
- puzzledobserver 3y agoThe Practical Engineering Youtube channel has a very interesting video on black starts of an electrical grid [0]. Are there any additional challenges in turning a grid off? [0] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uOSnQM1Zu4w https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uOSnQM1Zu4w
- idiotsecant 3y agoThere's a pretty big challenge, which is that you aren't turning off a grid at all -just particular transmission lines. Your typical power flows rely on those lines being up, and without them strange conditions can occur. Its sometimes just as bad to have an unusually lightly loaded line as it is to have an overloaded line. Lightly loaded lines with lots of generation end up messing up line voltages due to capacitive loading. You can end up having to shut down a line or taking other remedial action like shutting down generation because not enough power is flowing through a line.
- ckdarby 3y agoI suspect we'll see more openness to this with homes in the future coming with batteries to power for 12-24 hours without the grid.
- robocat 3y agoIn my experience 12-24 hours won't help you enough in a city, and is woefully inadequate in rural areas. There are better ways to spend your money to cover risks than batteries. Maybe if you were getting a battery for other reasons, or as a luxury if you are wealthy enough.
- toast0 3y agoI think if you have a big enough time of use differential, and you have significant use during peak pricing, you can justify a local battery system for peak shaving and get backup power 'for free' or vice versa. 12-24 hours would have outlasted any outage I've experienced, until I moved to my current place, but it has a propane fueled whole house generator (and low utility rates with no time of use component; i haven't attempted the math, but I'm pretty sure running from my generator is way more expensive than utility power... OTOH, I've had many utility failures and only one generator failure (12v battery failed due to charger failure))
- simfree 3y agoWith a battery, you could run your generator at peak efficiency when it's running, and idle it otherwise, significantly reducing your running costs.
- toast0 3y agoYeah, but even at peak efficiency, I don't think $/kWh on propane is going to be better than $/kWh from my utility. A battery system would be nice though, all things considered, so I could run the generator for fewer hours during an outage: only running the generator when my demand is high or the battery needs to charge would reduce the time spent at low load where efficiency is poor.
- robocat 3y ago> so I could run the generator for fewer hours during an outage: only running the generator when my demand is high or the battery needs to charge would reduce the time spent at low load where efficiency is poor. There is little point worrying about marginal efficiency when power is out because saving a few dollars over a few hours is not worth optimising for. - High fixed costs (batteries & inverter) would dominate small operating costs (propane, wear&tear).
- amluto 3y agoI would like to know why grid operators turn portions off instead of installing devices to mitigate the fire risk when a fault occurs. “Rapid Earth Fault CLearance” devices (REFCL), also known as ground fault neutralizers, are a newish but commercially available technology that massively reduces current, and thus heating energy, delivered into a ground fault. In testing in Australia, a REFCL-protected line was intentionally dropped into dry plants without setting them on fire. What gives? I doubt these devices are so expensive that they’re worse than the cost of “public safety power shutdowns” or of the billions of dollars that utilities are spending, and charging customers for, for undergrounding of lines and extra tree work.
- mschuster91 3y ago> I would like to know why grid operators turn portions off instead of installing devices to mitigate the fire risk when a fault occurs. The stuff you're mentioning is - at least from a quick Google, I'll admit that - only certified in Australia. Even here in Germany, introducing that onto the grid would take years for certifications. Bureaucracy moves slowly. Then, you'd need to upgrade a lot of transmission lines including the regional distribution grid (i.e. < 100 kV), a single unprotected line in a danger-prone area is enough to start a deadly fire. And there are a looooot of power lines that haven't had an inspection for decades - the hook that caused the 2018 fire was almost a century old [1]. And so, instead of inspecting, maintaining and upgrading the many thousand km's of national and regional lines, shutting them down during peak fire condition times is cheaper. IMHO it only makes sense to install REFCL devices as part of a general overhaul of an entire transmission grid area. [1] https://www.wsj.com/articles/this-old-metal-hook-could-determine-whether-pg-e-committed-a-crime-11583623059 https://www.wsj.com/articles/this-old-metal-hook-could-deter...
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- toast0 3y agoBecause they already have the ability to turn portions off. Installing a lot of new equipment means regulatory effort to get a plan approved, and a lot of installation labor. I imagine these systems will be put in place over time, but I was just looking at Wikipedia on Reclosers and they said Sensitive Ground Fault protection reduces the risk by 80%; if the risk is high enough, that probably still warrants deenergizing risky lines at times.
- sanderjd 3y agoThe thing that was most unclear with this incident in Colorado was: How did they decide which areas to shut down? It didn't make me feel like the people in charge knew what they were doing, when we left our neighborhood where the power was intentionally turned off (for over a day) to go to our friends' house where it was kept on, despite them having much stronger winds both in the forecast and in actuality. Their house is also in an area with much higher fire risk, surrounded by dry windswept vegetation. It's hard to trust an organization that says "we're turning off your power due to your area's unique risk of fire" when that conclusion seems incomprehensible to anyone aware of the weather and geography of the area. It's very hard not to wonder whether they are ignorant or are not being forthright. Maybe there is some information that would show that they made the right decisions, but if so, they certainly haven't shared it yet!
- zmj 3y agoAgreed this was confusing. It seems like the risk factors that would lead to turning off a neighborhood (non-buried power lines, exposure to wind and available fuels) should have been known and announced in advance. I'm in Lafayette, and it seemed strange that our power was on when neighborhoods in Louisville and Erie were out.
- sanderjd 3y agoYep, and pretty much the entirety of Boulder preemptively turned off, but not the areas south along 93 and to the east into Arvada near Rocky Flats, which are the exact super dry and windy areas where the Marshall Fire began. I actually do think there must be some plausible explanation, but it's hard not to feel sympathetic to the people who are convinced it is a tit for tat by Xcel, targeted at people who have been involved in recent legal confrontations with them. There are good reasons they aren't being given the benefit of the doubt here. I honestly worry more that truth is they were just winging it without any strong process or data with which to make the decision, and that this is their plan moving forward. But the good news is that the PUC investigating what happened is the way to get these answers, and is exactly what Governor Polis is pushing for.
- michaelrpeskin 3y ago
- ThinkBeat 3y agoThere is a bad snowstorm coming in folks. Snow, high winds and temperatures best thought about in Kelvins. Just joking with ya-all. Looks like we will be snowed in for a week or so. To keep ya-all safe, the utility will be turning off the grid. Remember to stay warm.
- zmj 3y agoThat's actually a real concern for using this strategy in Colorado in the fall. The Marshall Fire (mentioned in the article) was followed by snow and temperatures well below freezing. Sadly, this probably killed some pets that escaped the fire.
- bunabhucan 3y agoSomething that might not be obvious: the shape of feeders can change based on switching operations. New PV on the big expensive house next to open space can create problems (you now have a generator right at the end of the grid) and new EVs can be roughly as much demand as a new house. Sometimes the fix is to change what feeds what, especially in a dense city. The utility obviously knows what feeder every meter is on but may not have anticipated (or paid for!) bulk calling the exact customers based on that. CA had rolling outages (caused by Enron) and implemented a system for notification but it was work, took years to design and put in place. The systems for managing switching and restoring power are quick/live/critical whereas the systems for building / maintaining are more slow / archival / non-critical. Both are typically legacy systems mired in an interconnected web with other legacy systems and very, very slow to change. Anything that looks like a bulk customer / phone list api is even slower.
- evilotto 3y agoWhy is it that the costs "trickle down to the electricity consumers" while utilities like PG&E report record profits? Are profits more important than safety, or customers?
- kkfx 3y agoEhm... Sorry, no. To prevent wildfires from the grid you need to make most cable underground, where you can't keep them in a clear area, large enough to avoid lighting up a fire if a pole drop.