12 ms·
H-1B visa fraud alive and well amid anti-abuse efforts
- karakot 3y agoI only have one proposal. If a company has a layoff in number of thousands, then the company should be barred from h1-b for a certain number of years.
- avidiax 3y agoIf a sector has increasing unemployment or sub-inflationary total comp growth, no H1-B's for that sector.
- ahmeneeroe-v2 3y agoThese are both wonderful proposals. Happy to see people starting to talk this way. Hopefully we'll see a change soon.
- vishalontheline 3y agoThis is an interesting proposal. Unfortunately, the way around this is a "business solutions" company, whose main solution is providing H1-B'd temps to large companies. There are tons of those around: local companies hire people on H1-B. Foreign companies send people over on L1.
- karakot 3y agoYeah, thank you for reminding that the most of simple solutions are wrong usually.
- psychlops 3y agoThat sounds like a huge push for outsourcing.
- karakot 3y agoEverything is a push for outsourcing. Workers rights is a push (looking at you Boeing, moving from WA to SC). Ecological rules - looking at all toxic production which had been moved to the places with less accountabilities instead of fixing it. I'm pretty sure there're more examples.
- psychlops 3y agoDebasing the currency is not a push for outsourcing and, in fact, encourages exports.
- darth_avocado 3y agoSounds good in theory, but not at all practical. Apple just laid off 600 employees working on their electric car initiative, they moved employees internally where skills were transferable, but the rest were let go. But in your proposal, they would now not be able to hire for ANY job function on H1B.
- jdhzzz 3y agoWould a 1 year ban for H1B for Apple be that big of a problem after a "significant" layoff? Or maybe can only apply for up to a maximum of some (10%? 15%? 25%) percentage of the last year's layoffs?
- darth_avocado 3y agoI think 1 year is a lot of time in the industry for a blanket ban. If apple wants to get out of building a car but pivot into building AI (which is what they’re doing) or if a different company wants to reduce its sales and marketing footprint while increasing its dev efforts (a lot of tech companies are doing this), then these blanket bans are unreasonable and detrimental to everyone (customers, existing employees, shareholders including people’s retirement funds), including citizens. However, say Apple fires 600 car engineers and then files for 400 H1Bs for 400 car engineering positions after 6 months, then they need to be held accountable. Which to a certain extent already happens. USCIS will often deny H1B petitions in such cases and green card processing (PERM certification part) is usually paused at a company level after significant layoffs. As of today Facebook and other tech companies that had significant layoffs last year, are not filing PERM applications for their current employees and they won’t for at least a year after the layoffs.
- karakot 3y agoso the actual workers [s]are harmed[/s]held responsible, not the companies.
- Rinzler89 3y agoEvery system who's main job is controlling or gatekeeping a limited resource in high demand will 100% always get abused to some extent for personal gain or for profit. Same with housing. Especially when there's litte to no negative consequences for those caught abusing it. Like why wouldn't you? If you don't abuse it, then you're basically leaving money on the table versus your competitors who do abuse it. Until law enforcement picks up and fines outweigh this "cost of doing business", system abuse will continue as per.
- postepowanieadm 3y agoIt will never happen, as the Law Enforcement is a part of the system that organized and profits from the fraud.
- Muromec 3y agoWait, one can file fraudlent applications for visa sponsorship, get caught and will not be banned for like 5 years from the system? Why? It makes no sense
- bcrosby95 3y agoI don't know if it's normal, but abuse was so bad this year they did multiple redraws.
- addicted 3y agoThis is not true. If you commit fraud you will be punished. The problem however is that Congress refuses to fund USCIS. For example, until a few years ago, USCIS was incapable of taking digital payments because Congress refused to fund any digitization efforts for over 2 decades. They’ve still only allowed this only at the margins, so applications are not digitized. They exist in massive boxes of documents in basements. So they don’t even know who’s applied and how many times they’ve applied.
- throwme_123 3y ago[flagged]
- throwv666 3y ago[flagged]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- Seanambers 3y agoJust for fun - would this work as an European as well?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- cherryteastain 3y agoWhy is there a lottery anyway instead of a salary ranking/salary threshold system? This'd disincentivize bad actors, ensure the US domestic labor pool is not undercut, and (more or less) lead to higher quality H-1B immigrants.
- rudolfwinestock 3y agoYou just answered your own question.
- bradleyjg 3y agoBecause regions and industries that pay less would be mad, and they’ve got lots of congressmen.
- shadow28 3y agoThat could potentially be solved by having different buckets for different regions and industries? Seems like that'd be a much fairer system than the current lottery one.
- achow 3y agoDifferent regions can be easily gamed by opening PO Box offices in all the regions.
- Muromec 3y agoWell, then you check tax return of employees -- if they don't actually reside in the same region, the last person who touched the immigration form is getting a date with a rattan stick.
- DopplerSmell 3y agoFair is an odd word here, the system should work for the greatest benefit for Americans. I think a wage threshold and weighting would be best, but others think a controlled random mixing of labour markets is better for the overall economy.
- Dma54rhs 3y agoWhy is it suddenly called fraud and abuse when the "immigrants are taking our jobs" but from the upper middle class?
- runlaszlorun 3y agoIt’s not called fraud and abuse because “immigrants are taking our jobs”. It’s called fraud and abuse because it’s fraud and abuse. It’s been prevalent in the H1B process for years. Personally, I’m all for America bringing in talented foreign nationals. But the H1B process is bad for foreigners looking to work in the US who get way underpaid and don’t have easy options to work at a different firm. And bad for American workers who have to compete against underpaid wages. Given that the point of the program is to bring in talent unavailable, it’s become a farce. I think companies hiring H1B’s at below market wages probably think they’re getting a bargain. But I doubt that most of them - maybe other than FAANG - are getting good talent at lowball wages. It’s a bad program all around.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- notdang 3y agoIt seems that you didn't read the article. I'll help you with the fraud part: > When I was at USCIS," explained Law, "you would have registrations or petitions with very common names. The belief from some of the fraud folks was that some of the common names were inserted in there and then these businesses, after they won the lottery, would then go out and actually find somebody [with that name] as opposed to having a real candidate in place." > One form of H-1B fraud involves companies colluding to file multiple petitions on behalf of the same foreign worker. This serves to give the IT consultancies involved in trying to bring this worker to the US a greater chance of having their applicant selected, and of collecting a commission. As above, that's supposed to be more difficult under the new system.
- 3y ago
- FrustratedMonky 3y agoJust question. For software jobs. Why is there a demand that can drive abuse. When there are so many people that can't find jobs? It seems like right now there should not be enough demand for H1-b (for software) to justify abuse. Like it shouldn't be profitable enough.
- odux 3y agoThere are actually four large “buckets” on H1B usage in software. First are the “regular” software jobs. At the large tech players or other regular companies (eg a software job at a bank). Like you said, there is a lot of supply due to layoffs and not a lot of demand. H1Bs in this area are also limited this year due to this. Second are the college graduates. Once you complete a STEM degree as a foreign student you get three years of OPT which is for all practical purposes a work permit to work in STEM jobs (with some conditions). If the student (now employee) needs to continue working for the company in the US after this they need a H1B or a green card. Most genuine companies apply for H1B for these employees the moment they join and because it is a lottery keep doing it in the hope that the employee gets a H1B and continues working. These are not new jobs but people in jobs for up to 3 years that the company wants to continue employing and does not intend to layoff. Supply and demand plays a smaller part here. Third are the outsourcing companies, TCS, Accenture and the like. These companies have people in India and contracts with large Us companies. They predict some number of demand for moving people from India to US (to help support the rest of the offshore team, to replace a higher paid employee at the US company with a lower paid employee of the contracting company etc). These companies will mostly but just barely follow the law (they have also been caught and paid files) and will use all loopholes available to them. These are the biggest “abuses” you see in the press. While the general “abuse” news in the press is about these companies replacing American workers with lower cost H1B employees the other problem is they are not catering to current demand but predicting work at a “client” based on current or future contract, creating “job openings” based on this (which they can, it is their own company) and flooding the lottery. The fourth are smaller body shops and “consulting” companies in the US. These also predict demand and “create jobs” to enter applicants to the lottery. But the difference is typically the companies in the third category don’t get the employees to the US if there is no “client project” (as in, real demand) and even if they they do, they have the means to pay the minimum required pay the H1B demands - they are big enough to afford a bench of employees. The companies in the fourth category will get people to the US first on fake, or near-fake demand and then pitch them to “clients”. In the meantime the employee is not paid the companies skirt the law in all ways as possible to continue “holding” the employee. They also refuse to share paperwork with the employee (preventing them from moving jobs) and sometimes have the employees pay for the H1B which is illegal (but gets to the grey area if they get the payment in India before the employee travels to the US). There is very less demand today in the first category. The second category is not much related to demand. Most of the “abuse” happens in the third (by volume) and fourth (by severity). Abuse in quotes because a lot of this is in the gray areas of legality and sometimes outrightly legal but not “right”.
- ilrwbwrkhv 3y ago> Rather than hire US workers to perform the onshore work, these firms hire large numbers of H-1B and L-1 visa workers to fill the jobs in America. Terrible for America. And terrible for India.
- robertlagrant 3y agoBut good for the people running the consulting companies, and their friends in politics.
- ilrwbwrkhv 3y agoYup and that is why people like Narayan Murthy are the greatest criminals in the history of India. Ruined an entire generation of Indians by teaching them to do second hand work and stopped any original thinking from happening. That is why they are so behind China.
- blackhawkC17 3y agoHow is it Murthy’s fault? India started behind on many sectors and needed time to catch up. These vilified IT sweatshop jobs were and remain stable paths to the middle class for young Indians growing up in poverty. It’s only recently that India started to produce high-quality startups, because they had already built a base with the low-hanging fruit first. P.S. - I’m not Indian.
- ilrwbwrkhv 3y agoIndia has no high-quality startups because of outsourcing.
- finolex1 3y agoI think you're getting the order of causation reversed. The alternative to Infosys in the 90s would be to move abroad or work in a government job. You can't build a Porsche on day 1 - you have to start with the 10k car. The consulting companies kick started the engineering base that eventually led to MNCs/big tech setting up offices in India, and the broader startup ecosystem today.
- throwkk 3y agoI was told that entering in as a refugee is the easiest way compared to H1B, Is it true?
- binarymax 3y ago“Easiest” way is probably getting married to a citizen. On the scale of least horrible, refugee status might be OK if you can get it, but the anti-refugee climate here has never been worse.
- ChrisMarshallNY 3y ago> “Easiest” way is probably getting married to a citizen. I don't think that's the case, anymore. I remember a notorious case, around here, where a guy had a Russian wife (I have no idea of the background -but they were married for many years), he was dying of leukemia, and required her around-the-clock care, and they deported her.
- lesuorac 3y agoI mean you probably are missing a bunch of details. Being married doesn't automatically grant you citizenship. It does give a way to apply for a green card (IIRC, no caps on this path so it's "easy") which then gives a path to citizenship (naturalization). So; no-duh if the guy's wife is russian she can be deported; she's probably overstayed her visa while caring for the guy.
- ChrisMarshallNY 3y agoMe Mum was British[0], but had to get US citizenship, in order to bring in her mother, for final years care. She was pissed off. [0] https://cmarshall.com/miscellaneous/SheilaMarshall.htm https://cmarshall.com/miscellaneous/SheilaMarshall.htm
- astura 3y agoDude, there must be something incredibly specific about this case for this to be a thing. Like the wife just said she was a tourist and never left instead of applying for a green card. If you just do the paperwork - enter the US under a K1 Visa (fiancé(e) visa), get married, and then apply for a green card once you're married - you won't be randomly deported when your spouse gets leukemia. It is actually is very easy (multiple people in my family have done this - one guy has even sponsored multiple foreign wives because they keep leaving him cuz he's an asshole). But you do have to do the paperwork if you don't wanna get deported.
- Zigurd 3y agoSince H-1B says it is supposedly intended for high-value employees unobtainable in the US, why not auction the visas, with a reserve price that would prevent them being used to push down wages?
- rayiner 3y agoBecause the system is really intended to drive down skilled worker wages and subsidize American universities that essentially sell American permanent residency to full-tuition paying foreign students.
- lgleason 3y agothis ^^^
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- shagie 3y agoNot "high value", but rather "high skill". Some examples of occupations that need a professional degree in order to be filled. Information Technology Software engineers Database administrators Teachers Primary Secondary University Health care professionals Physicians Nurses Dentists Psychologists Engineers Civil Chemical Mechanical Industrial Surveyors ... and Fashion models With an auction approach, would the software engineers completely at big tech companies (or consultancies capable of demanding big tech compensation) continue to be able to drown out the other professions? https://h1bdata.info/index.php?em=central+consolidated+school+district&job=&city=&year=2023 https://h1bdata.info/index.php?em=central+consolidated+schoo... https://h1bdata.info/index.php?em=emory+healthcare+inc&job=&city=&year=2023 https://h1bdata.info/index.php?em=emory+healthcare+inc&job=&... The visa lottery makes it difficult to reliably get H1B visa teachers. H1B visa abuse makes it even more difficult. An auction would make the H1B visa program into a "visa for software developers where consultancies charge high prices to win auctions and pay their employees little."
- 3y ago
- greatpostman 3y agoThe real fraud is H1Bs just hire each other at American companies
- victor106 3y agoWith all the tech layoffs, IT is actually loosing jobs. Do they really need H-1B till the IT job market stabilizes?
- onemoresoop 3y agoThere are multiple factors. Some H-1B are very skilled and in need. But there are consultancies who make money off these workers and don't care about the skill, they'll do whatever they can to make money. Also another factor is suppressing salaries as people need to compete these lowly paid workers...
- lgleason 3y agoH-1B's are a race to the bottom.
- alephknoll 3y agoThe point of H-1B is to lower wages. Not to stabilize them. It's a way to increase supply of labor which puts downward pressure on wages.
- pkoiralap 3y agoSomething that I personally feel unfair about the H1B lottery is that it doesn't consider where you live and what you are currently doing. Students that graduate through a STEM degree get to work for 3 years in their OPT (Optional Practical Training). This extends then to them having 3 chances (one per year) at getting the H1B. Now what's unfair is that an employer in the US can apply H1B for employees living oversees. That application then goes to the same pool where H1B application of the employees that are already living in the US go. The very same people that already hold a college or graduate degree, are already living in the US, and are contributing to the US economy. Unfortunately, the lottery is fair. So those that don't get picked up even after their third attempt are kicked out. They leave their life that they were trying to build in the US, potentially their girlfriends and partners, their friends, and their possessions. While that happens, someone who has never stepped foot in the US soil gets to go to the US. So in a sense it's fair for them. And while there is no real metric to measure this, when compared, between the fairness people oversees get and the unfairness people already living in the US experience, I personally think that the later tips the scale by a huge margin.
- rtkwe 3y agoI would expect that to be partially counter balanced by companies being more willing to sponsor someone already in the US over someone currently overseas? Haven't had to go through that process fortunately but seems likely from a practical standpoint.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- tivert 3y ago[replying to deleted child comment] > Sponsored green cards take like 1.5+ years to process, so someone could be OPT the whole time but the employer would have to get the application rolling quickly after hiring or else risk their employee having to go back to their home country for some period of time when OPT runs out and the green card is approved. Add to that: 1. Some (many?) companies do not file for green cards right away, because they like to keep their employees tied down with an H1-B. I think my employer has a policy of not applying for a green card until the employee has 5 years or service or something. 2. IIRC, there are country-based quotas for employment-based green cards, so it could take very much longer than 1.5 years to get one. E.g. I think it can take 10+ years for an Indian to get one. Though I think having an active application for one is enough to stay in country for H1-B holders (though I'm even less sure about OPT holders).
- victor106 3y ago> We're told some consultancies tap up foreigners to work for clients illegally using the identities of legit citizens or green card holders. "That's where the true scam is and the real money is at," If they are really doing this. It’s outrageous. And out right illegal.
- testfrequency 3y agoI read this a few times and am really struggling to see how this scam works out. Crudely speaking, are these agencies just finding existing green card holders and American citizens with names that they can use to put down on paperwork…then hire the foreign worker who happens to have have the same name…and this somehow bypasses some sort of legal checks somewhere? What’s the point of a SSN?
- victor106 3y agoYeah, I was thinking the same. This is just wrong on so many levels. This is what leads to identity fraud. I am reaching out to my congressman and senators office to let them know that several elements of this program are abused so much they should take a fresh look at this. I suggest you do the same. I truly believe that immigration is what keeps America the greatest country in the world. But this kind of abuse needs to stop.
- shmatt 3y agoGiving your place of work fake IDs and passports is already illegal. How would your representatives fix this? Fingerprinting every day in the lobby?
- ab8 3y agoWhy do they all keep saying H1-B workers are underpaid? The government determines minimum pay for each application. My experience has been that this number is quite high.
- bdcravens 3y agoPay is only "high" as it relates to the experience level and the location.
- gibbonsrcool 3y agoEven if the pay by salary amount is fair, these workers can be exploited to work more hours than their non-H1B colleagues such that if their pay was broken down hourly it would be comparatively lower.
- bluGill 3y agoBack in their home country they are probably expected to work those same hours (or more!) for a lot less money. By our standards it is exploit, but often for them it is better.
- gibbonsrcool 3y agoI understand their incentives. But the fact that they are exploited here, just less so still, makes the exploitation wrong. The H1B program needs to end.
- prithsr 3y agoThe government sets payscale 'tiers' based on qualifications / roles, and these tiers determine the minimum you're able to earn once you obtain an H-1B or PERM. the employer is still able to work w/ the lawyers to get you to fall at a lesser paying tier, and also offer no further growth/compensation as they have no incentive to-- regardless of performance or structure. Source: My exact role and bulk of responsibilities are valued at at least 2x; but given how difficult it is (for me, at least) to transition out given the job market, I have no other option but to stay or simply leave the country.
- alwayslikethis 3y agoAbove all, I wonder why brain drain is not viewed as a geopolitical tool. High skilled young professionals from China and Russia are essentially non-replaceable due to their declining birth rates. You can do a lot more damage this way than through various sanctions. A lot of people already want to move to the US, so this can easily be done by getting rid of the cap and switching to a tax on the employer to simplify the process.
- avidiax 3y agoThe trouble is that optimally using that tool would involve completely draining one category of brain in the target country. That would make a missing link in their economy, but the incoming workers would terribly suppress wages in that sector in the receiving country.
- kachurovskiy 3y agoIn Germany visa applicants are evaluated based on merit without a lottery for decade and it's working well. US could do something similar instead of using a hole in the fence but it doesn't look like the decision making system is capable of making hard decisions like that.
- abswest 3y agowhat numeric metric do you use to assess that it is "working well" in Germany?
- kachurovskiy 3y agohttps://www.bamf.de/EN/Themen/Statistik/BlaueKarteEU/blauekarteeu-node.html https://www.bamf.de/EN/Themen/Statistik/BlaueKarteEU/blaueka... I haven't heard of any discontent with the program from locals or applicants. It's growing, too.
- 62951413 3y agoDid you know that you could have 15 years of working in the Bay Area experience and still be refused a German blue card because you majored in Physics or EE instead of CS? But mere work visas were easily obtainable a couple years ago with a signed contract.
- Yizahi 3y agoThere are two options to get Blue Card. One is education, but second is professional work for I think 10 years above certain threshold salary (very low threshold for IT, even by EU means). So that 15 YOE IT engineer can certainly apply and get Blue Card. The only nuance is that it needs to be full employment, self employment doesn't count or is problematic iirc.
- rel2thr 3y agothe locals aren't upset about salaries? German programmer salaries seem to be on par w/ unskilled labor. If I was a local I would want to stop immigration until supply + demand equilibriated around USA levels.
- shermantanktop 3y agoThe H-1B system is voluntary indentured servitude. It’s well paid, especially by the standards of the source country. Employers love it. Visa applicants still find the prospect appealing, even if their experience may not be great. But the power dynamics of the situation are not that different from what a migrant lettuce picker in California has to navigate. The lettuce picker actually might have more freedom.
- psychlops 3y agoIndentured servitude is without pay by definition.
- asdasdsddd 3y agoPeople just want the vibes of words and phrases without the rigor
- Nifty3929 3y agoThat is not the case. Indentured servitude is labor that was paid for in advance by some service provided - e.g. passage to another country. Just because payment was received in the past, or that it was in-kind, doesn't mean the labor isn't paid labor.
- CPLX 3y agoYou can’t quit and walk away from indentured servitude.
- Nifty3929 3y agoPerhaps not, but that doesn't mean it's not paid for. And in any case, I'm sure the terms would have been different in different cases, and it probably was possible to quit if you were able to pay for your previously-rendered services in some other fashion. Of course, these are just details. Fundamentally, those indentured were held captive and forced to work. But that still doesn't make it unpaid, or involuntary for that matter. The bondage existed only to enforce the terms previously agreed to. I have no way to know, but I imagine many indentured servants were happy with the trade, though many also weren't. Lots of fraud too, with people being tricked into it. As I write, I can't help but think of student loans which have similar characteristics.
- lgleason 3y agoBefore the H1B really started to ramp up, you used to see foreigners working in IT that truly were some of the best and the brightest because there was a lot of competition and very few spots. These days, that is the exception, not the rule, because it was primarily designed to drive down wages so that CEO's can make larger salaries. The fact that they were able to convince people that reducing your own earning potential by giving the jobs to foreigners is the right thing to do morally shows how gullible/naive many in our industry are.
- jonfw 3y agoThe H1B guys may undercut US talent, but not by nearly as much as they undercut us when they're still living overseas! Countries like India are developing a lot of talent and most companies are building strategies to hire there. If we can bring the best talent over consistently, than they can help us to keep the standards highest in the US, and justify our salaries.
- denton-scratch 3y ago> EPI, for example, notes that American employers do not have to recruit US residents before hiring foreign H-1B workers, that it's legal for US employers to underpay H-1B workers, relatively speaking, and that H-1B workers are often exploited and lack job protection and mobility, among other issues. I think that, in the modern, immigrant-averse west, that's exactly how a worker visa system is supposed to work. * We don't have enough skilled workers, and employers think the ones we have are too expensive * Foreign countries have a glut of skilled workers, and are competing with our companies * So let's allow in a quota of foreign skilled workers, and let's let companies take the piss and underpay them. Profit! From the POV of the government (they can screw the quota down to placate nativists, and point to the fact that the visa workers are earning a lot less than the natives), and from the POV of the employers (they get a cheapo workforce). A better solution is to improve the education standard of the natives; but that would involve public expenditure, which is anathema to conservatives, to the press, and apparently (in the UK) it's also anathema to the Labour Party. I'm not an open borders wingnut; but I think expenditure on high-quality education is a vital investment in a country's future. We have some world-beating universities in the UK; but government policies have resulted in those institutions giving many of their places to overseas students, who pay a lot more. So we educate lots of foreigners, who then go back to where they came from, and then get hired on worker visas to come back and work here, e.g. as doctors and nurses, of which we have a dire shortage. Then we tighten the rules on worker visas, like banning them from bringing their kids with them.
- vishwanath1306 3y agoThe worst part about H1B and subsequent immigration policies is that it doesn't value your contribution to the country. Someone doing a PhD in the US is usually on an NSF/NIH/DARPA/<Govt agency> grant, and contributing to critical research here. If they choose to to go into industry (academia has uncapped H1B), then they go into the same pool as someone from India working some basic task with some IT Consulting company. Eventually, the PhD would need to leave despite the government spending close to half a million for their education. This is a huge waste of government resources, close to a billion plus dollars in a lot of cases.
- crappywappy 3y agoNever understood why I have worked with H1B at past companies where a local person would suffice. We were just making basic web services. H1B is so abused it's not even funny.
- nirav72 3y agoH1b program itself needs to be overhauled. It's entirely possible this might get addressed with change in the presidential administration starting next January 19th.