5 ms·
96% of US hospital websites share visitor info with Meta, Google, data brokers
- lupire 3y agoAre they sharing health data?
- unglaublich 3y agoWell, you generally browse the pages that are relevant to your health concerns, so it's indirect health data. It's how building a profile works. No one tells Google or Facebook "Zack likes Ferrari", but Zack's browsing of Ferrari articles tells that about him.
- nemomarx 3y agoKnowing you visited a hospital at a certain time and date would be health data, right? Are they just sharing like, email addresses in a big list, or are they giving metadata about when people show up?
- ceejayoz 3y agoIt depends, basically. https://www.hhs.gov/hipaa/for-professionals/privacy/guidance/hipaa-online-tracking/index.html https://www.hhs.gov/hipaa/for-professionals/privacy/guidance... > Regulated entities may also have unauthenticated webpages, which are webpages that do not require users to log in before they are able to access the webpage, such as a webpage with general information about the regulated entity like their location, visiting hours, employment opportunities, or their policies and procedures. Tracking technologies on many unauthenticated webpages do not have access to individuals’ PHI; in this case, a regulated entity’s use of such tracking technologies is not regulated by the HIPAA Rules. However, in some cases, tracking technologies on unauthenticated webpages may have access to PHI, in which case the HIPAA Rules apply to the regulated entities’ use of tracking technologies and disclosures to the tracking technology vendors. Regulated entities are required to “[e]nsure the confidentiality, integrity, and availability of all electronic PHI the [regulated entity] creates, receives, maintains, or transmits.” Thus, regulated entities that are considering the use of online tracking technologies should consider whether any PHI will be transmitted to a tracking technology vendor, and take appropriate steps consistent with the HIPAA Rules.
- xxs 3y agoof course not - only visited pages, time spent on them, stuff like that.
- TheNewsIsHere 3y agoThat greatly depends on implementation. I’ve been implementing Google Ads, Analytics, and Tag Manager for a medical practice recently. Google’s official stance is that PHI is categorically prohibited to send to Ads/Analytics services, but it’s very easy for a marketing firm to unwittingly do. Thankfully I’m working with a conscientious marketing firm and our client is diligent and well meaning, so it’s easy to avoid the pitfalls, but naively following many integration walkthroughs could have you sending entire form content to Google (or others). I’m sure that’s one of the reason Google explicitly says “don’t put us on your EMR pages” (paraphrased).
- xxs 3y agoI didn't imply ads at all - google analytics has quite extensive info about the patient, the 'user', as is. The visited sites/subsections and stuff would be quite revealing. Just using the same massive aggregator as your metrics provider is where it gets wrong.
- TheNewsIsHere 3y agoThat’s true! Our client is a small practice in pediatrics so we don’t face the same challenges as say, the Mayo Clinic would, in trying to avoid profiling based on indirect information. Most people aren’t going to be browsing the Betty Ford clinic for fun. They’re looking for something specific. That’s juicy for analytics. I’m glad I don’t have to deal with that challenge. (Conversion matching quality isn’t a fun challenge either. We’ve landed at “the practice will have to do that themselves to avoid the privacy obstacles”.)
- ldayley 3y agoLike when you visit “cancer patient support resources” and read for a while…
- skywhopper 3y agoWhich doctors you go to and what types of specialities you search for can tell a lot about a person. Oh, did they search for mental health clinics? Or dialysis treatment? Or abortion providers? Or gender reassignment surgery? Or vasectomy providers? Depending on where the widgets are placed, they might could tell when your appointments are or what messages you send to your doctor through their clinic's website.
- e40 3y agoClearly the HN crowd believes this is a much bigger problem than 99% of the population. I just don’t see it being fixed anytime soon. Depressing.
- phuff 3y agoThe title of the original article is a little misleading. It's _website_ visitor tracking and it looks like it's really just advertising analytics... That's maybe bad but it's also the same as like... 98% of all other websites.
- xxs 3y agoThat's really pretty much everything, google knows you may think you have breast cancer -- email, gender, age, visit pages, etc. Certain sites and information classes/types are not just like the rest of 98%.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- malisper 3y agoWebsite visitor information is still really sensitive. If you book an HIV test online, you probably don't want Google and Facebook to know that.
- dylan604 3y ago[flagged]
- tasty_freeze 3y agoImagine you stated online that you don't like the fact that your Uber ride data is being sold to Facebook. Then imagine someone said, "If you don't like theZuck or Googs knowing where whereabouts and who you are visiting, just walk when you need to go somewhere." Hopefully you'll realize why you are being down-voted.
- dylan604 3y agoJust because you think it is okay to continue to feed the beast is not my issue. I can spare the -4 points to engage the discussion. I also don't use Uber because I don't support their history even if they might no longer behave that way now. You don't have to walk just because you don't use Uber. There are other ways to get around. The fact that you feel this way just means to me that you've drunk too much of the Kool-aid. Society has become lazy/complacent with the status quo, and does not want to put forth the effort to fight for the rights that they so freely complain about on web forums. Yes, things can be more convenient if you are willing to accept the true costs. Things can be more difficult when you choose to not accept the true costs. Just because they are more difficult does not mean it is impossible.
- apantel 3y ago96% of… all websites.
- tasty_freeze 3y agoDon't you think hospitals should be held to a higher standard than the analytics gathered when you visit, say, dominoes.com?
- JohnFen 3y agoNot really. I think all of them should be held to high enough standards that this isn't an issue with any of them.
- JoshTko 3y agoAre they sharing search terms, type of doctors selected, symptom checking info which is common on these websites? Especially if all data can be use to uniquely identify this is pretty problematic.
- internetter 3y agoIf you've used google analytics, you know that a lot of this would be implicitly shared. like the top comment, I think hospitals just aren't thinking about how disastrous this is.
- skywhopper 3y agoFacebook widgets definitely attempt to track this sort of information. Anything that goes in the URL bar is trivial to grab, but pretty much anything typed on a page is also snaggable.
- resource_waste 3y ago[flagged]
- ThaDood 3y agoLink to the actual study cited in the article - https://jamanetwork.com/journals/jamanetworkopen/fullarticle/2817444 https://jamanetwork.com/journals/jamanetworkopen/fullarticle... And at a quick glance it looks like it is mostly related to website information, not PHI or PII.
- wolverine876 3y ago> is mostly related to website information, not PHI or PII If you are looking for an oncologist or abortions or whatever else, that's PHI. We know well that the industry has profiles on Americans and probably can identify you.
- westpfelia 3y agoExactly! If hospital systems are selling this, who is buying it? Health insurance companies. Then they can judge if they should still cover you or raise your rates.
- wolverine876 3y agoYes, and many other organizations also want this information. Your detailed profile is valuable, and my impression is that health info is particularly valuable.
- malisper 3y agoNote that website information can still be PHI. From[0]: > if an individual were looking at a hospital’s webpage listing its oncology services to seek a second opinion on treatment options for their brain tumor, the collection and transmission of the individual’s IP address, geographic location, or other identifying information showing their visit to that webpage is a disclosure of PHI to the extent that the information is both identifiable and related to the individual’s health or future health care [0] https://www.hhs.gov/hipaa/for-professionals/privacy/guidance/hipaa-online-tracking/index.html https://www.hhs.gov/hipaa/for-professionals/privacy/guidance...
- dylan604 3y ago
- iambateman 3y agoI’ve worked with the marketing folks for a large hospital and it is my strong belief that they haven’t considered the implications of sharing this data. Legislation is in order to define what analytics companies cannot do with data from healthcare sites. I’m not sure if there are other categories which ought to be protected, but healthcare is certainly one.
- rqtwteye 3y agoA hospital shouldn’t do have to do marketing. They should focus on providing health care.
- paulryanrogers 3y agoPrivatizing and moving to for-profit hospitals has been a boon for PE. All this attention on patient outcomes is just slowing down the inevitable transition. /s
- devilbunny 3y agoEven in a fully public, NHS-like system, they do. Come to X hospital, no need to go to [big city] for your [surgery] when you can have it here - well, if they don't do this, people will go to the [big city], and if it goes on long enough, the NHS-like system will cut their funding and possibly reassign surgical specialists away due to lack of activity. That leaves the smaller city with less access to healthcare, even if it's free to the user at the point of service. [EDIT: my karma is now 667. Would someone please remove their upvote just for a bit? A screenshot of "devilbunny (666)" from HN would be a great little digital memento.]
- shepherdjerred 3y agoHere's a downvote :)
- devilbunny 3y agoThanks, but two other people found something else I wrote worthy in the meantime. Urgh. I mean, I could lose points easily, the hard part is only losing one or two, not forty. Um, emacs and vi are both pretty useful editors and there's really no big difference when you get used to one of them? I mostly like pico for editing? [karma whirring up and down could power a small city]
- tootie 3y agoI think the term "data broker" is getting slightly abused. Using Google Analytics or a Facebook pixel is almost mandatory for understanding how your site is used. Especially if you don't have a super sophisticated marketing team who can be more bespoke about it. They also mention tools like Hotjar which is usually used for those little popup surveys. Companies that share data with brokers usually do it via backend processes that would not be visible from a network inspector.
- doctaj 3y agoHotjar’s flagship functionality is heat maps and session recordings — which show aggregate and individual mouse movements, respectively.
- matttproud 3y agoWriting this as a citizen of the country, what the fuck is wrong with the United States? Why is the continued debasement of its citizens something that they put up with?
- dogman144 3y agoIf you’re in tech, you can first look to your industry coworkers clearing $500k tc at the companies building and maintaining these products. Not to far from being a cigarette salesmen at Philip Morris in 1980 these days, just like when the data was coming out on how toxic the product was, PM was hiring scientists to put out competing public studies and threatening funding of university research that countered them (Meta is doing this currently…), on and on. Keep working there and ignore the growing research and civil impact like this article? Or..
- skywhopper 3y agoThe sad part is that even if none of these hospitals used such widgets, Chrome or Edge are sharing most of the same information with Google and Microsoft anyway.
- malisper 3y agoDidn't expect something relevant to what I do to show up on HN. This has been a hot button issue for the last two years ever since the Markup did a report on hospitals sharing data with Facebook[0]. Since then the government has explicitly called this out as a problem[1] and a number of hospitals and related companies are dealing with fines and lawsuits[2][3][4] Given the government is actually enforcing the law for once, this is one of the few times I've seen people take regulation like this seriously. [0] https://themarkup.org/pixel-hunt/2022/06/16/facebook-is-receiving-sensitive-medical-information-from-hospital-websites https://themarkup.org/pixel-hunt/2022/06/16/facebook-is-rece... [1] https://www.hhs.gov/hipaa/for-professionals/privacy/guidance/hipaa-online-tracking/index.html https://www.hhs.gov/hipaa/for-professionals/privacy/guidance... [2] https://www.ftc.gov/news-events/news/press-releases/2023/07/ftc-gives-final-approval-order-banning-betterhelp-sharing-sensitive-health-data-advertising https://www.ftc.gov/news-events/news/press-releases/2023/07/... [3] https://www.ftc.gov/news-events/news/press-releases/2023/02/ftc-enforcement-action-bar-goodrx-sharing-consumers-sensitive-health-info-advertising https://www.ftc.gov/news-events/news/press-releases/2023/02/... [4] https://finance.yahoo.com/news/costco-sued-accused-sharing-confidential-143613079.html https://finance.yahoo.com/news/costco-sued-accused-sharing-c...
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- maram 3y agoIt’s interesting how, most if not all, hospitals have switched to use Mychart https://www.mychart.org https://www.mychart.org!
- JakeStone 3y agoI have a regular prescription I have gotten refilled at Kaiser Permanente for years. I use their online site and get my meds mailed to me. It may have been 2 years ago or so, but the process stopped working and wouldn't accept my confirmation after giving my credit card info. I've got a handful of privacy tools on my browser. I finally gave in and temporarily white listed the pharmacy and still cleared out any trackers. Sent the web admin a basic, "WTF, folks?" and got a BS non answer. Fast forward to maybe November or December last year. Refill time, and the trackers were even worse. I kind of need my meds though. So I created a new account on my computer, and ordered my meds. Then I filed a complaint of a possible HIPAA violation, starting at https://www.hhs.gov/hipaa/filing-a-complaint/index.html https://www.hhs.gov/hipaa/filing-a-complaint/index.html and was polite, factual, and provided some non hysterical examples of how a prescription could indicate a specific health issue with resulting advertising or PII release to parties not needing it. I received an email at the end of February. I was probably not the only person that sent a complaint, but the end result is that KP is being investigated. Yay.
- sizzle 3y agoThanks for holding them accountable. This stuff is such a needless barrier to care for so many people.
- m463 3y agoI went through a similar gauntlet with kaiser as well. This was years ago, but I complained that kaiser had trackers throughout its website for doubleclick and googletagmanager. (nowadays they don't use those domains and go directly to google.com, I assume because people don't block that) I complained. To be clear, the tracking links traverse the entire website - communication with your doctor, test results, prescriptions, even the complaint form I filed out. I got the same sort of non-answers. I pushed and pushed and finally, I did get an answer - "the website is a convenience". I blocked the trackers, and pretty soon to continue to use the website, I had to agree to the privacy policy. I didn't agree. I stopped using the website. But they wouldn't let me delete my account. (I think california law allows you to ask.) I called multiple times. I still have an account and get emails from them.
- 3y ago
- rapjr9 3y agoOnce your data is inside the hospital it can still be widely shared, though subject to regulation. I was part of two research efforts called SHARPS and THaW that studied trust, privacy, and security in medical systems: https://sharps.org/ https://sharps.org/ https://thaw.org/ https://thaw.org/ One research group analyzed how patient data is shared inside medical systems and found that in some cases as many 300 different entities had access to your data. The billing companies, consultants, out of network clinicians, staff, testing companies, supply companies, IT management companies, outside expert consultations, insurance companies, medical device companies, data analysis companies, and many more. In some cases it was unclear if the data was further shared with subcontractors and other third parties.