4 ms·
"Quantity has a quality all of its own" combined with "good enough if you don't care about manpower losses" I believe the IS-1 was a better tank. Certainly mor
by ggm 3y ago
"Quantity has a quality all of its own" combined with "good enough if you don't care about manpower losses"
I believe the IS-1 was a better tank. Certainly more powerfully armed.
I was misled by slanders to believing the Sherman was at best mediocre and at worst earned the sobriquet "ronson" when it was survivorship bias: people lived to say how bad it was where other tank crews simply didn't come back. That said, it needed the up gunning to the British weapon which made the firefly. British tanks started bad but got better. By end of war they were pretty ok, and survived into the modern tank era sold on to other nations in volume and for engineering uses.
- nicbou 3y agoThe Firefly was a flawed compromise. It made the Sherman an effective big cat killer, but affected its rate of fire and infantry fighting power. But yes the Sherman was an excellent tank for its job: to wage war on multiple continents from factories in America, with regard for logistics, maintenance, ease of transportation, crew comfort and crew survivability. It was a great example of pragmatism.