4 ms·
Disclaimer/confession: I happen to be the author. That may not be obvious but it is also no secret. I posted it as my contribution to the general ongoing HN dis
by Mz 15y ago
Disclaimer/confession: I happen to be the author. That may not be obvious but it is also no secret. I posted it as my contribution to the general ongoing HN discussion of issues like women in tech and related stuff that shows up here.
Enjoy. Or not.
Thanks.
- jerrya 15y agoI enjoyed it, and I try to stay away from the gender stuff at HN because it is often trite in part due to the issue you are talking about. First though, I do think in Aliens, that part of the mens' and the audience's enjoyment and celebration with Ripley that she ran that loader so well is because she is a woman, so in that respect, it is sexist (woman shows disbelieving men and audience). (It might also otherwise be because she's been in cryosleep for decades and unused to loaders, or just that she does her job so well.) (Also, there are times I really hate Chekhov's gun, but that scene has never been one of them.) And one of the aspects of gender discussions on the web I find annoying is in fact that at many such discussions the male commenters getting the most applause are actually often very sexist, condescending, white knighting, patronizing, cheerleading, and fact free commenters (and that are probably clueless as to their own actual behaviors. (cf. Hugo Schwyzer) For the sake of your essay you categorize men in two groups: Men who don’t much like me or who are subtly trying to keep women out of a male-dominated area or some such but who are basically decent, professional people who don’t stoop to personal attacks and ugliness. In contrast, well-meaning, supportive nice guys are frequently maddening in their boundless ability to pave a road to hell with good intentions. My fear is that you and others default to perceiving the men from Aliens, and in fact, many men, as belonging to the first group. But you can see that Apone and Hicks aren't in either of those groups. One take away from your discoveries is that maybe you should reconsider the nature of the word "enemy" and what it means to be an enemy or friend, because Apone and Hicks, and people that take you seriously and engage in an intellectual argument with you (and fight with you) are probably your friends in ways that the trite cheerleaders rah rahing you for your gender are not. I am not sure what the relationship of your essay is to "Hacker News". Written as is, I think it would be better suited to a variety of feminist and men's blogs, including the Good Men Project. Best wishes,
- Mz 15y agoThank you for your long, thought out reply. However, I tried to carefully qualify my statements. Please note the use of phrases like "tend to be". It isn't possible to put forth ideas without trying to generalize somewhat. Unfortunately, generalizations frequently then get misinterpretted as bias as well. FWIW: I like the scene so much in part because my father and ex husband were both career military. I don't see Hicks or Apone as her enemies. I like the blunt nature of military culture. I do not read such bluntness as "hostility". I just chose to leave out additional thoughts on that aspect of it because I felt it would be an extraneous (thus distracting) tangent which would take a lot away from my point rather than add value. Edited for accuracy and typos.
- nhebb 15y ago> I do think in Aliens, that part of the mens' and the audience's enjoyment and celebration with Ripley that she ran that loader so well is because she is a woman, so in that respect, it is sexist Also known as "the soft bigotry of low expectations".
- jerf 15y ago"First though, I do think in Aliens, that part of the mens' and the audience's enjoyment and celebration with Ripley that she ran that loader so well is because she is a woman, so in that respect, it is sexist (woman shows disbelieving men and audience)." While I broadly agree with that analysis, I would point out that's a metanarrative analysis. In the context of the narrative itself I believe Mz's analysis is accurate. And you gotta start there. The metanarrative unavoidably has elements of the real world in it and the way it changes is with people choosing and accepting other narratives over time. I say this because I think in general sometimes people can overanalyze things like this, and the danger there is that sufficient "analysis" can turn anything into anything else. (Which is the core fallacy of postmodernism in an information theory nutshell.) It is unavoidably a product of its time and culture, but irreducibly, it is merely what it is, as well. Too many people get so caught up in the former they forget the latter.