5 ms·
Here are some question for PG (or any of the YC partners): How many of the YC founders are college dropouts? How many of the YC founders that had successful (
by jedberg 15y ago
Here are some question for PG (or any of the YC partners):
How many of the YC founders are college dropouts?
How many of the YC founders that had successful (by whatever definition you'd like) exits were college dropouts?
And lastly, how do you feel about college education in general? Do you agree with Thiel, that it is not a good use of time and money? Is college education a big factor when choosing companies for YC?
- kennystone 15y agoThe stats don't matter because college has been the default choice of young people for decades. The winners in life usually go to college, so the best companies will usually be founded by college graduates. The point is that college isn't adding much, certainly not $250k, towards the success of those founders. And it may be even more detrimental to society than the debt - so many of New York and Chicago's best and brightest were steered to banks and hedge funds, for example. YC funds a lot of founders who are young and have not finished college.
- jedberg 15y agoThe stats are more of an interesting anecdote than data, but they are still interesting none the less.
- larrys 15y ago(I'm not YC) But, interesting and related to this entire conversation. I forked to the article in the NY Times circa 1996 that you were quoted in (from your profile): http://www.jedberg.net/article.html http://www.jedberg.net/article.html And this in particular, (1996): "Dartmouth, one of the most academically competitive colleges in the country, has long had a reputation for encouraging computer use by students. It now has the new distinction of being one of the most e-mail-intensive, delivering about 250,000 electronic messages a day to 5,000 students and 3,000 faculty and staff members, or more than 30 messages apiece." And, in fact, I spent many hours at Wharton in the late 70's early 80's with a Dec-10 at the computer center and CRT's. Had I been a college dropout of course I would have never had that opportunity which led to so many things (computer only being one thing). I would probably have had the same opportunity (with computers of course) at a public college so cost didn't have to be a factor. The situation of course depends greatly on the individual circumstances of course and there is no question that it is applicable to people beyond the professionals (Doctors etc.) that Thiel seems to acknowledge as having to spend the time and money.
- jedberg 15y agoAh my past comes back to haunt me! I guess that's what I get for linking to it on my website. Yes, I agree that I would have never learned what I did about computers if I hadn't had a chance to play with them like I did at Berkeley.
- jonny_eh 15y agoYa, circumstance is still important. It all depends on what you want to do and what you have access to. If you want to be a web or mobile developer, why do you need to go to school? What can they offer you that free (or even cheap for pay) online courses can't? If on the other hand, you're interested in biotech and need access to the equipment and knowledge only available at a university, by all means go for it! But if/when the day comes when that kind of knowledge is ubiquitous, like internet tech became, I hope you'll reconsider.
- temphn 15y agoIt's a societal convention that the smartest people go to college. However, systematic studies suggest that this correlation is not causation: http://www.dailyfinance.com/2011/02/23/elite-colleges-not-the-only-path-to-elite-paychecks/ http://www.dailyfinance.com/2011/02/23/elite-colleges-not-th... Now, the two economists have updated the study with new data, more detail -- and the results are even more compelling. In the abstract, they report: "When we adjust for unobserved student ability by controlling for the average SAT score of the colleges that students applied to, our estimates of the return to college selectivity fall substantially and are generally indistinguishable from zero." In this view, college is just an imperfect, expensive proxy for your SAT score. And the reason this proxy exists is because of the Griggs vs. Duke Power ruling, which prohibits companies from administering SAT-type tests of general reasoning. It may not be coincidental that the explosion in college prices began around that time. If it turns out that a three hour SAT at $100 can replace a four year college degree costing $250,000 in terms of its predictive value for an employer - and the Dale/Krueger study sure seems to show this - then yes, Peter Thiel is on to something very big, and you may want to short higher-ed. Or at least Sallie Mae.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- dmragone 15y agoThis is missing the point. The indicator colleges provide occurs upon admittance. Dropping out is perfectly fine, because you can still say you went to (MIT/Harvard/Stanford). And therefore were good enough to get the degree, but had better things to do.
- kami8845 15y agopg has said before that he only likes taking dropouts into the program if they've gone to college long enough to know what they are missing.
- brackin 15y agoThere's a number of 17 - 18 year old founders that applied instead of college. Not sure on dropout numbers.