3 ms·
I more agree than disagree with most of the points--at least for the typical conference presenter. The one thing I'd add (though this is more in the hands of t
by ghaff 3y ago
I more agree than disagree with most of the points--at least for the typical conference presenter.
The one thing I'd add (though this is more in the hands of the conference organizers) is that shorter (25-30 minute) presentations are often better than 45-50 minute ones. Some of this relates to what the post says at the beginning. If it's a bad presentation, I've wasted less time. But the other thing is that a presentation can cue me in to something being interesting more than it can teach me everything about that something.
I've been seeing this as a general trend although I have colleagues who hate that trend and respond by trying to cram 60 minutes of content into 25 minutes grumbling all the way.
And, oh, stay on schedule. It's really rude to the next presenter (and your audience) if you don't. I might end up going a minute or 2 over if I get off-track but I feel badly when I do.
- exe34 3y agoI 100% blame people not staying on schedule on the organisers. I'm autistic, I'd happily cut off your microphone on time, not matter if you're the pope or a Nobel laureate. This is why I'm not allowed to chair sessions.
- kstrauser 3y agoOooh, can I recruit you to cut off question askers who aren’t asking questions? Talks need someone not shy about enforcing that it’s question after the presentation, not offtopic rambling time.
- skeeter2020 3y agoAttend grad school. Questions are almost always a way to try and prove how smart you are.
- kstrauser 3y agoYou know it. “Well, in my experience doing this since 1997…” “Lemme stop you right there.”
- ghaff 3y agoOr analyst conferences, etc. Generally speaking I'm not a huge fan of public raising of hands type Q&A's. They turn into more of a comment than a question and showing off sorts of things as you say. Maybe a few pre-submitted questions electronically or just save them for later 1-on-1s.
- exe34 3y agoI quite like the way that in some sessions they make you submit questions into a webpage and the chair will pick the questions to ask - it really makes a difference when they can say "there's a few other comments you can read online", rather than drag on the q&a session.
- abnercoimbre 3y agoYeah at my indie conferences [0] if we live-stream the event that means we have an online audience too. I require everyone to submit their questions to a private chat server, even if you're there in person, and I curate them in real-time. [0] https://handmadecities.com https://handmadecities.com
- hermitcrab 3y agoIIRC they have a young girl on stage at the IgNobels and her job is to repeatedly shout 'boring' if you overrun your timeslot.
- exe34 3y agoThat's amazing!
- CPLX 3y agoI run a company that produces conferences in about 20 cities annually. We run our conferences absolutely ruthlessly on time, like to the minute. We prep every speaker for it, we have a countdown clock on stage and we interrupt to end a session if we have to, though that doesn’t happen much given we communicate clearly about this in advance. It’s shocking how many conferences don’t do that. I’m still amazed when I go to other events and see things get 15 or 20 or even 30 minutes behind the published schedule. It’s just so disrespectful to the audience to do that in my opinion.
- hermitcrab 3y agoAlso disrespectful to any speakers that have to follow.