7 ms·
Starting today, ISPs must display labels with price, speeds, and data caps
- LorenDB 3y agoWhy does that label look like it came off a cereal box? I legitimately thought that picture might be a joke of somebody riffing on the nutrition facts label.
- dan-g 3y agoProbably for that exact reason—consumers are familiar with the format, and know that something with that particular design is to be trusted—I.e. as a part of some governmental regulation.
- dartos 3y agoIt’s clear, legible, standardized, and easily recognizable as a form of compliance information relevant to a consumer (much like nutrition labels)
- Funes- 3y agoIs the format used in anything other than nutrition labels (and ISP labels, from now on)? It also struck me as odd.
- p1mrx 3y agoLighting Facts: https://www.ftc.gov/business-guidance/resources/ftc-lighting-facts-label-questions-answers-manufacturers https://www.ftc.gov/business-guidance/resources/ftc-lighting...
- throw0101a 3y agoI'd really like it if we moved our ways to using lumens more on light bulb packaging instead of "100W" or "60W" on LEDs: I understand why it was done in the past, but we're getting to the point that there's an entire generation of folks who have had no experience with incandescent bulbs.
- NeoTar 3y agoThere is the wonderful figure on light bulb packaging in the EU which attempts to express how much energy the light bulb will use in a year (defined at 1000hours of usage)... It's given as XXX kWh/1000h ... which if you're at all familiar with units can be simplified to just... XXX Watts. Plus ca change...
- imzadi 3y agoI think it's intentional. Nutrition labels are familiar and also effective in providing a lot of data in a small space.
- dghlsakjg 3y agoUniversal standardized design is a feature. That label is accesible, easily compared across brands, and makes it hard to hide undesirable terms.
- toomuchtodo 3y ago> The labels are required now for providers with at least 100,000 subscribers, while ISPs with fewer customers have until October 10, 2024, to comply. "If a provider is not displaying their labels or has posted inaccurate information about its fees or service plans, consumers can file a complaint with the FCC Consumer Complaint Center," an agency webpage says. https://consumercomplaints.fcc.gov/hc/en-us https://consumercomplaints.fcc.gov/hc/en-us https://www.fcc.gov/broadbandlabels https://www.fcc.gov/broadbandlabels https://www.fcc.gov/document/what-look-new-broadband-nutrition-labels https://www.fcc.gov/document/what-look-new-broadband-nutriti... EDIT: @windexh8er Doing God's work. Many thanks.
- windexh8er 3y agoAhh, yes - Mediacom decided they're not going to do it. Filing a complaint now.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- jabroni_salad 3y agoSo typical for mediacom, always at the forefront of the industry's worst practices. They were one of the first to bring in bandwidth caps and search redirects as well. Metronet is finally turning on my street next week and I'm not gonna look back even if it means dealing with a cgnat and having all of my traffic go out of chicago instead of minneapolis.
- toomuchtodo 3y agoMetronet does do cgnat, but the service is excellent at the price point (I manage someone's resi connection in their service area; $70/month for 1G symmetric service with no caps). When I call technical support, I get someone who can talk fiber light levels all the way up the OSI stack. You will not regret switching to them. I don't get paid to say nice things about them!
- xenospn 3y agoThank you, government, for making our lives better.
- numbers 3y agoIt looks like CenturyLink doesn’t have it on their website, can someone confirm this maybe I just can’t find it? I’m going to file a complaint.
- fifteen1506 3y ago[flagged]
- imzadi 3y agoAsk who? Have you ever tried contacting any of these companies for anything? You get a run around, sit on hold for an hour, and when you do get a human they don't speak English and have no idea what they are talking about. The sales people will tell you anything just to get their commission.
- fifteen1506 3y agohttps://gethuman.com/ https://gethuman.com/
- fifteen1506 3y agoOk, tbh I'm just a troublemaker implementing Aahz's Law. Anyway, those calls should definitely be recorded by the client. While accountability isn't brought back in full scale, GrapheneOS allows recording.
- redserk 3y agoAnd what's the next step you're proposing with said data? Your post suggests you believe you're the first person to think of this idea. This has regularly been a complaint among utility/service agencies at the state level, a regular complaint to the FTC, a regular complaint to the FCC, and a regular complaint to local, state, and national politicians.
- Bilal_io 3y ago> What? You want to know the fees you ask for the fees. If you are not wise enough to ask maybe you deserve to be scammed by legitimate companies. This is like walking into a grocery store and no seeing their prices, if you're interested in milk prices, you gotta ask an employee. If you're not wise enough to ask maybe you deserve to be charged extra.
- kbolino 3y ago
- Funes- 3y agoWhat about a list of blocked sites? Many ISPs are in cahoots with governments and corporations to block sites without ever notifying their clients, and I'm sure the US is no exception.
- JumpCrisscross 3y ago> ISPs are in cahoots with governments and corporations to block sites without ever notifying their clients, and I'm sure the US is no exception It is. We have the First Amendment. If you have examples to the contrary, I’m incredibly curious to see it.
- Funes- 3y agoTrying to visit Library Genesis or Sci-Hub throws me a 451 error ("File unavailable For Legal Reasons"), for instance. Monoskop.org couldn't be loaded either some months ago and I had to go through the Tor browser to visit it, as well. These aren't violating any law in the European country in which I reside.
- JumpCrisscross 3y ago> Library Genesis or Sci-Hub throws me a 451 error libgen.li and sci-hub.se loaded for me fine. > aren't violating any law in the European country in which I reside No clue. These labels are for the United States. Our government can’t tell ISPs to block a site.
- kbolino 3y agoThat's (very likely) server-side blocking based on IP geolocation, not ISP blocking.
- Funes- 3y agoAbsolutely not. There are some ISPs left in the country that aren't blocking access to those very sites. I mean, I was accessing them no problem until I switched providers. That's precisely how I found out they were blocking them.
- otterpro 3y agoWe should have labels like this for web hosting service, cable tv providers, cell phone providers, etc... I've been trying to get a web hosting service, but everything has a fine print on price with asterisk. It took me awhile to figure out that dreamhost's rate is $2.59/month, but will renew at $8?/month. On certain vendors, I didn't even know how much I'd end up paying, until nearly at the end of payment step where there's a tiny fine-print somewhere buried with gray font that's barely readable.
- coldpie 3y agoHuh, I've been with a small handful of different webhosts over the decades and never had that experience. They've all just had their prices up front (modulo taxes), no balloon policies or whatever junk. Sounds like Dreamhost is being scummier than average.
- NeoTar 3y agoHow about for subscriptions in general? Both virtual and physical (e.g. a gym membership)? At the very least, a regulation could say that for any promotional rate, the duration of the promotion, and the non-promotional rate must be shown at equal prominence (i.e. the same colour, background, font and size).
- eastbound 3y agoWouldn’t you say that AWS prices are obscure? Or, if AWS prices are clear (but inaccessible for people with no prior knowledge), then an ISP could charge “$.46 by million .css, $.78 per million .js”.
- p1mrx 3y agoInteresting, Comcast now has 115/24 for $30/month, and the only tier with faster upload is 1300/40 for $126/month. I generally shop for DOCSIS service based on the upload speed, so Comcast will get a lot cheaper when my current contract expires. Edit: oops, "Internet Essentials" is only for people on Medicaid or similar assistance. My cheapest no-contract option is 175/24 for $56/month after the paperless discount. In any case, they doubled the upload speed for that plan because the feds raised the definition of broadband from 25/3 to 100/20.
- jrochkind1 3y agothat's almost certainly an introductory rate. Look at the label to see! Are you talking fiber or cable? I only have access to cable, not fiber. If you can really get fiber for $30/month non-introductory, I'm jealous -- where I am (I think comcast currently has different eastern and western US prices, but is otherwise standardized), cable broadband the _cheapest_ plan available (without qualifying for income limits on "essentials" plan) is $68/month non-introductory price. Advertised as "150", but the new lable claims "typical" speeds of 176 down 115 up.. which is... way more "up" than they've ever advertised before, odd.
- jrochkind1 3y agoI hadn't heard about this, but I went to comcast with an incognito browser and claimed to be a new customer -- and indeed these are next to plans (you do have to click through to detail page). This is actually great. Comcast is my only available broadband provider, and I've been trying to figure out how to switch to a cheaper plan, but haven't actually been a able to figure out the post-introductory rates on the plans before, and the customer service/retention people put you on hold at random times designed to somehow influence you to pay more and give you confusing answers. Now it's clear. I can switch from 300Mbps I don't need to 150MBps that is fine, and save $30/month, great. (I think comcast still won't let you switch to a CHEAPER internet plan without talking to a human, you can't do it self-serve).
- tacocataco 3y agoCorporations get away with so much by hiding the ability to resolve conflicts behind customer service hell.
- hansvm 3y agoAlso, switching plans starts a new contract.
- jrochkind1 3y agoThe plans I am looking at are contract-free, but definitely something to be aware of -- and clearly specified on the new labels! The lower-end cable broadband xfinity plans all seem to be advertised no-contract, it's only once you get to 800mbs down that there is a contract. ($70 month introductory rate, 12 month contract, $110/month non-introductory rate. Funny that they let you out of the contract right when your introductory rate expires?)
- CharlesW 3y agoIt can (and so that's a valuable call out), but I've been able to switch internet service tiers multiple times without a new or extended contract.
- 3y ago
- kasperset 3y agoStep in the right direction. I like that they included upload speed, latency and not just download speed.
- dtnewman 3y agoAbout time. I once went to sign up for internet with what looked like a great rate, let’s say $30/month (i don’t remember exactly). After fifteen minutes on the phone as we are wrapping up the agent says “ok, so do you authorize me to charge your credit card 47.99/month?” I reply that i thought it was $30, to which she says taxes (unfortunately it’s standard practice to exclude taxes in US advertised prices, but at least the amount is not under their control) plus a $12/month “delivery fee”, to which I replied that I’d like to pick up my internet access myself thank you , so can we waive that one? I ended up hanging up and just finding a provider with a slightly higher price but no BS. If you want to charge more for modems and other optional stuff, fine, but when you start adding fees that aren’t really distinguishable from the product itself, you merit this kind of regulation. I pray, please go after car dealerships next.
- kstrauser 3y agoAmen. If it’s something the vendor is adding themselves, it’s the price, not a fee.
- pants2 3y agoT-Mobile is the site I can find the actual nutrition-label-type info. Can we get another website that aggregates all the labels into one explorer?
- mdaniel 3y agoI would think that broadbandreports.com would benefit from that (they have now evidently consolidated on the more misleading https://www.dslreports.com/ https://www.dslreports.com/ url)
- tacocataco 3y agoWe should have nationalized the big ISPs when they stole the billions set aside for rolling out fiber. If only corporations had repercussions for their malicious behavior. Maybe some day.
- kstrauser 3y agoMy long-term tilting at windmills ambition is to require companies to express data caps in terms of time you’re allowed to use your connection. For example, say Comcast has a 1Gb service with a 1TB data cap. You could hit that limit in about 8,000 seconds, or about 2.5 hours. In my mind, Comcast should be required to advertise that as “one gigabit for up to 2.5 hours”. I know that ISPs oversell. That’s fair and reasonable. No ISP would build out their network as though every customer were using 100% capacity 24x7. The degree of overselling we see today with ridiculously low data caps is just obscene.
- thanksgiving 3y ago> I know that ISPs oversell. That’s fair and reasonable. No ISP would build out their network as though every customer were using 100% capacity 24x7. The degree of overselling we see today with ridiculously low data caps is just obscene. My conspiracy theory is this is NOT overselling or over subscription but a coordinated attempt to shape consumer behavior away from online streaming toward their own offering that is not subject to the data cap such as cable television. How come frontier does not have data caps but Comcast Xfinity does? Why does Comcast Xfinity not have data caps specifically where they have competitors? This is not anything official, just a thought.
- kstrauser 3y agoI don’t think that’s much of a conspiracy. See “zero rating”: “you pay to stream from those mean leeches at Netflix, but our wonderful service doesn’t count against you!”
- JumpCrisscross 3y ago> No ISP would build out their network as though every customer were using 100% capacity 24x7 My FCC data label says unlimited.
- kstrauser 3y agoMine too. Our ISPs didn’t build their infrastructure as though each customer would be maxing out their connection at all times. It does mean they have a good idea of how fat their pipes need to be to support the traffic loads they see on their graphs. Then they buy enough capacity to meet those needs, plus some safety margin. For instance, if all customers had 1Gb service and peak usage on their end is everyone streaming Netflix at 40Mbps at 8PM, it would be prohibitively expensive for them to buy the capacity to support every customer downloading at 1Gb simultaneously when 40Mb is only 4% of that.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- Night_Thastus 3y agoI just tested it, it works fantastic. I cannot tell you how thrilled I am with this. It's all the information I wanted in a very clear format. Recently when migrating service, Comcast told me the plan I was on didn't exist anymore and they had an alternate plan with higher speed for less money. However, they refused to say what it would cost after the "introductory period". Without knowing that I could not agree. Now, I know exactly and can actually decide if I want it!
- ChrisArchitect 3y agoOfficial post: https://www.fcc.gov/document/consumer-broadband-labels-now-required-nationwide-points-sale https://www.fcc.gov/document/consumer-broadband-labels-now-r...
- aj7 3y agoI’ve asked this before. I’ve noticed if my speed is slow, and I test it a few times, (I usually use the Netflix-owned site,) my speed rapidly improves. Do ISP’s throttle service, DETECT your visit to speed testing sites, and THEN speed things up?
- JimiofEden 3y agoIs there a clear definition of 'typical' when it comes to the speeds/latency - e.g., should I expect this on a p95 level at my residence for the contract? I ask because I'm paying for a service advertising itself as 500mbps down/10 mbps up/latency 14ms, but I have never in my 3 years of paying for it seen that level of performance. Running a `networkquality` test right now on ethernet reveals about 159 down/2.0 up/latency 50ms, which is closer to what I've come to expect on any given run On top of that, if the confines of 'typical' are broken on the side of the provider, would this just be an fcc complaint? More than happy to track this over the course of a month and provide data to back up my findings
- Night_Thastus 3y agoThe trouble is that there are a lot of situations that could be causing that. Is the coax line leading to your house in good condition? Is your ISP performing some kind of maintenance on their local infrastructure? How new is your modem and what does it support? What about your router? Ethernet cables or wifi? What about the computer that's interfacing with it, is that the bottleneck? Is all the relevant firmware up to date? What is connected to your network and what is it doing? I have high end networking equipment that's all kept up-to-date and I generally get a bit higher than what is advertised. If you have poor quality or old modem and router, they're never going to be able to handle 500 mbps down.
- bochoh 3y agoFor Spectrum to find the broadband facts you have to go through the order process and then a "Show Broadband Label" will show up on the internet package selection. Buried pretty deep. Edit: There is also a little bit of a dark pattern. The price shows 49.99/mo for 12 mos with auto pay, but the Broadband Facts sheet shows price at $84.99 and says "This monthly price is not an introductory rate". Very shady from my (only) option for ISP. Edit2: [Dark pattern](https://imgur.com/a/FktbVuV https://imgur.com/a/FktbVuV)
- a1371 3y agoI absolutely love that they look a lot like food labels. It's a consumer friendly choice and is instantly recognizable.
- uconnectlol 3y agohow was this not just an exercise of checking the law or amending it for fraud / false advertising with a result like, "a service has to state the actual cost up front and not require the person to calculate a bunch of stuff in his head with 5 equations for 10 competitors before he can even compare them". you can't say "$30/mo" and then put a star once you click 3 pages deep saying "(for the first 3 months)", because that makes it practically impossible for the buyer to compare prices, gating it behind some stupid fucking address entry form that breaks 80% of the time. it's simple fraud and nothing else. you write: "price: $30/mo and then $70/mo after the first 3 months" and i bet FCC spent 100 million dollars making this and can you even access these food labels before entering your address? (and why is it not mandated that they provide a list of zones and prices per zone?) a number like "total latency" is just complete nonsense, as its not a real metric that can fit in one number, and the kind of number marketers love to abuse. and nothing about what kind of modem the ISP is compatible with. is it cable, adsl, fiber? wifi extender and battery backup? because someone in FCC needed to work his full shift so he added those during his time? i'm not going to compare isps based on what random bullshit they bundle in, i only care about the actual service. anything more than 3 variables is too much. modem rental is important since they fucked up the chance of having open standards so hard that most people practically have to rent a modem. i guess FCC can't be blamed, they aren't techies or whatever.
- imzadi 3y agoI recently switched to Wyyerd. I don't see the labels on their site anywhere, but maybe they are under the 100k threshold.