7 ms·
Death penalty for corruption? That seems barbaric. Then I read there are a few countries that impose capital punishment for non-violent crimes: China, Indonesi
by andsoitis 3y ago
Death penalty for corruption? That seems barbaric.
Then I read there are a few countries that impose capital punishment for non-violent crimes: China, Indonesia (some acts of corruption which "damage national economy or finances"), Morocco, Thailand (bribery), Vietnam (bribery).
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Capital_punishment_for_non-violent_offenses https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Capital_punishment_for_non-vio...
- shp0ngle 3y agoOn one hand it's Vietnam where everyone bribes everyone. (Literally. Stealing country funds is a fact of life.) On the other hand it's 21 billion. Still rough.
- Saigonautica 3y agoSome people here do pay bribes. I do not. Neither do most people around my age that I know. I immigrated here 12 years ago. I have a company license, a driving license, proper residency, and so on. I got every last piece of it by filling out forms, and waiting a normal amount of time. I speak Vietnamese like a small child and have no Vietnamese heritage. Perhaps some people will report something different, and perhaps they are also correct. However, this is my story.
- alephnerd 3y agoWe're Westerners so we're insulated from low level corruption because we can report to the Tourist Police and our local Consulate or Embassy, who will complain to that Quan's MPS. The kind of low level corruption your mentioning impacts the working class or middle class (the kind living in a 1 bedroom apartment in D10 with a Honda motorbike) because they have no recourse. That said, the mid-upper level corruption is very significant. How else do you see retired generals and senior party apparatchiks with a $50/mo pension eating steaks at the Landmark 81 and living in a villa in Thao Dien. And this is why my SO makes it a principle to always speak in English so she doesn't get Vietnamese service.
- EdwardDiego 3y agoQuick question, you talk about D1 / D10 etc. Are those postcodes or suburbs or something?
- refurb 3y ago> And this is why my SO makes it a principle to always speak in English so she doesn't get Vietnamese service. That's a general recommendation for any overseas Vietnamese (Viet Kieu) to just pretend not to speak Vietnamese any time they interact with officials. They'll never get aggressive and will usually move onto easier prey. But you are correct the low level corruption is common. A good story I heard was getting the household registration completed at the police station - bring in forms, call back "you forgot to sign this form", go back and sign the form, a couple weeks later you call "oh, it was actually the wrong form, come back", go back sign another form, a couple weeks later "it's not finished yet", a couple weeks later "you're missing one form". Finally, they go in, finish that form and say "hey, you've been working hard, let me buy you a coffee" and you slip them the equivalent of $10 USD (about 20x the cost of a coffee). Poof, magic, it's done the next day and the cop will even swing by your home to drop off the paperwork. A lot of the corruption is simply slow-rolling things until what the US Foreign Corrupt Practices Act calls "facilitation payments" are made.
- throwaway129900 3y agoBack when my family built our house a few years ago, we had to pay some bribe for a local officer to get our construction permission, otherwise it will get delayed for who knows how long. On paper, gov's officer's salary is <500usd a month, yet several provincial secretary own large houses and villas. Where does the money come from ? You see this stuff reported once in a while in Vietnamese newspaper, and stuff that are not reported could be worse. Amomg Vietnamese people, government's corruption is well known, happens at every level, and everybody I know is treating it as an open secret.
- doix 3y agoMy very limited experience with Vietnam officials was that you could avoid bribes, but it was much more convenient to just bribe them. I was going through the land border from Laos to Vietnam and was told to leave some "coffee money" in my passport on both sides of the border. I think it was either 20k or 50k Dong. Apparently if you did not do this, you would get seen last and they would stamp it perfectly diagonally in the middle of a fresh passport page to try and ruin that page. No idea if this was actually true because everyone just paid.
- notahacker 3y agoQuite a few in that part of the world impose it for international drug smuggling, and we're talking mules rather than kingpins here. And if you really want to be appalled, look at the ones where adultery or homosexuality are potentially capital crimes.
- wubrr 3y agoWhy is it more barbaric than death penalty for something like murder? How much damage would 27B in corruption cause to people and society?
- shp0ngle 3y agoEveryone steals in Vietnam. Every time the communists change positions in the politburo, the new communist in charge arrests the previous one for corruption. And so it goes. (Nguyen Xuan Phuc, the one who was hailed for zero covid previously, was later arrested for... stealing covid funds. Oh wow, who knew) There is 0 trust between actual people for the party. People just shut up because the economy is doing fine and people have jobs.
- monero-xmr 3y agoMy friend worked in Vietnam and Laos for several years. Every company had to hire a communist party member on staff who rarely showed up. When they did they would demand everyone go drinking, paid for by the company.
- kneel 3y agoCommunist parties sound like fun
- NoGravitas 3y agoAin't no party like a Communist party. The Communists have the music.
- Saigonautica 3y agoI own a company in Vietnam. I do not do this, and was never asked to do this. To the best of my knowledge, neither have any of my other colleagues that own businesses.
- monero-xmr 3y ago
- snapcaster 3y agoI kind of see it as the opposite of barbaric. Someone stealing billions of dollars has caused far far far more net harm than someone committing a one off violent crime. I guess roughly tying consequences to harm caused seems less barbaric to me
- IncreasePosts 3y agoShe owned more of a bank than she was supposed to, and used that bank to get bigger loans than she would normally be able to get, and then she bought commercial real estate with those loans. Where does the net harm come in here? I guess other mega rich property developers were prevented from acquiring the commercial real estate...maybe a few hundred millionaires were harmed by this billionaire. Is there anything more than that?
- pickleberto 3y ago[dead]
- nordsieck 3y ago> Where does the net harm come in here? The harm comes from the possible worlds where the loans don't get paid back. That's the reason why there are loan limits in the first place.
- TylerE 3y agoAlso if banks are loaning money to her, that's money that's not being loaned to other people.
- notaustinpowers 3y agoNot entirely. She used almost 1,000 fake loan applications to to appropriate the $12.5b from the bank. Then 3 employees at the bank committed suicide from October 6th-14th in 2022 which resulted in a bank run. There are 82 other defendents, many of them being leadership at the bank, with 5 of them in hiding.
- 3y ago
- ignoramous 3y ago> Death penalty for corruption? That seems barbaric. I think one can make an argument that death penalties themselves are barbaric given miscarriage of justice is a thing. And let's be honest, the electric chair is gruesome in the day and age of Nesdonal & Norcuron. To single out captial punishment for a capitalist crime as barbarism reeks of double standards just because there's no precedent for it in the West.
- tivert 3y ago> Death penalty for corruption? That seems barbaric. Honestly, I think it's fine, but only if reserved for billionaires. That kind of economic power breeds arrogance, which needs something to keep it in check. The quantity has a quality all its own. The death penalty is definitely not OK for low level people or the sums even a wealthy regular person could have. And I don't even think it should be an option for most violent crime, either.
- inglor_cz 3y agoIn places like Vietnam and China, billionaires aren't the "apex predators". The Party leadership is. That is why they can get the death penalty.
- bilbo0s 3y agoDon't get it twisted man. At least in China, they kill party leadership too. In fact, just to make sure no one is holding out on them, they'll take out your wife and mistress too. In China, the party is almighty, but it won't hesitate to eat it's young, it's parents, or even it's mate.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- xandrius 3y agoBasically you are ok for death penalty strictly for other people? Seems quite convenient :D I also am OK for 100% tax to anyone who's not me or my immediate family.
- tivert 3y ago> Basically you are ok for death penalty strictly for other people? Seems quite convenient :D Come on. Your objection is meaningless distraction, because it's so general it's an objection to any kind of punishment of anyone proposed by anyone who isn't themselves guilty.
- 3y ago
- tromp 3y agoDeath penalty seems inherently barbaric as in practice you cannot avoid executing people who are not found to be innocent until years or decades later. Even if you think guilt can be proven beyond any doubt, I know of no jurisdiction with an error-free record.
- eddd-ddde 3y agoSo you say it is barbaric not for executing someone, but for wrongly punishing someone. How is that different for a regular life sentence? Taking someone's liberties wrongly seems just as barbaric.
- tromp 3y agoAt least you can return their freedom and try to compensate them for the time unjustly spent in prison.
- keybored 3y agoI don’t know the specific of this case or what they do in East and South-East Asia. But we’ve had these discussions before. The point then is raised: say you have a white collar crime that downstream causes life-crippling financial misery for tens of thousands of people. On what grounds can one dismiss capital punishment for that crime as barbaric but then (presumably, by omission) not find that capital punishment for cold-blooded murder is barbaric?
- pavlov 3y agoYou’re leaving out a lot of countries that impose death penalties for non-violent acts that are victimless and not even crimes in the West. For example adultery and apostasy: “The following countries impose the death penalty for adultery: Afghanistan, Brunei,[1] Iran, Maldives, Mauritania, Nigeria, Pakistan[citation needed], Saudi Arabia, Somalia, Yemen, Sudan, Qatar.” ”As of July 2020, apostasy by Muslims (ridda) carries the death penalty in the following countries: Afghanistan, Brunei, Iran, the Maldives, Mauritania, Qatar, Saudi Arabia, Somalia (implicitly), the United Arab Emirates, and Yemen.” This is the height of state-sanctioned barbarism left in today’s world.
- mavili 3y agoAs it happens quite often, you're mistaken about the apostasy part, don't know about the adultery one. Apostasy itself isn't punishable; it's when someone "deflects" to the enemy side and colludes with them. At that point it's the 'treason' aspect that carries the punishment, not because someone says they don't believe in something anymore.
- Ylpertnodi 3y agoUSA still has the death penalty?
- hollerith 3y ago
- huytersd 3y agoI don’t know whether it’s warranted but corruption is the primary reasons a lot of these third world countries have such a hard time pulling themselves out of the hole. The damage they cause to millions of lives is probably way more impactful than some two bit murderer.
- spxneo 3y agoIsn't wiping out 42,000 families livelihood or 3% of your country's GDP not barbaric? Or is the exchange rate here not favourable to your standards?
- koala_man 3y agoSome US states would hand down a mandatory lifetime sentence to someone robbing three families, but no jail time for someone robbing 42,000.
- blago 3y agoThe prevailing opinion is that the death penalty was handed down to provide leverage and incentivize restitution.
- Saigonautica 3y agoThat's always been my understanding as well. I recall some cases in the last few years where this resulted in quite a bit of the funds being recovered. Sadly I cannot remember the specific cases.
- mavili 3y agoThere we go again, a western "civilised" citizen calling a sentence barbaric because it was passed by a nation they don't like. It's called justice dude. You seem to belittle 'corruption' but it's actually root of a lot of evil.
- kak3a 3y agocorruption or death penalty is barbaric?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- nimbius 3y agoAccording to prosecutors, over a period of three years from February 2019, she ordered her driver to withdraw 108 trillion Vietnamese dong, more than $4bn (£2.3bn) in cash from the bank, and store it in her basement. The verdict requires her to return $27bn, a sum prosecutors said may never be recovered. she stole around 2% of Vietnam's GDP annually. You just can’t move this kind of money without the government noticing. She most likely fell out of favour for some other reason with the ruling party. moreover, Viet Nam is a communist country. It may seem difficult for western capitalists to reconcile since "victimless" and "non-violent" are the litmus for most prosecutions but sentencing the bourgeoise to the death penalty for embezzlement is absolutely in keeping with the party line and doctrine. in 2008 the PRC had a tainted milk scandal, during which time it tried, sentenced, and executed two high level corporate executives for the fraud.
- maxglute 3y ago> 108 trillion Vietnamese dong, more than $4bn (£2.3bn) in cash from the bank, and store it in her basement For personal curiosity, largest dong note is 500k , that's 208 million bills. Very lazy Theydidthemath attempt but 500k dong is ~$20 USD. If you look up visiualizations of how much 1B of 100 USD notes are, usually palletized, 1B USD is 12 pallets. 1T dong is 60 pallets. Her driver moved 120 pallets of dongs in her basement. ~480ft x 480ft / ~146m x 146m square tiled.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- madaxe_again 3y agoHonestly, I think these are the varieties of crimes where capital punishment should apply - while a violent offender might be one day rehabilitated, someone who feels it’s ok to loot billions at the expense of their fellow man deserves to suffer schaphism. The harm is infinitely greater - and we seemingly live in a world where this behaviour is more often than not rewarded with high office and plaudits.
- kazinator 3y agoI have a different perspective. If someone commits fraud to the tune of $27B, that mainly means they just outfoxed rich people out of their money. A lot more harm lies in a legally made $27B.
- Saigonautica 3y agoWithout this intending to be a comment on whether it is just or not, there's an interesting caveat to the law that might be of interest. De jure, here's an amount that the guilty party can repay to avoid the death penalty. I recall it being 3/4 of the amount stolen.
- virtualritz 3y ago> Death penalty for corruption? That seems barbaric. I find this a 'curious' pov. If financial fraud is affecting savings of many thousands of people, where savings = lifetime spent toiling, a view one may dare take is that there is little difference in killing someone (essentially robbing them of the leftover lifetime). In a country like Vietnam, where about 13% of people pay into pensions at all [1], loosing your savings literally will shorten your life. Even if you're in those 13% btw, as you can't live off state-pensions[2]. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pensions_in_Vietnam#Funding https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pensions_in_Vietnam#Funding [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pensions_in_Vietnam#State_non-contributory_pensions https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pensions_in_Vietnam#State_non-... EDIT: I like to add that I am against death penalty under any circumstances. But if you're in the US and are ok with death penalty there, I'd argue you should be, too, in the case at hand.
- hinkley 3y agoAs someone else said, she stole 6.6% of the GDP
- BizarroLand 3y agoThe equivalent in America would be 1.68 trillion dollars, which is 70 million dollars shy of the total amount of outstanding student loan debt in America. I feel like if you only polled people who owe more in student loan debt than they make in a year if they would push a button to allow the single person who stole 1.68 trillion dollars to be executed by the state in exchange for 96% of their student loan debt vanishing into thin air (but being 1/(number of agreeing people) responsible for her death) then chances are they're pushing that button.
- yeknoda 3y agoDeath penalty serves multiple purposes 1. Remove from society, with no additional cost to society. 2. Signaling to dissuade new offenders. You can go one step further and punish the family, parents, and friends. Seems to be happening in the US for underage mass killers. It’s a simple, effective, and low cost way to deal with crime of the highest magnitude. Why should it be off limits for corruption?
- kazinator 3y agoAny component of a punishment that is intended to deter is wrong. They hypothetical future offenders supposedly being deterred by the punishment are not parties in the defendant's case. Therefore they have no place in the sentencing. Death penalty should be: take a life, pay with your life. There is no need to consider deterrence in any shape or form. The concept of deterrence being a reason for capital punishment only bolsters anti-capital-punishment arguments.
- esafak 3y agoThat's not right. Deterrence establishes a causal link between the punished and the criminals of tomorrow, who consider the likely outcome of their crime before committing it.
- kazinator 3y agoPunishments have a side effect of deterring. People don't wish to be punished so they don't transgress. It shouldn't be the focus of punishment. One problem is that the severity of punishment can be varied in order to vary the deterrent effect, whereas the punishment should fit the crime. That a certain fair punishment is not sufficiently deterring others is immaterial to a given defendant. Fair punishments may deter insufficiently. The deterrent effect involves the probability of being caught and convicted. A law enforcement and criminal justice system that is not effective at catching and convicting can just crank up penalties to keep the deterrent effect high.
- EdwardDiego 3y agoWell point #2 is obviously not working, and it makes sense, how many murderers are making rational decisions? Also, who would be deterred by the risk of execution, but not deterred by the risk of a life sentence? Claiming harsh sentencing is a deterrent is a convenient cover for the real reason - it's about revenge. Because it very obviously isn't a deterrent, at least, not an effective one. Unless US states that execute people have dramatically lower rates of murder than states that don't, in which case, I'm wrong and stand corrected. Guess it depends which of rehabilitation or punishment you value most.
- CatWChainsaw 3y agoCorruption is barbaric.
- squokko 3y agoStealing 6% of a large country's GDP causes more aggregate harm than murdering ten individuals (which would be an obvious death penalty case).
- moomoo11 3y agoDo you think people’s retirement accounts, livelihoods, and service meant for society wasn’t affected by crimes like this? I’m from a third world. We were victims ourselves of some asshole who took our money and disappeared. Even in US our first immigration lawyer stole 18k from us which is a big deal when my dad was only making 30k. “Just sue them” easy to say when you’re rich. If you want to host these awful parasites at your house go ahead. But I bet you won’t. You probably never had to suffer so be glad. As a member of society I think people should who don’t want to contribute to it by engaging in truly heinous crimes (and yes I believe destroying people’s livelihoods by stealing their hard owned money in a malicious scheme is as bad killing or r working someone) should not be allowed to further leech resources after their awful behavior.