5 ms·
“Prefer A over B” rules usually are problematic because what they usually mean is: (1) There is a concrete set of cases where A is better than B. (2) But, ther
by dragonwriter 3y ago
“Prefer A over B” rules usually are problematic because what they usually mean is:
(1) There is a concrete set of cases where A is better than B.
(2) But, there is also a concrete set of cases where B is better than A.
(3) And, either (a) the cases where A is better than B are more common than the reverse or at least (b) people in the environment where the advice is developed are currently choosing B in cases where A is significantly better.
But, critically, “prefer A over B” does not communicate the set of cases where A is better than B or vice versa, so it tends to lead to the conditions where “prefer B over A” becomes the advice based on (1) and (2) being unchanged but (3)(b) working in the opposite direction.